Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

OT - Usage dilemma (long)

Posts

OT - Usage dilemma (long)

#1

JL

OT -  Usage dilemma (long)

JL

Some background.

Our community playhouse had "tenants" (a local theater group) for many years. They occupied the space rent free for all this time. They were supposed to do upkeep on the building - they didn't. Their reasoning was that if they didn't own it, why should they invest money in the building. They did pay the utilities. They also performed minor maintenance.

The roof was leaking and needed replacing. The electrical was in sorry shape (ganged neutrals, inadequate conduit, bad connections, etc.). The Leyland cypresses were overgrown and doing not nice things to the front of the building. The rigging was not to specification and had never been inspected.

A number of people (including members of the theater group) got together, raised money, bought the building from the heirs and proceeded to renovate the building.

The local theater group continued to use the building. When asked to contribute something, they declined. They did allow other groups to use their lighting equipment (somewhat grudgingly) - but generally they just were somewhat of an obstruction for other groups using the building - this included the group that purchased the building.

So anyway, they moved out. When they moved out, they did take everything that they could easily move. In addition to the other things that they removed was an electrical "raceway" or lighting bar that was on the catwalk above the auditorium. This was part of the original building equipment.

So - one of the people who may have been a participant in the removal of the raceway wants to come into the facility and run the lights for a local dance group. He is qualified. However, there is "testimony" from a couple of sources that he was one of the participants. His granddaughter is in the local dance group. If he runs the lights, the tech fee for the dance group will be less.

His wife is a nice person - she has been a stage manager for various productions under the new management. She has asked if he can run the lights.

I am the tech person at the playhouse. I'm responsible for running all the shows and seeing that there are technicians available. The tech fees for rentals are a "pass through" - any group renting the theater is responsible for negotiating a fee with the technician. Minimum fee is $100 for a four hour period. There is no maximum fee, but it is typically on an hourly basis after the $100. Thus if a group needs the theater for 8-10 hours, the fees can add up.

I don't want to "upset" anyone, but there is a lack of trust on my part. I don't want to upset the stage manager, because she (while new), is becoming experienced and fairly reasonable as a stage manager. But still....

Comments?

BTW below is a photo of our latest set.


Re: OT - Usage dilemma (long)

#2

Re: OT -  Usage dilemma (long)

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I personally ran into a similar situation with my mothers house -very low rent in exchange for full maintenance of the property as it was 100 mile from where we lived. I also found the property ran down - with no major maintenance done. However I felt much of it was my fault as I had no experience with this type of thing. I would never again rely on a verbal contract -PERIOD. It appears your situation was / is similar. I thought / He thought etc. Whatever you do make absolutely certain all the issues are in writing, signed and witnessed. Trust has little to do with the situation then. I doubt you need to go to the expense of an attorney (unless you have one that will volunteer his time as a charity write-off for your group), Often both sides of these situations believe they are right - and no one was really trying to be dishonest. It is just misunderstandings that really can cause hard feelings. Once spelled out in writing you may find both sides are happier.

Re: OT - Usage dilemma (long)

#3

Sounds like its time for an official policy

John in NM

A lot of the previous problems and grudges could likely have been avoided by running things in a businesslike, if still generous, manner. As tedious as contracts and policies are, there is a good reason to have them.

Now, if the playhouse management is like my employer, they'll say "what a bother, just do whatever you think best" :D Is the decision largely up to you?

In that case I would ask you these questions -- what is it you're worried about exactly? Probably not negligent equipment damage since you say he's qualified. Malicious damage? Theft? Simply having a guy you maybe don't much care for running around on this and perhaps future shows? Do you know him personally or is it all rumor?

If it were me, I would probably allow it with the explicit understanding that absolute professionalism is expected, and future access depends on expectations being met. Given the behavoir of the former tenant company, that might just be enough rope for him :D

Re: OT - Usage dilemma (long)

#4

Re: OT -  Usage dilemma (long)

John McGaw (Bodger)

"Put back everything you had a hand in removing and then we'll talk further" seems like a good opening line to me but I always was a hard-a$$ about ungrateful people wanting more and sometimes (often) it didn't make friends. It always did make others pay attention though and made them think hard and long before screwing with me again.

Re: OT - Usage dilemma (long)

#5

Kneale Brownson

Re: OT -  Usage dilemma (long)

Kneale Brownson

I'm with John. I'd agree to the guy running the lights if those include the lights that belonged to the building originally.

Re: OT - Usage dilemma (long)

#6

Bob

Re: OT -  Usage dilemma (long)

Bob

I agree with all the responses. My wife's daughter is the Managing Director of Blackfriars Playhouse and if you like I can run it by her, shes sharp as a tack. Theater groups are a funny lot and have there own way of doing things (Whats acceptable and whats not) If nothing else I would get everything in writing as to what is expected. Business is business, He said, she said don't get it and you cant change the past.

Re: OT - Usage dilemma (long)

#7

Re: That group may have felt they paid

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

for the raceway. Per the question the statement was made that

"A number of people (including members of the theater group) got together, raised money, bought the building from the heirs and proceeded to renovate the building."

Also in the statement it appears the "Theater Group" had the lighting equipment!

"The local theater group continued to use the building. When asked to contribute something, they declined. They did allow other groups to use "their lighting equipment" (somewhat grudgingly) - but generally they just were somewhat of an obstruction for other groups using the building - this included the group that purchased the building."

As I stated before a lot of the issues here may have been honestly misunderstood by all concerned. Your answer would certainly cause very hard feelings and would cause a definite rift between the groups (possibly forever) - I don't believe that is JL's intention. I would proceed with caution and a WRITTEN, SIGNED, contract that spells out the duties, responsibilities and if necessary the ownership of all properties involved.

Re: OT - Usage dilemma (long)

#8

Re: OT -  Usage dilemma (long)

Ralph Lipeles

To me what is done should not be based on trust. There should be a written agreement, signed by the responsible parties.

Ralph Lipeles

Re: OT - Usage dilemma (long)

#9

Re: OT -  Usage dilemma (long)

Thomas S Stockton

JL

I think you should move on and let what happened in the past go and start fresh. It sounds like a really complicated situation and the best thing for everybody involved would be to come up with a written use policy and stick with it. The nice thing about having good written policies and procedures is that if there is a problem you can use them to back up your groups point of view, also if they are not willing to follow them it is really easy to turn them away if they don't follow them.

The downside is that you have to be really good at following what you have written and be fair about how you implement them, nothings worse then hearing so and so gets away with it because they are related to the boss. They need to apply to everyone and anybody who uses the facility needs to be given a copy and they have to sign something saying they read them. no exceptions.

It may sound daunting coming up with stuff like this but I have found that most groups are willing to share their policies with like minded groups so everybody isn't reinventing the wheel.

Things like policies and procedures fall under governance which is one of the main functions of the board of directors of any organization.

I'm on the board of a non profit and like any group you learn from your mistakes and sometimes people feel we don't move fast enough but if someone comes to us with an idea of something new we are real clear that we would love to hear the idea but we need to figure out the rules ahead of time.

Tom

Re: OT - Usage dilemma (long)

#10

JL

Thanks for the reponses.  Lots to think over.