Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Burning pine for firewood

Posts

Burning pine for firewood

#1

Dale Lenz

Burning pine for firewood

Dale Lenz

Ellis' post below turn a dimmly lit light bulb on in me head. I've got a small Southern yellow pine plantation out back that needs to be thinned out. The pine pulpwood market is Way down. I have Heard all my life not to burn pine in a wood heater, fireplace etc., especially SYP because of the pitch and cresote build up problems associated. I've spent hours searching the web for Good information on that very subject. "Joe Blows" chimney service says not do, but cannot fine any Good source that says either way. One place said the key is dry pine is fine. My chimney goes out the wall and then up, a PITA to take a part and clean. Hope to put the flute pipe up through the ceiling and out the roof one of these day and when I do, plan on burning a month of season pinewood, sweep the flue to see how much "stuff" that has gather there. If someone has a Good site to refer me too, I'd like to know about it.

Re: Burning pine for firewood

#2

Re: Burning pine for firewood

John Veerkamp

Dale,

My personal experience only. Pine burns hotter and faster than the hardwoods I have used (oak, hickory, ash, locust, hackberry and elm). I have heated with wood for 35 years and the only creosote buildup came from green wood. Wet wood will cool the flue by the steam driven from the wood causing the tars to deposit on the flue surface instead of exiting as gas..

I theorize that pine's bad reputation comes from the hot fast burning. Think of the fires caused every year because someone stuffs a Christmas tree in the fireplace. I think that any hot flash fire will ignite tar residues even from hardwoods if due diligence is not practiced. That said, the volitile compounds vary significantly from species to species and care from wood burning is essential. I have found that the best aid for clean burning is a magnet thermometer on the flue to regulate the exiting gas temperature.

Re: Burning pine for firewood

#3

Re: Burning pine for firewood

Bill Tindall

I have never burned pure pine but I have burned some mixed in with hardwoods. It is yellow pine. It was dry. It burned smoothly. Actually I was quite surprised how well it burned. Of course it did not last long. We are talking fireplace burning here, not a stove.

I think the secret to clean chimney is to burn a hot fire at some frequency. I can look down our chimney and it never has anything in it but a then layer of black stuff.

Re: Burning pine for firewood

#4

Re: Burning pine for firewood

Barry Irby

Dale, I don't claim to be an expert, but maybe I am. I have gathered lots of information about this over the years as a Home Inspector and before that as a Builder.

I think the information you got above is correct. The key is to burn dry wood. And to build the fire correctly. Thinking of a tile flue, You should start with a small fire, build it up slowly to a hot fire, then let it settle down to a medium or small fire. What's going on is you heat the flue tiles slowly to avoid thermal shock (don't start with a quick hot fire and shatter them), then once the flue is hot and drawing well, it is hot enough that the volatile gases will exit without condensing on the walls of the flue (forming creosote) and you are good t go. the same concepts will apply to a metal flue, but you can move up to the hot fire more quickly. Either way it is a bad practice to start with a tiny fire and never get the flue good and hot. And, as mentioned above, burning wet wood puts a lot of steam in the flue gases and cools them to the point creosote will form.

So I think burning DRY pine will be fine. However, it is "goffor" wood. You put one piece in the stove and go for another one.

I don't have an authoritative source for that information.

Re: Burning pine for firewood

#5

Re: Burning pine for firewood

Sophie on the southern Oregon coast

Hi Dale,

John has it pretty much covered. I also have used wood heat as a primary heat source for many years. We would fire up the wood stove in the fall and burn till late spring shutting down only long enough to clean out the ashes. Just about any wood is acceptable for burning except of course for treated, painted or fresh fallen when the sap was up. Some woods have more BTU’s then others some burn hotter but shorter some create more ash and so on. Species of firewood used for burning is largely determined by your location. Up at our old place alder, birch and big leaf maple was the way to go. Here on the coast its fir, madrone, and myrtle but if you get up into high country it’s almost all pine. There is one thing about pine though, if the tree has died on the stump when the sap was up, as a lot of them did here with the beetle kill, it creates a tremendous amount of pitch in the stump. Here we call it Fat Wood, a small piece of that would start a fire in a monsoon, not something you would want to throw a big chunk of on your fire. Creosote buildup is mostly caused by a persons burning habits. It would be really nice if we could just load up the ol’ stove, crank down the damper and let it burn for 10 hours or so but that’s about the worst thing you can do. A small hot fire with no smoke makes just about 0 creosote but takes a lot more attention. That’s why pellet stoves work so well, I’ll let you in on a little secret, pellet stoves have a really little man inside of them and that little guy is constantly throwing little logs in that tiny little fire while he has a friend blowing on it. I learnt that on the internet so it must be true. ;-)

Sophie

Re: Burning pine for firewood

#6

Re: Burning pine for firewood

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I burned wood as the only heat source in my large home for about 8 years. My main creosote problem was during the spring and fall when I had to shut the damper down and let the fire smolder. I finally got wise and started burning well dried cottonwood during those periods of moderate weather. It burned like pine, very fast and hot. I could throw a couple of cottonwood logs in and in 15 minutes the house was warm, by then the cottonwood (like pine) was half gone, when it got colder I still used it to start a fire and then loaded with Ash, Oak, Locust, Elm etc. The only problem I can see with pine is that it wouldn't look like you could hold a fire all night in real cold weather. That may not matter if you have secondary heat, but would be a pain if that was all you had. I would hate to get up at 2 or 3 AM or worse get up in the morning to a cold house with frozen pipes. With pure locust I could hold a fire for at least 16 hours and heat my house in 10 deg weather.

Re: Burning pine for firewood

#7

Dale Lenz

Thanks for the info so far

Dale Lenz

Assuming I do cut my smaller pine for fuel wood it will be burned in my shop, so don't need a fire all night, if I do need a night fire, I'll throw some hardwood in the stove and choke it down. I agree with getting a hot fire going at first to warm the flue etc. The problem with wood heat is to not choke the fire down as that's when you going to get creosote build in the flue, but....if you keep the fire burning HOT, it runs me and most people out of the building, guess you could open a door/window!

Sopie, as a forester I was taught and believe sap does not rise and fall with the seasons, there's a change in pressure come spring (pressure rises) and fall (pressure drops), same amount of "sap" just different pressure. As we learn more, certain old tales are thrown out. For instance: Some folks say to cut and dry white woods when the sap is down or you will have problems with staining. The stain/fungus/bacteria needs about 50ºF to grow, don't have during most places in the winter, at least not for long periods. So therefore, stain of lumber is less likely during cool weather... Just something to chew on.

Back to burning pine, would like to find a site that I trust to take me forward, might just need to try and sweep the flue. Sounds like the idea of mixing hardwoods with the pine might be the ticket. Burn some pine at first to get the shop toasty and then put some hardwood logs to burn most of the day.

Re: Burning pine for firewood

#8

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

A couple things.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I burned wood in a fireplace insert stove for about 10 years as my primary source of heat. I burned just about everything at some point or another, but eventually started avoiding light soft woods for anything other than getting the fire going. There's just not enough energy density there.

Somewhere along the line I read why this is--pound for pound, all wood has the same energy. But, the heavier a "log" is (moisture content being equal, of course), the more energy it will contain because the wood is more dense. So 50 pounds of pine has the same amount of potential energy (the cellulose) as 50 pounds of oak. It's just that 50 pounds of pine may not fit in your firebox, but 50 pounds of oak probably will.

As for creosote, I never had a problem. I used a chimney cleaning salt that I suspect was mostly TSP, available around here from Menard's. A scoop per week would break down any built up creosote there may be. If I happened to have some sappy or wet wood and noticed some more creosote near the heat exchanger tubes in the firebox (it was a goofy setup), I throw an extra scoop of the salt in, and the creosote would be gone in a couple hours. After about 5 years, I got around to cleaning my chimney. I looked down it with a flashlight and didn't bother--it was totally clean.

Jason

Re: Burning pine for firewood

#9

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

One more thing.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Since I saw the other thread that touched on moisture content, let me add this. Wet wood is terrible to burn. You'll burn a lot more of it because you have to keep more draft going. The moisture cools the wood as it evaporates during the fire, hence the need for increased draft. More draft means you go through more wood, and the wood is heavier with the extra moisture. It will also contribute to creosote buildup, no matter the species.

I found 6 months was a bare minimum for firewood seasoning, one year was much better, and I've heard that two years is ideal (but I didn't have room for that much firewood).

Jason

Re: Burning pine for firewood

#10

Re: Agree Jason - except

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Certain wood species are completely different in the amount of moisture in the live wood when cut and somewhat accordingly drying time required. Ash (at least in this area) has a very low "as cut" moisture content and can be burned almost immediately with great results. Sycamore was the "wettest" wood I found in this area and I normally let it dry for a minimum of a year & a half (also almost impossible to split without a power splitter). Had some scrub walnut - it took very little drying. Cottonwood was extremely wet and heavy but seemed to dry much quicker than Sycamore - used it in a year. Locust, Elm and fruit woods all seemed to be optimal within a year.

Re: Burning pine for firewood

#11

drying rules of tumb

Bill Tindall

Wood drying rules of thumb are useless guides be they for lumber or firewood. Because the drying rate out the ends is 10X the radial drying rate the length of the firewood determines rate as well as the numerous factors that affect lumber.

here in sunny TN I can cut wood in the spring, stack with good air circulation in a covered pile (very important factor) and it is dry as it is going to get by fall.

Here is a useful guideline. Wood doesn't shrink till it gets to around 25% moisture. When you see it checking and cracking the wood is near the finish line.

Re: Burning pine for firewood

#12

How about plywood ?

Yonak

I've seen plenty of warnings about not burning treated, painted or wet wood, but I can't recall anyone addressing plywood. It seems like the adhesives in plywood would not be good to burn in the wood heater, but I haven't really heard. Maybe they're benign.

Re: Burning pine for firewood

#13

Re: How about plywood ?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'd worry less about the chimney and more about the air. Traditional plywood adhesive was a urea formaldehyde adhesive - not sure if that's true anymore, but until I knew what it was, I'd be reluctant.