ot installing shower grab bar
Jerry Gibbs
Friend wants to install a shower grab bar. Wall is 1960s stud wall covered with drywall and then covered floor to ceiling with ceramic tile. Any hints to securely install the bar are appreciated. Jerry
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
ot installing shower grab bar
Jerry Gibbs
Friend wants to install a shower grab bar. Wall is 1960s stud wall covered with drywall and then covered floor to ceiling with ceramic tile. Any hints to securely install the bar are appreciated. Jerry
Re: ot installing shower grab bar
John McGaw (Bodger)
The key word in your post is "securely" and that limits your choices. You can figure out some way to get a couple of long strong screws from each mounting pad into studs or you can install wide blocking securely between the studs which will allow you to mount the bar at your desired height and angle. I took the opportunity to install 7/8" plywood blocking 24" wide between the studs from the 'back' side of the wall in my largest bathroom but not everyone happens to have the drywall removed from the proper wall to do that and I can't imagine any other way to do it without destroying the tiled wall in the process. Personally I don't think that any sort of drywall anchor is strong enough for the job and would not trust any of them with what might be someone's life but that is just me.
Re: ot installing shower grab bar
Keith Newton
Obviously, you would want to hit a stud, if you can, so measure out of the corner 15.25" for the first probe into the wall, and the odds are about 50%, unless the layout started from the other end.
It is a lot easier to drill a small hole in the grout line than through a tile face, so start there with a small drill made for tiles. If you luck out by finding one stud, then the rest should be 16" on center from there on along.
There are some pretty heavy duty Molly bolts on the market now that the geek squad use to hang TVs on that may be good enough, but I would much prefer a good heavy screw into a stud.
Re: ot installing shower grab bar
Jim in River Oaks, Ont.
Can you access the wall from behind the shower?
Drywall is simple to repair, but a full wall brace inside the wall that distributes the load in question is the choice I would make, a wide surface flush the inside of the wall, ply wood cut to fit the space and spread the load would be my choice if you can open up the wall from the opposite side.
Take care,
Jim
Re: ot installing shower grab bar
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
I will add to the voices encouraging firm attachment of the grab bars. Having one pull out when someone is relying on it...not a pleasant thought, entirely aside from the damage it would do to the tile.
I recently installed grab bars in the shower (my wife Arlene was about to get a hip replacement). When we remodeled that bathroom a couple of years ago, we put in 2x6 blocking on the (outside) wall, for future grab bars (it was my wife, coincidentally, who resisted putting them up at the time); but neither my son nor I could remember at what height we put the blocking. I drilled several holes through the wood siding in a stud bay, and pushed in a probe until I found the blocking.
Then it turned out we hadn't run the blocking the full length of the wall, and I had to cut a hole in the siding at one end of the wall to install blocking from the outside. I diligently followed the practice of "measure twice (three times), cut once," and then found I'd managed to get one stud bay over, so had to recut the hole. Once it stops raining, I need to pull the plastic off that wall and install dutchmen in the siding.
I found that the screws that came with the grab bar were not nearly long enough, and had to buy longer screws; be sure to get stainless steel screws.
And shoot the holes in the tile (which should, of course, be clearance holes, the side of the shank or a little bigger, not the smaller holes you'll/he'll need in the wood for the screw to screw into) full of bathroom-rated silicone caulk. Be liberal; you can clean up the excess.
Finally, a suggestion: we borrowed a walker from our local senior center (which has a great temporary loan program), and a friend then dropped off her walker. My wife thought to put one of them in the shower, and I don't think she's touched the grab bars once. Depending on your friend's needs, this might be a short-term solution while working on the grab bar attachment. Much depends, though, on the physical capacities of the person using the shower. When in doubt, overdoing it is good.
Also think about getting in and out of the shower. We had a glass shower door installed when we did the remodel, with two fixed panels and the door in between them. We realized, when Arlene was practicing getting in and out of the shower before the surgery, that we should have had an extra handle installed in the fixed glass panel next to the door, as a grab bar for comfortable exiting from the shower. The walker turned out helpful here, too.
Confirmation
Jim in River Oaks, Ont.
I will say that working through a remodel with the knowledge you may require grab bars in the future is excellent advice. I have first had experience with this, 5 years ago I had my right hip replaced and had significant troubles with the shower situation in the house. A few years later I remodelled much of the house, the shower was addressed with my knowledge from my first go around with hip surgery. I designed the new shower to be "Hip Replacement" friendly, just in case. I am now 6 weeks since my current replacement and I smile and thank myself daily that I chose to adjust accordingly, surprisingly with no grab bars, but forward planning as mentioned with blocking built into the walls just in case.
Take care,
Jim
Double Hips!
Re: ot installing shower grab bar
don
I recall seeing a This Old House episode where they installed grab bars. Clearly securing the bar to studs or plywood would be ideal, but if that's not possible, the product they used on this show seems workable.
http://www.wingits.com/Fastening-Systems_c_7.html
stud finder
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
Some of the new, expensive ($70 or so), high-grade stud finders are reputed to be able to find framing through multiple layers of stuff. If you can't come at it from behind, might be worth trying one.
Re: ot installing shower grab bar
Jerry Nicholson
I installed 3 grab bars near the tub for my wife. The studs were easy to find and after nicking the surface of the ceramic tile with a center punch I drilled through the tile with a masonry bit. I used large long screws (stainless steel, I think) and drilled a pilot hole the minor diameter of the threads. They have been up a few years and I haven't seen any sign of loosening. I wouldn't consider trying to mount the bars to sheetrock, no matter what kind of anchor is available. I did something similar at the door from the kitchen to the garage (two steps) but of course I didn't have to bother with ceramic tile.
Jerry
Re: ot installing shower grab bar
Barry Irby
I agree with all those who said it would be better to find the studs, but if you can't, you might call some body like Fastenal and see what they recommend for this application. They may have some sort of fasteners that will do the job for you.