Storing Long Term Kiln Dried Wood
don stephan
Wondering how long kiln dried wood can be stored in unheated barn in the Midwest without having the moisture content climbing more than 1-2%?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Storing Long Term Kiln Dried Wood
don stephan
Wondering how long kiln dried wood can be stored in unheated barn in the Midwest without having the moisture content climbing more than 1-2%?
Depends on the season
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
Wood responds to ambient humidity. Moisture content in your example will go down in the winter, up in the summer. How fast? Not sure.
Re: Storing Long Term Kiln Dried Wood
Dick Coers
Top boards won't take long to change, probably less than a month in the wrong time of year. Middle boards much longer. Wrap it all in plastic sheeting, and tape up the seams, way longer.
Re: Storing Long Term Kiln Dried Wood
Bill Tindall
days if it is a single board with good exposure. But so what? Where ever it gets moved to it will equillibrate up and down to that location.
Re: Storing Long Term Kiln Dried Wood
Grant in Iowa
Don,
The answer is: It depends. It depends on the humidity and air movement in the space the lumber is stored. It depends on if there is a concrete floor, or a damp dirt floor. It depends on how big and tightly packed the stack of lumber is. It depends on how much of a given board is exposed to the air.
But the real thing to consider is what moisture content do you want your lumber to be at when you use it?
When we kiln dry lumber, we do so for some valid reasons. Kiln drying, when done properly, can uniformly dry woodworking lumber to a usable moisture content much sooner than air drying. It can (in the right kiln) raise the temperature of the stack of lumber to a level to which pests are killed. It can set the pitch in certain woods if the right temperature is reached. It can lower the moisture content of lumber to where it won't mildew or stain more quickly. It can lower the moisture content of a stack of lumber to where insects won't infest it readily. In a steam kiln, it can turn certain woods such as walnut a more uniform color, which makes it easier to find matching boards for a project.
As you seem to already know, it will NOT keep the lumber moisture stable for its lifetime. Experts will point out that some cellular changes do take place, which may or may not mean the boards are more stable. But the boards will still eventually equilibriate to the climate they are in, despite the efforts of those who sought out kiln dried lumber...and despite multi coat finishing. And during that equilibriating process, they'll expand or contract
I have known guys who took wood back to be redried simply because their stack of kiln dried lumber had sat around in their shop for a year and had equilibriated. They wanted to build with it, so they took it to be redried to below 8% again. Folly, in my opinion.
So what is the value of kiln drying? Modern "techie" woodworkers will pay more for kiln dried lumber for some reason. Mostly because they've been told or have read to look for kiln dried lumber. And they've been told to look for KD lumber in the 6-8% range most times. And curiously this figure is standard in most all geographic areas, despite widely varying climates. Someone please explain why this is so important.
I would submit that what you really want to do is get the lumber equilibriated to the climate in which it will live the rest of its days...the climate of the home the project will be in ultimately. Why build with 6% mc wood when it will live in a home that (in my midwestern case) will be in the 10-12% range? This just means your building techniques will need to accomodate more movement than otherwise necessary. In my opinion, it is best to start a project with wood at its future moisture content. I try to condition my shop similar to my home. This is where my dried lumber lives.
As you might surmise by my thoughts, I seldom kiln dry lumber. The process has its place, and is indeed a fairly good way for a novice to ensure that the wood they are buying is properly dried. And as I have said above, it has other benefits, such as bug killing and setting pitch. One must be aware, however, that lumber can be ruined in a kiln if it is not operated smartly.
I have fallen victim to a local sawyer who "speed dries" his lumber, proudly presenting the lumber I had him saw a mere 35 days after I took him the logs. He got to reduce his inventory and get paid quicker. I got 600 board feet of case hardened cherry out of the deal. Lesson learned. Not saying it isn't possible to dry lumber quickly, but the risks of less than ideal lumber increase as the drying time decreases.
It has been a while since I have posted, maybe over a year. Just in case the science of lumber drying has changed, I encourage those who have counterpoints to post and explain. We all learn from differing viewpoints.
Regards,
Grant in Iowa
Re: Storing Long Term Kiln Dried Wood
Sgian Dubh
"And they've been told to look for KD lumber in the 6-8% range most times. And curiously this figure is standard in most all geographic areas, despite widely varying climates. Someone please explain why this is so important.
Grant, not all geographical regions or jurisdictions aim for a target wood MC of 7% MC ±2%. Here in the UK the target is about 11% MC. The 7% MC target (I think) is primarily a North American thing.
My understanding of the 7% MC target is that this allows for a bit of moisture regain between kilning and the manufacture of the furniture at the large plants in the US, and presumably elsewhere now where large scale manufacturing is undertaken primarily for the North American market. Slainte.
to answer your question
Bill Tindall
"And curiously this figure is standard in most all geographic areas, despite widely varying climates. Someone please explain why this is so important."
Most hardwood lumber is manufactured here in the Appalachian Mt. region and then shipped worldwide. Sawmills are hundred or more thousand bdft/day capacity and kiln capacity several hundred thousand bdft capacity. It is not practical to dry for some micro market. The 7% specification results in lumber that all the main world wide customers can use for the products they make. So, if all their lumber is dried to 7% any customer that needs lumber from their inventory can use it, worldwide.
I lived in southern MN for three years. The indoor humidity in the winter was essentially zero. Lumber is not going to be 12 % MC under these conditions. We sold lumber for 25 yeas here in TN. Be assured that we stay humid longer than the upper midwest. Our lumber in inventory never reached 12 %. If it did our customers would have rejected it. 12% lumber is problematic to glue. It will glue but clamp times are greatly longer(according to Franklin technical adhesives manual), something a furniture factory would not find attractive.
Oak is the most difficult lumber to dry. A properly operated modern kiln can (and often does) dry 4/4 oak from log to 7% in 30 days. Poplar can be done in a few days and cherry not much more than poplar. Personally, I have never seen a drying defect in cherry. It is so easy to dry that it is difficult to screw it up.
Europe target is also 7% according to source
Bill Tindall
This subject came up once before and at the time I asked a major exporter (Gilbert Hardwoods) whether lumber dried for export was different. " No", was the answer. All their lumber is dried to 7%.
I have since become acquainted with the person that manages inventory at an even larger exporter. I will ask there and report back.
Re: Europe target is also 7% according to source
Sgian Dubh
Bill, I'm not suggesting that North American kiln operators dry to a different MC target for the European market. I said that British kiln operators, and I think also the mainland European kiln operators, dry to 11% MC±. I believe there may be talk over here of changing the target MC to a lower figure. The figure my tentative research so far indicates is 8% MC. I've yet to find a reliable source to confirm that to be the case, but I'm still digging. Slainte.
Re: Storing Long Term Kiln Dried Wood
Barry Irby
It is my understanding that lumber exposed to air equilabrates at a moisture content (MC) that is about one fifth of the Relative Humidity (RH) of the surrounding air. This is based on research about lumber in crawl spaces.
I am a Home Inspector and was looking into why there is mold on the lumber in crawl spaces and what conditions were necessary for it to rot. Research indicates softwood will not rot until there is some free water in the cells and that is well above 20% MC. So since RH cannot go above 100% and one fifth of that is 20% and below the threshold for rot, you would think floor joists would not rot, but they do. So things that happen must be possible. I can explain the phenomenon, but I have gotten off topic.
But this is vaguely true for hardwood lumber also even though there are a lot of variables. But is your lumber is at 6% and your RH is near 30% it probably won't change much. In air conditioned houses the RH is probably somewhat higher in summer and in much of the country in heated buildings it probably lower in winter, especially without humidification.
This is one reason hardwood floor is often installed in rather narrow planks. A five percent change in the width of a 2 1/4" board is much less noticeable that it would be in a eleven inch wide plank. Wooden flooring does much better in "conditioned" houses that in ones without central heat or AC.
Re: Storing Long Term Kiln Dried Wood
don stephan
The reason for my question - a couple people this fall have said they need to cut down and have sawn into lumber quite a few logs, one person cherry and another ash. I've always been told air drying will only take lumber down to 12%, and boards should be 7% to be used inside a conditioned space (i.e. furniture, flooring in a house or office). Kiln dried wood Ive purchased locally and measured always seems to be about 7% moisture content.
Neither person has sufficient conditioned space to store their lumber, so it will be stored in covered unconditioned space for several years. If kiln dried next spring to 7% or similar and then stored for several years in covered outdoor space, will the wood revert to 10+% moistuire content, so that it would have to be dried again before use for furniture/flooring?
answers and Warning!
Bill Tindall
If kiln dried next spring to 7% or similar and then stored for several years in covered outdoor space, will the wood revert to 10+% moistuire content......it will rise to ambient conditions, what ever they are.
, so that it would have to be dried again before use for furniture/flooring? no, just "conditioned" to the local environment.
Ash is the preferred wood for powder post beetles to eat. Here in TN if you store ash that is not treated it will be destroyed.
There are too many personal details that I can suggest whether to dry it now or wait the years till it is needed and then dry it. Either option has its advantages.
more information
Bill Tindall
Sawing logs is similar to killing a cow. You need to have a use for all the parts for it to make any economic sense to do it- steaks, roasts, stew meat and lots of hamburger. Even the best logs yield considerable 1 and 2 common lumber. A log that may look good to an inexperienced person may only yield #2 common lumber.
If you don't have use for the lower grades you are better off selling the logs and using the money to buy what you need.
The perils of outdoor storage
Bill Tindall
If you can keep the bugs out of it and the rain and snow from leaking into the pile, lumber can be stored forever outdoors on sticks. I have some in this state for more than 20 years.
I would never risk storing lumber outside dead packed. Well actually I have risked it and this is why I offer this sage advice. If water leaks into the pile it will quickly rot. All sorts of critters will invade the cracks and take up residence, often to the detriment of what they touch, even if they don't eat the wood.
Hence, if you are planning on outdoor storage treat for bugs (at least in TN), keep it on sticks, , well covered, open at sides and up off the ground to provide good air circulation and hope for the best.
There is a lot to know about sawing and drying lumber and many ways to ruin it, get screwed by those you hire, and wind up with lumber you will never use.