Distinguishing white oak from red oak
Yonak
When sorting through a stack of rough sawn oak lumber, what's the quickest reliable method of picking the white from the red ?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Distinguishing white oak from red oak
Yonak
When sorting through a stack of rough sawn oak lumber, what's the quickest reliable method of picking the white from the red ?
Re: Distinguishing white oak from red oak
JL
Easiest? I would say look at the ends. Red oak pores are much larger than white oak. If you have a magnifying glass, you'll also find that white oak pores are typically blocked while red oak are like "straws" and open.
Other than that, I look at the grain. Red oak has a much coarser grain not to mention wide variations in color between the early and late grain.
Re: Distinguishing white oak from red oak
William Duffield
Three ways: First, the vertical length of the medullary rays. Red oak's are much shorter, usually less than 3/4", but rarely over 1". White oak rays re often over 1-1/4" and sometimes up to 7". The problem is that there is some overlap.
Second, you can blow air through red oak (from the end grain). You can't blow air through white oak heart wood, because the early wood pores are mostly blocked by tyloses. The problem, again is that there is some overlap in the number of tyloses.
Third: Latewood pores are much smaller in white oak. Latewood pores in red oak can be individually distinguished and counted.
To see the distinguishing characteristics, it helps immensely to carry a sharp block plane, a loupe, and a liquid to wet the newly planed grain. I usually use odorless mineral spirits.
Re: Distinguishing white oak from red oak
Yonak
Excellent ! I didn't know about the comparative characteristic of the medullary rays. That'll make the job go much more quickly, for sure, as I can see them without smoothing or treating the surface. Thanks so much.
Chestnut oak
Bill Tindall
You didn't mention this possibility. You will have a hard time categorizing it. White oak has a more dense, less porous look to it and it is never red.
Re: sodium nitrite
Rick L
Follow the directions as I listed. The other ideas aren't guaranteed 100%
http://www.fpl.fs.fed.us/documnts/techline/is-it-red-or-white-oak.pdf
Re: Distinguishing white oak from red oak
Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI
Plane off a shaving and sniff it; if the smell reminds you a bit of puke, it's red oak.
Re: Distinguishing white oak from red oak
Stuart Hough
I'll second Dave's post. Even from the big box stores it'll hit you with just a light misting of water on the end grain.
Never saw that one before. Thanks!
sodium nitrite the best way