Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

Posts

Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

#1

Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

mkula

This I messed up the first time I tried to post this...

Anyway, I am working on building butchblock counters for my kitchen redo (will be 2" Big leaf maple) and have read lots of past posts and articles about oil finish options, but so many differing opinions. I'm hoping to try to settle this as best I can before I get tot he finish stage, so I am wondering if people out there have specific pros/cons or preferences with the following options below. I do plan on using the counters to cut, moderately, and I don't have a problem with repeated maintenance, oiling, etc... Just wont the most durable, best looking food-safe finish I can find that'll really make these counters look great and last.

Thoughts about:

Straight mineral oil?

Mineral oil mix (with beeswax, etc... Rockler and other places have a product like this)

Raw Linseed oil?

Tung oil or Waterlox??

Walnut oil or similar?

Any other suggesting?

thanks in advance for your wisdom!

Re: Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

#2

Re: Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

John in NM

I would go with either tung oil or boiled linseed oil (Tried & True if you're worried about driers). Thin the first coat 50% with turp or mineral spirits, then 25% for the remaining coats. Finish will require periodic re-application, but it should penetrate nicely, which I like better than a film finish for high wear areas.

There are many, many opinions on this though, I'm sure you will get plenty for each option, and maybe even some you haven't thought of yet :D

Re: Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

#3

Re: Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

John McGaw (Bodger)

I have only done cutting board sized end-grain blocks but have tried several different finishes: straight mineral oil, walnut oil, walnut oil with beeswax. For cutting board use I can't recommend one above the others but the last one seems to keep its appearance just a bit better, walnut oil next, and mineral oil last. For turned treen I've used a finish of mixed bees wax, carnauba wax, and real turpentine as a softener which are melted together. This works great for friction polishing on the lathe but I'm not sure I'd want to attempt it on a large flat surface. It sure is durable though.

Re: Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

#4

Cutting board finish

Merle

Whatever you decide to do, try doing it on a sample first.

You might also consider GF Salad Bowl Finish diluted 50% with mineral spirits. Let it dry a day between coats and apply maybe 3 coats total. After the final coat has dried thoroughly, you can lightly sand with 400G. I have never done this on a kitchen counter, but it makes a nice looking end grain cutting board. ;)

Re: Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

#5

Re: Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

Bill Leffingwell

I have been making and selling cutting boards for 20 years and have used Walnut oil the entire time.Is it the best? For me YES because of it is a food{good for salad oil) it is available,and it is inexpensive and a selling point for the " all natural group".Is it really the best? I really do not know,but with end grain if you apply several coats of Walnut oil and let it soak in you will have a good finish.

Bill

Re: Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

#6

Re: Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

mkula

I probably should have said this'll be edge grain counter. I know less tough than end grain, but still should be okay for my needs. Has walnut oil worked well for you with edge grain or any experience?

Re: Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

#7

Re: Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

Bill Tindall

Here we go again. We have had sections of counter top "butcher block" for 40 years in each of two houses, plus various cutting boards one of which was made in shop class in 1967. We put whatever cooking oil happens to be handy on them. The argument that cooking oil will become rancid and lead to some terrible result doesn't hold up to scrutiny if one intends to actually use them. When a pie crust is rolled out its oil will transfer. Ditto bread kneading. Etc. Our top and cutting boards stay oiled by and large just from use. But if the counter gets exposed to meat, for example cutting up the deer I shot this evening, it will be scrubbed and if it looks "dry" when it dries it will get a dose of what ever bottle of cooking oil is within reach.

The advantage of some cooking oils is that they will partially cure and hence stick in the wood better. Olive oil is largely unreactive so it could be used if rancidity is a fear, which it seems to be in most quarters.

If you don't like whatever you choose just scrape it down and start over.

In judging responses try to determine if the opinion is coming from someone that actually has years of use with their recommendation.

Re: Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

#8

Kneale Brownson

I'm with Bill

Kneale Brownson

I have a couple of raw wood surfaces used as kitchen counter tops for the last 40 years that have only ever seen vegetable oil as a finish. We wash before and after each use and I reapply heated vegetable oil when they "look dry".

Re: Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

#9

Re: Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

Bill Leffingwell

I have used walnut oil on all surfaces with no problems.I have heard that vegetable oils can turn rancid.but I have talked a number of people that have used a variety of "vegetable oils" none have ever had problems.I think Bills comments build a good case for using veggie oil it is cheaper than Walnut oil and obviously does the job.I will probably stick to Walnut oil on my boards,since the cost differential per board is only a matter of a few cents.To some it all up I think if I was you I'd use a vegetable oil,hard to go wrong with what ever choice you make.

Re: Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

#10

Re: Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

John McGaw (Bodger)

Walnut oil is different that your run-of-the-mill veggie oil from the salad dressing aisle at the supermarket. It is the one (at least to my knowledge) such oil which polymerizes. That means that, in addition to being tasty, it will harden into a film to provide long-lasting protection. You could quite easily make real varnish using walnut oil in place of tung or linseed oil although once you add a dryer to it I would hesitate to use in on a food-contact surface.

Re: Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

#11

How the oils differ, or don't and why it matters

Bill Tindall

All fats and oils are in most ways similar. They are all combinations of fatty acids and glycerin. Three fatty acid molecules attach (esterify) to one glycerin. What makes pig fat different from linseed oil is what and how much of each kind of fatty acid the critter or plant uses to make its fat or oil. These differences are not great.

It could be like building a house. Pigs, sheep and cows use different proportions of western spruce, fir, hemlock and pine; while olives, walnuts and corn use different proportions of white pine, eastern hemlock, yellow pine and more or less plywood, the plywood being the fatty acids that can react with air to make a film.

Some of the fatty acids can react with air. When they do they can break apart to make different kinds of smaller and hence more volatile (and smelly) fatty acids (rancid smell). They can also react with one another and when this happens the oil links together (polymerize) to make a film. If there is a lot of linking together the film will be hard and durable. Less hooking together and the oil will just get sticky.

All rancid is not equal. Rancid butter from milk fat gags most people, though others enjoy this same smell in their preferred cheese. Rancid smell of linseed oil is accepted as the normal smell of linseed oil, though some avoid using it in confined spaces such as the inside of a cabinet.

Olive oil and Camellia oil contain little of the fatty acids that enable linking together of the oil. They don't acquire a rancid smell nor do they get sticky or form a durable film. Corn oil has more of the fatty acids that enable linking together. When corn oil reacts with air it gets sticky, which is good if you want to keep it in the cutting board. Walnut oil has even more of these acids. Tung and linseed oil have the most and they react with oxygen to make a durable film, and produce a distinctive “rancid” odor.

Re: Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

#12

"Rancid" defined

Bill Tindall

Most fats and oils react with oxygen and when they do they break down to make volatile fatty acids which have distinctive smells. Different oils break down to make different smells. Butter fat breaks down to make butyric acid, the smell of which can gag a maggot,....... or be desirable in some cheese . Other fats and oils will make other acids which smell more or less, and different.

Any oil that dries, which would include Linseed, Tung and Walnut, will react with oxygen and make a rancid smell. The characteristic smell of these oils is a result of this reaction.

When corn oil makes a rancid smell it will not smell like rancid butter, nor will it smell like linseed oil. If you don't like the smell don't use it. But don't think you are avoiding a rancid smell by using one of the drying oils. You are just trading one distinctive "rancid" odor for another.

Re: Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

#13

Always interesting reading Bill...

John in NM

when you start talking about chemistry :D

I have a tung oiled coat that smells like a wet dog :D

And I have to admit, I've never heard of wood treated with any oil smelling rancid.

Re: Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

#14

Re: Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

Mkula

Just wanted to say thanks for all the wisdom. Will surely help my job. This is my largest project undertaking and ill follow up with pics-- and oil details once I'm finished. Thanks again.

Re: Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

#15

Re: Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

Howard Acheson

Let me touch on another point. Any use of knives, cleavers, etc. will quickly damage the surface of your tops no matter what treatment you use. On long grain surfaces, the blades cut the wood strands of wood creating spots for juices and other liquids that might lead to rancidity or odors. End grain surfaces actually "heal" from cutting damage. Think of the bristles of a whisk broom. Cut across the bristles (grain) and the bristles are permanently damage. Cutting down into the bristles just moves them apart with causing and damage. End grain surfaces act the same way.

An excellent treatment for wooden food preparation surfaces like cutting boards and butcher blocks is a mixture of mineral oil and either paraffin or beeswax. This is what is used on many commercial wood surfaces. It will last longer and be more protective than just mineral oil. It is a totally non-toxic and odor and rancid free treatment. Mineral oil can be found in most supermarkets in the pharmacy section or in a true pharmacy. Paraffin is found in the canning section of the store or in a hardware store.

Heat the oil in a double boiler and shave in some wax. The exact proportions are not critical--a 5-6 parts of oil to one part of wax will work fine. Stir the mixture until all the wax is liquefied. Apply the mixture heavily and let it set 10-12 hours or overnight. Next day do it again and continue until the wood will no longer absorb the finish. Let it set for 10-12 hours and then lightly scrape off any excess. Then buff it with a rag.

Reapply whenever the wood begins to look dry.

Never put a wood board in the dishwasher and don't soak it in dishwater for long periods.

Re: Butcherblock counter oil finish debate

#16

good theory but.....

Bill Tindall

My flat grain tops and blocks have done just fine for 40 years of constant use.