Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Wood ID

Posts

Wood ID

#1

Wood ID

Yonak

I found a log in the woods that had been down for quite some time. I decided to cut it up and this is what was inside :


The photo belies the color. It's much darker than the photo shows .. a medium chestnut brown and it's quite light weight. I actually thought it was cedar when I was carrying the log, it was so light.


Just looking at it I would be convinced it's sassafras, but it had no scent to it at all after sawing and planing. All the sassafras I ever worked with had a very distinctive, characteristic smell, even when it had been sawn and stored for many years. Is it possible that laying on the ground for some time could have eliminated the odor somehow, or is it some other kind of wood ?

Re: Wood ID

#2

Re: Wood ID

Ray - Middletown, in

I have a sassafras log that has little to no odor, been down to long I guess. Could it be butternut maybe?

Re: Wood ID

#3

Re: Wood ID

Dale Stansbery

I would have guessed ash, but it looks a little too yellow. Does the photo accurately represent the color?

Re: Wood ID

#4

Re: Wood ID

Yonak

Ray, butternut is a really good guess, I think. It's about the right color and weight for butternut, but the grain may not be just what remember butternut to be like. It doesn't have the darker flecks and streaks. Do you think if you were to open up that sassafras log you would get that strong sassafras smell ?

Re: Wood ID

#5

Re: Wood ID

Yonak

Dale, the grain is a lot like ash, but it's so light in weight and darker in color, I think, than ash.

Re: Wood ID

#6

Dale Lenz

Re: Wood ID

Dale Lenz

Looks like sassafras to me, but no smell, humm. If butternut it will have a chambered pith, open up the pith to see. Any chance of getting a better pic of bark on one of the top slabs?

Re: Wood ID

#7

Re: Wood ID

Ray - Middletown, in

Been turning on it for some time and it emits almost no odor other that a slight damp musty odor. I think the tree was a dead "leaner" that had been there for a long time before harvesting.

Ray

Re: Wood ID

#8

Re: Wood ID

Yonak

Dale, here's a picture of the outside but, unfortunately, as you can see, the log had been dead so long the bark had fallen off. I found it leaning against another tree.


Re: Wood ID

#9

Re: Wood ID

Yonak

I think that's the answer, Ray, because mine was a dead leaner also.

Re: Wood ID

#10

Looks like ash..or...maybe...

Tom Dunlap

...a long shot...catalpa???

If it was standing dead and dried it would be very light. It does look a lot like ash to me.

YOu could do a Google image search and compare your guesses to other pics.

Tom

Re: Wood ID

#12

I'm going with Sassafras too

Keith Newton

I recently found one just like that along the fence row, on my gramp's farm. There were living ones still growing along with it. Your picture is the same color as my pup's coat, and her name is Sassafras.

There are just not a lot of other light colored ring porous woods with that good of decay resistance. Catalpa, and Royal Pawlonia, but they are whiter. Catalpa, smells like creosote.

I don't know where you are, but Chestnut, and its cousin Chinkipin can still be found, though I'm sure it is getting more rare.

Re: Wood ID

#13

Dale Lenz

Catalpa...

Dale Lenz

That's another possiblity...Depending on how bad you want to know, send me a small chunk or you could send to to the Forest Products Laborory for ID. Your right, the bark pictures didn't help, thanks anyway.

Have a catalpa coaster and they really soak up the water without running off the sides.

Re: Wood ID

#14

Catalpa

Don Orr

If it had been on the ground for a few years it is not likely Ash as it would be much more rotted or at least spalted. Your description of color , lightness, and texture is consistent with Catalpa. The bark is consistent as well, along with minimal sapwood. Also, Catalpa doesn't readily rot. Not much of an odor when worked and a nice, almost iridescent look when finely sanded and oiled. An under-appreciated wood in my opinion.

Re: Wood ID

#15

Re: Wood ID

Gary Smyth

You mentioned chestnut color and light weight. Why couldn’t it be chestnut?

Re: Wood ID

#16

Chestnut is the wood  Here's a wood link also

del schisler

It is chestnut i have work with the wood of course their are lot's of grain . go here a scroll down and look for the wood you thank it is, Paul has a long list. good luck

http://www.hobbithouseinc.com/personal/woodpics/

Re: Wood ID

#17

Re: Chestnut is the wood  Here's a wood link also

William Duffield

If you had found it in a structure it would be chestnut, but since it was out in the woods, most of the chestnut would have rotted away many years ago. Therefore, it is probably Allegheny chinkapin. What is its diameter, and in what part of the world did it grow? Lots of possibilities can be eliminated just by knowing its habitat, especially since sassafras has a much wider distribution than chestnut or chinkapin.

Re: Wood ID

#18

Re: Chestnut is the wood  Here's a wood link also

Yonak

The diameter at the stump is 8". We are in west Georgia, latitude about the level of Atlanta, north of the Piedmont. It was growing in a relatively lower-lying area .. closer to the creek than the hilltop and in an area that would get plenty of runoff, fairly moist ground, but not swampy.

I had a chance to look at the stump that I cut it off of yesterday and I don't believe the bark had fallen off like I had said earlier. It looks like it had withered and shrunk, but the remnants are still there. I believe it had been dead for several years but the roots are still holding the stump pretty firmly.

This is not a critical thing that I know the species, but I am curious. I think I'll take a sample to a local Forest Service office.

Re: Wood ID

#19

Ellis Walentine

Sassafras

Ellis Walentine

It doesn't surprise me that the smell is not there, as it mostly occurs in the bark. Traditional sassafras tea is made with the root bark, which has more aroma and flavor. If you dig around the stump of that tree, you'd probably catch a whiff of sassafras.

The grain and ring pattern of your samples is a dead ringer for sassafras, though there are other ring porous species that look similar, as some other folks mentioned. I would not guess catalpa or ash (swamp ash, maybe, but not white, green or black ash with that bark evidence) or butternut (too dramatically ring-porous for that).

If it is sassafras, you should see a distinct iridescence on a freshly hand-planed surface if you look very closely. A coat of oil should intensify this shine. I wouldn't expect that with any of the ashes.

Ellis

Re: Wood ID

#20

Re: Chestnut is the wood  Here's a wood link also

William Duffield

It sure looks like chestnut from here. Of course, the chestnut blight destroyed most of the chestnut trees in the early 1900s, but the books say they still exist in some areas, mostly as small, understory trees. Chestnut was not really common in your part of Georgia, at least according to the maps. Allegheny chinkapin, OTOH, which is very closely related to the American Chestnut, is common in your area, but then, so is sassafras.

The best way I know to make an accurate determination is with a block plane, a 10x loupe and a copy of Robert Hoadley's book, Identifying Wood. The information provided in it will easily separate chestnut from sassafras, and with a bit more difficulty separate American chestnut from Golden chestnut (which does not grow on the East coast, but will not separate American chestnut from Allegheny chinkapin. For that, you really need a seed capsule.

Re: Wood ID

#21

When you are back at the site,

Keith Newton

Sometimes it helps identify a dead tree like this, if you look at other living trees at the site. They can be the offspring of the one you found. That was the case for the one I found about like yours recently.

Re: Wood ID

#22

not chestnut, not sassafras either

Bill Tindall

If what you noticed is its exceptional lightness for its size it is Catalpa or Paulownia. Grain matches. They both are like balsa wood and grow exceptionally rapidly. The latter has a hollow center(pith). Both are exceptionally light and rot resistant. Catalpa propagates along creeks banks, while Paulownia is more likely to be upland in rich soil, but not always. I have dozens of Catalpa along our stream and I have Paulowina which has aggressively reseeded an upland poplar clear cut area. I think the wood has an odd smell. Young tree bark is smooth, gray.

Each seed prolifically, so there will likely be others in the neighborhood.

Re: Wood ID

#23

Re: Sassafras *LINK*

Keith Newton

Ellis you are right about there not being any scent. As I mentioned earlier, I found a old dead tree a few weeks ago which had grown in the fence row of my granddad's farm; now forest. There were living Sassafras trees growing just feet away, so I feel pretty sure about the ID.

I cut it open yesterday, and took a few snaps with my iPhone, then put them up on flicker. I didn't recall any ray cells from my last use, but down in one corner where it was perfectly quarter sawn, there are some little flecks in the late wood, a little smaller than in Cherry.


http://www.flickr.com/photos/7391658@N03/8144567272/in/set-72157631902021471/lightbox/