Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

RAV4 ?brake failure

Posts

RAV4 ?brake failure

#1

RAV4 ?brake failure

Shelley Thomsen

hi, George and thx for sharing your story.

On Oct 9, 2012, my brand new RAV4 failed to adequately brake to decrease the speed with which I hit a car that ran a red light. That woman got the ticket. But, I stomped on the brakes, ABS brakes, All Wheel Drive, and after a brief moment, my RAV4 fishtailed. I thought that ABS brakes were supposed to help avoid the fishtailing situations.

I purchased this RAV4 at Toyota of Grand Rapids, Michigan. Since I wanted the blue color, it was obtained from a dealership down by Detroit, Michigan.

When I shared the above situation with the body/collision manager, Mike, at Toyota of Grand Rapids, MI, he dismissed there being a problem with these brakes. Mike stated that ABS brakes were only designed to work when roads were wet. Mike asked if there were any indicator "Lights" lit on the dash and there were no indicator lights of any kind lit up.

I had 958 miles on this RAV4, and I had been driving this RAV4 approximately one month.

I did note that after I started driving my RAV4, that the brake strength decreased somewhat. I decided to really keep track of that, and prior to the accident, the braking strenght of my RAV4 never returned to its original degree of strength of braking.

My brother, who is extremely mechanically savy, works on cars, really is upset by this. He states that my RAV4 should never have fishtailed on a dry road.

I agree.

What do you think?

Accident Conditions: The weather was fine, it was a clear day, the road was dry, the sun was out, I had both hands on the wheel, I was not on the phone nor on Blue Tooth, nor was I texting. And, I hit my RAV4 horn as hard as I could and the driver did not respond to this. At the same time that I laid on my RAV4 horn, I pressed on the RAV4 brake as hard as possible. It did not seem to do any good.

Since that time, I have had a loaner car, Buick LeSabre, that has really good brakes. In a safe situation, I stomped on the brakes going 40 mph and gee whiz, the brakes worked without fishtailing and the car stopped much sooner than my RAV4 on October 9, 2012.

Re: RAV4 ?brake failure

#2

Re: RAV4 ?brake failure

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Sounds like you've got legal issues going.

I believe ABS should work on any road, dry or wet. ABS works when a wheel is about to lock up, and prevents the lockup.

Re: RAV4 ?brake failure

#3

Re: RAV4 ?brake failure

doug f, san clemente, ca

Shelley - I'll just address part of your question. Mike, the service guy, is mistaken. ABS braking is nothing more than an electronic control that pulses your brakes for more effective stopping. We demonstrate in our Emergency Driving Demos that stopping distance is decreased by 20-30% with ABS, wet or dry.

When used correctly, that is the brake pedal is stomped HARD and held down, ABS is a life saver. It allows you to concentrate on steering. Make no mistake, it's a rough ride when the ABS kicks in, but it works.

Have yours checked by a competent brake specialist; it may be nothing more than an adjustment.

Drive carefully.

Doug

Re: RAV4 ?brake failure

#4

Re: RAV4 ?brake failure

RobCarr

Have your mechanic look at the proportioning valve. It's supposed to change the amount of brake fluid that goes to the rear brakes. Rear disc brakes require lots of pressure to operate, but drum brakes don't.

Re: RAV4 ?brake failure

#6

Re: RAV4 Traction Control

Dustmaker Mike

does the RAV4 have traction control. If so this my be your issue. It is supposed to keep you from doing a fishtail by applying the brakes on the wheel that is affected.

Bring it back to Toyota and have them checked either way they have the tools to test the ABS and TC to make sure they are working correctly.

Re: RAV4 ?brake failure

#7

Re: RAV4 ?brake failure

Rick Christopherson

Because the RAV4 has such a short wheel base, it is entirely possible that your rear wheels lifted off the pavement under hard braking. This would not be a fault with the ABS braking system, but of the weight distribution of the vehicle.

Re: RAV4 ?brake failure

#8

Re: RAV4 ?brake failure

Iw

I agree with Rick. I would like to ask if tried to steer around collision?

Re: RAV4 ?brake failure

#9

Re: RAV4 ?brake failure

George Colonel

Good Afternoon Shelley,

Vwery sorry to read about your mishap. I reported having problems just after we bought our 2012 RAV/4. The Dealer checked out the entire system. To be on the safe side, we had a second Toyota Dealership look at it. Each time, there was no problem to be found.

It was suggested that it being a new car, I was not familiar, or quick enough to operate it properly. It was upsetting, but is an explanaton. Fortunately, I was backing out of my driveway, but was still able to avoid hitting any other car parked curbside. No damage except to my pride.

I still have only 3500 miles or less on the vehicle, have experienced no other problems, and drive the car with complete confidence.

I realize this doesn't address the fishtailing yu experienced. Sorry I can't comment on that.

George

Re: RAV4 ?brake failure

#10

Re: RAV4 ?brake failure

Keith Weber

Hi Shelley,

I can't help with the braking issue, but I have a question about the accident. Did the other driver run a light that just turned red (meaning that yours just turned green)?

Often people will misjudge how far away the light is, or look away for a few seconds after seeing a green, only to look back and realize that it's red. Then there's the idiot drivers that just feel that they can just squeak through for a few extra seconds after it turns red.

The bottom line is that people sometimes run red lights. I'm not making excuses for these people -- they broke the law and were "legally" responsible for the accident. But, a lot of the time the other contributor to the accident is the person entering the intersection as soon as the light turns green without assessing the big picture to see if it's safe. I look both ways before every intersection I ever enter, whether I'm going fast, or just starting out. It's usually apparent if someone is approaching an intersection too fast. Just because I have the right of way, doesn't mean I have to hit someone that messes up.

You mentioned that you hit the other driver. If that is the case, then he would have been in your vision the whole time unless he was hidden behind a truck or other obstacle, and his closure rate would have suggested that he was not stopping.

I'm not trying to point fingers -- I'm just trying to give everyone something to think about in the hopes that people pay attention and hopefully can avoid an unnecessary accident. I watch other drivers all the time as they enter an intersection to see if they just go on a green light, or if they look left and right. Most people just go. Something to think about! In the last 30 years of driving, I've never had an accident, but I would have been in quite a few if I didn't drive for others on the road. Maybe it comes from driving motorcycles, where somebody else's screw up can cost me my life, as can somebody else's lack of awareness if I screw up.

Drive safe!

Keith

Re: RAV4 ?brake failure

#11

Re: RAV4 ?brake failure

Shelley Thomsen

hi,

there were 2 witnesses that observed the other driver run the red light. I too, also observe intersections when I approach them as I take my driving very seriously. And, if my brakes had worked, the outcome could've been better.

However, now that I have my RAV4 back from the body shop, I notice that the brakes are more responsive. I have also been very observant of my braking, my speed, and the time that it takes my RAV4 to stop. Funny thing, the brakes work so much better now.

I, too, am a defensive driver. But, it always helps to have a vehicle that is in optimal working order.