Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

A cheap fix for a motor starter

Posts

A cheap fix for a motor starter

#1

A cheap fix for a motor starter

Bill Tindall

The switch that starts the motor for my air compressor failed. Many of our shop machines have these switches variously called motor starters, magnetic starters, contactors,etc. It is the thing in the box between the start switch and the motor. It will leave your knees weak if you go to the motor shop and buy one. For a 5 HP motor the cheapest I found by far was from Grizzly and it was $79, a fraction of the motor store price. A friend suggested I try the heating and air store, and ask for a "contactor" rated for the motor, in my case 40 amp "resistive load", and 220 V to activate the coil. It was only $16.

Caveat: The air conditioning contactor will be rated for only 100,000 starts and it will not be fused. A true industrial starter will be fused and be rated for more cycles. In my case the motor had built in overload protection so I was willing to do without the additional protection provided by an industrial starter.

Re: A cheap fix for a motor starter

#2

Re: A cheap fix for a motor starter

Larry in NW Oho

Bill The motor starters on most machines can usually be rebuilt., of course the real problem is finding the parts. But with most of them the part that goes bad most of the time are the contacts and they are, for the most part, easy to replace. If they have a name, model and serial number on it, you may find something after a little surching on the internet. I would start by looking at some surplus stores. Larrin in Nw ohio

Re: A cheap fix for a motor starter

#3

Re: A cheap fix for a motor starter

Bill Turpin in WNC mouintains

Bill, a 40 amp resistive load is not what you have. You have an inductive load. Motors pull ~6 times the running load on startup. The contacts are sized to take this load(heat). Since silver is used for the contacts, this yields the cost. Be careful, especially on three phase. Bad contacts can single-phase the motor and fry it. Poor economy.

Re: A cheap fix for a motor starter

#4

amp ratings

Bill Tindall

These things have two ratings, resistive load and inductive load. If the person at the store is knowledgeable the customer doesn't have to be. Tell them the size motor and full load amperage stamped on the motor, 23 amps in my case. So for my situation the device is labeled: "2 pole" (need to break each leg of single phase 220 Volts line), "40 amp capacitive, 50 amp resistive" (actually one size larger than I need for a 23 amp motor) , "coil 220 volt" (220 volts operate the coil as opposed to 110 which could be the case in some machines), "50/60 Hz" ( single phase line frequency).

If trolling ebay, or used machinery shops, or finding replacement contacts is better value than the $16 I spent , go for it.

The bottom line here is that starting the compressor motor in the heat pump is not different than starting my air compressor. A device that will do one will do the other. The industrial device may last 10 lifetimes, where as the heat pump starter may only last 20 years, if that is important.

Re: A cheap fix for a motor starter

#5

Re: amp ratings

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Bill is quite correct in his assessment - another place to find the industrial contactors is scrap yards - If you have industries in your area. As far as I know, every industry I have worked for scraped out obsolete machines with all the control circuits intact. In 99% of these machines the control circuits are fine. You can use an oversize contactor if you change the "heaters" (try to find Square D or Allen Bradley as they are probably the widest known and stocked items in the electrical supply houses). All of the industrial rated contactors do have replacement coils, heaters and contacts. The only issues you need to watch are the coil voltage ratings as replacements are pretty expensive. If you are lucky enough to find one that will physically fit into your case and has the right (or larger current rating) with the right coil, the unit will last forever in a shop environment. (You don't have to use the exact size and if there are unused contacts that's also ok)

Re: A cheap fix for a motor starter

#6

Re: A cheap fix for a motor starter

John McGaw (Bodger)

Bill, before you go any further you need to figure out what you really need: a contactor or a motor starter. They are definitely not the same thing. A contactor just switches power while a starter controls power surge at motor startup via one or more techniques and is quite a bit more expensive and complicated. Take a look at this for a good explanation of motor starters:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2n9YzhWigx

Re: A cheap fix for a motor starter

#7

Bob

Re: A cheap fix for a motor starter

Bob

Hey Bill, You can go to Granger and get the part that is burned out in the MS if its the coil you can change it to a 120VAC by rewiring it and just use a 120V leg its a cheaper coil. It could even be the contacts in the conductor in which case is only a few dollars.

Re: A cheap fix for a motor starter

#8

Re: disagree - motor contactor is same

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

as a contactor for all practical purposes.

NO motor starter/contactor for small air compressors (under say 75 HP) would ever use a surge protector in my experience. Sometimes we would tie a resistor & capacitor across the contacts to reduce arc of the contacts and stray RF. A normal small motor starter (I have designed circuits and used several hundred in my job before I retired) consists of a (A) coil (used to close the contacts), (B) a set of heaters which start heating upon the load being applied through the contacts and heater. The heaters are designed to take a starting load without opening but will open quickly when either 1) the starting load stays on too long (motor doesn't start properly) or 2) after the motor is started the load exceeds the run current the heater is rated for after a certain time span. and (C) a set of contacts - these may be a set of 3 (for normal 3 phase - you just need to use 2 of the 3 for single phase 220 - don't break the neutral), They may also have a set of "pilot contacts" - these are used with a momentary "ON" and "OFF" start / stop buttons & hold the contactor coil energized until the "OFF" button is pushed. A standard contactor (as Bill stated) is basically the same unit without the "heaters" Therefore Bill is depending on the thermal overload inside the motor to protect the unit.

Re: A cheap fix for a motor starter

#9

Re: disagree - motor contactor is same

John McGaw (Bodger)

You seem to be overreacting to my simple clarification of terms. I was merely pointing out that someone who goes out shopping for a 'motor starter' rather than for a 'contactor' might well be sold the former rather than the latter and be much poorer than necessary when all is said and done.