Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

OT -- Ok, I learned... never buy a used HD

Posts

OT -- Ok, I learned... never buy a used HD

#1

OT -- Ok, I learned... never buy a used HD

John in NM

Worked for a day then had a very catastrophic failure, complete with funny little grinding scratchy noises. Ugh!

Vendor was very helpful about a refund though, so on the whole this was a painless lesson for the cheapskate :D

Anyone know if there are any gotchas on a laptop drive? Going to stick with the OEM 5400 rpm, probably just 150-300 GB range, since I don't even come close to filling up 80 GB drives. I'd get an 80, but they're almost impossible to find new now, at least for a cheapskate.

Re: OT -- Ok, I learned... never buy a used HD

#2

Oh My! Thought you were talking about Harley's!


Re: OT -- Ok, I learned... never buy a used HD

#3

ROFL ! Me too ! . . .

steve mackay

Was about to go into rant mode !

Re: OT -- Ok, I learned... never buy a used HD

#4

Oops!

John in NM

I've had the subject truncated often enough that the abbreviation is getting to be second nature. Sorry about that guys :D

Re: OT -- Ok, I learned... never buy a used HD

#5

Re: OT -- Ok, I learned... never buy a used HD

John McGaw (Bodger)

Is this a reasonably modern computer with SATA connections for the HD or is it an oldie? If it has SATA then you could reasonably install an SSD of perhaps 128gB and gain really great performance and reliability and even gain battery life. They do come in smaller sizes too if you really think that you only need 80gB. In fact that is what I've got on the computer I'm typing on now (an 80gB Intel SSD) but on this one it is just for the operating system and some high-priority programs and data and everything else is on a 3tB spinning drive. Even the lowest-end economy SSD outperforms the best laptop spinning drives.

Re: OT -- Ok, I learned... never buy a used HD

#6

Used HD with a rebuilt top-end isn't bad, though!


Re: OT -- Ok, I learned... never buy a used HD

#7

I'd take a 1964 Power Wagon first...

John in NM

4 wheels, all spin. Ya like what ya like :D

Oh yeah, with a 318 and 4 speed stick.

Re: OT -- Ok, I learned... never buy a used HD

#8

Almost did that...

John in NM

But I found a NOS Hitachi 80 GB for $33.

We've had some bad luck with SSD's here at work, but they were only put in a few of the really harsh location computers, so I'm never much surprised when hardware fails in those. If the new spinner doesn't last I'll give an SSD a try (it is a SATA btw).

Re: OT -- Ok, I learned... never buy a used HD

#9

SSD

Bill Howatt

If anybody decides to get a SSD make sure the disk partitions are properly aligned or the performance can go down to 50% of what it should be. This is of particular concern on XP machines because of how the disks were formatted since there were no SSDs when it came out. Proper alignment should be confirmed on Vista and W7 machines. Google "SSD alignment" and you should find various methods and programs for checking it. You do not need to buy a program.

If you have an Atom processor-based netbook it is unlikely a SSD will help because of the limitations of the chipset.

If you are buying a any HD, trying to buy a small one can cost you more than the current larger "sweet-spot" drives.

Bill