Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Softwood lumber question?

Posts

Softwood lumber question?

#1

Softwood lumber question?

Barry Irby

Been doing some framing of wall on the current house I am working on. Bought some "Premium" studs at Lowe's Essentially every one of them had the pith in them. In many cases you could see they took a 4x4 right out of the center of the tree and split it into two studs. The entire bundle was full of them. This is clearly juvenile wood. Spruce or similar white wood. I don't want to go into a discussion of juvenile wood but I would rather not use it. Does anyone know if the grading rules address it? Stuff looks like crap to me and calling it "Premium" just makes it worse.

Re: Softwood lumber question?

#2

Dale Lenz

Re: Softwood lumber question?

Dale Lenz

Barry...As a forester I get a quick lesson on lumber grading ever few years when at lumber shows etc. To learn to become a Reconize grader, something like the SPIB, Southern Pine Inspection Bureau, takes months of training. So a few hours of lumber grading is pretty vague at best. But, from what I've gather lumber is down graded by visable defects, knots, wane, cracks etc. I'm not going into cutting-units, I'll leave that to someone else, if they wish to tackle that one. Warp at the time of grading is an issue, but not sure that the pith in a board is considered an issue, although, the center of the tree is bound to have knots, as that's where branches begins. I'm thinking softwood lumber is graded using A.. B... C's if you will and #1 though some such number. Premium is a marketing name as Choice, etc. Let the buyer beware.

Hope this helps, somewhat.

Re: Softwood lumber question?

#3

Re: Softwood lumber question?

Dick Coers

You need to ask around, and see where the contractors buy their framing lumber. I'm certain it's not Lowes. I saw a bundle of 2x6's at Menards that was "pre molded". It had sat around somewhere with a lot of water getting to it. There was black mold and white fuzzy growing all over them between the layers. Couldn't believed they had it on the floor!

Re: Softwood lumber question?

#4

Re: Softwood lumber question?

james runchey

Just goes to show you how times change...I did some remodeling in my house, an 1873 edition, ripping out a couple of walls. The 2x4s were a full 2" x 4" clear cypress. They looked so good that I ripped a quantity of 2x2s, straight as an arrow, not a blemish, not a knot. I used the 2 bys to make some kitchen cabinets. I love working with nice reclaimed wood. Not like the crap on the market now.

Re: Softwood lumber question?

#5

Bob

Re: Softwood lumber question?

Bob

I had the same problem at Home Depot I also noticed there 1X2s, 3s and all 2 by stock was in bad shape so I was waiting until they got in some better quality. That day never came then I noticed there 3/4" birch plywood had a lot of voids and defects so I talked to manager in Pro sales at Home Depot and was told that there 1by was air dried in a trailer because it was a hot summer and it saved them money. He concurred that the quality dropped dramatically and they were not getting the quantities they asked for as well so I figure there is a shortage. I went to a real lumber yard.

Re: Softwood lumber question?

#6

Re: Softwood lumber question?

Chuck Hans

if you choose to buy your lumber at a big box store you deserve what you get, there are much better choices out there. The lumber at the big boxes is not even much good for firewood, but their customers buy it so they supply it, and smile all the while. A good lumber yard is your only choice if you want something that you can use.

Re: Softwood lumber question?

#7

Re: Softwood lumber question?

Howard Acheson

The pith is not a defect in construction grade lumber. In fact, more often than not, the pith is cut into studs and timbers after outer clear wood is cut into 1x boards.

Re: Softwood lumber question?

#8

Bob

Re: Softwood lumber question?

Bob

I need cheap cribbing for my ceiling so I can put up sheet rock and the plywood is for shop cabinets. Hardly worth an hour ride to the mill of lumber yard. If it's for customers I would never buy at the big box store.

Re: Softwood lumber question?

#9

Interesting Advertisement.....

Barry Irby

I had to call Lowe's yesterday and while I was on hold, they were advertising their "Premium" lumber as being superior because it was the "center cut" and contained the the heart of the tree. This supposedly made it straighter and less likely to warp and it contains less bark and wain. What BS. Anyone familiar with Juvenile wood would recognize this as crap.

I would go to the local lumber yard, one of the few to survive, but they make it such a ritual to get a few pieces of lumber. You have to park up front, walk in, wait for the salesman to finish his coffee and/or cigarette, or his chat with one of his buddies, let him stumble through the computer and find those mysterious "studs", write them up, go back out side, drive around back, check into the yard, find the pile, either load them or wait for a loader, drive back to the front and check out of the yard, and drive to the job. I try to support them, but

it feels more like charity than commerce.

Re: Softwood lumber question?

#10

Re: Interesting Advertisement.....

Dick Coers

That kind of cutting works for big beams, like 12x12s. In that application, straightness is more important than checking. A lot of timbers for timber framed is boxed out with the pith in the center. If you cut those big timbers off the side of the log, it would twist and bow more.