Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Wood vs. Plastic Cutting Boards

Posts

Wood vs. Plastic Cutting Boards

#1

Wood vs. Plastic Cutting Boards

Yonak

A recent scientific study tested wooden and plastic cutting boards for transference of bacteria to food. It was determined that both types of boards fared equally well when salmonella was smeared on them and washed with simple hot water and soap. 99% of the bacteria were eliminated.

What I didn't see in the report was if the study was conducted on used boards, that is, with normal cuts and scratches where bacteria like to hide (I can't imagine a testing laboratory would miss this likelihood). I wrote to the tester to find out. I will report here when and if I receive a response.

Re: Wood vs. Plastic Cutting Boards

#2

Re: Wood vs. Plastic Cutting Boards

John McGaw (Bodger)

I make (or at least have made) wooden cutting boards and they do have their place but plastic has one advantage that wood will never have -- you can chuck your plastic board in the dishwasher where it will be exposed to prolonged bouts of caustic detergent and insanely high heat. I never worry about the plastic boards harboring bacteria. Wood is beautiful and very satisfying but I reserve mine for 'safe' cutting -- no raw chicken need apply.

Re: Wood vs. Plastic Cutting Boards

#3

Re: Wood vs. Plastic Cutting Boards

Howard Acheson

Where was the study conducted and by who?

Re: Wood vs. Plastic Cutting Boards

#4

Re: Wood vs. Plastic Cutting Boards

RobCarr

A wipe down or spray with a simple vinegar and water solution will kill more bacteria than soap & water alone, regardless of whether it's made of wood or plastic.

Having said that I have always used 3 cutting boards...

1) Wood -- (I think it's made of end grain teak) This is my main utility cutting board used for Vegetables/Fruits/Bread/Cooked Meats & Poultry. This board has to be 30 years old - it gets wiped down w/ mineral oil about once a month.

2) Plastic -- For cutting raw meats (Beef/Pork/Veal/Bacon).

3) Glass -- Used exclusively for raw Ground Meats/Sausage/Chicken/Duck/Quail. This board gets a wash cycle in the dishwasher after each use. This board is made from some kind of tough thick glass sandwich, like a car's windscreen.

Re: Wood vs. Plastic Cutting Boards

#5

Bob

Re: Wood vs. Plastic Cutting Boards

Bob

Health department don't allow wood butcher blocks in commercial Kitchens or butcher shops and super markets that should tell you something. But I have been using wood for 10 years and no issues yet. We use 10% bleach and water to clean it now and then but most of the time we just use soap and hot water.

Re: Wood vs. Plastic Cutting Boards

#6

Re: Wood vs. Plastic Cutting Boards

Richard McComas

Anytime a government agency tells me anything I double, triple and quadruple check what they say.

Re: Wood vs. Plastic Cutting Boards

#7

Bob

Re: Wood vs. Plastic Cutting Boards

Bob

Yea they lie a lot, I don't trust anyone in or near Gov't.

Re: Wood vs. Plastic Cutting Boards

#8

Re: Wood vs. Plastic Cutting Boards

Yonak

Howard, I learned of this study in an interview with Chris Kimball of America's Test Kitchen. I have written to Chris Kimball to find out the whos and wheres and I'll report back when I find out.

Re: Wood vs. Plastic Cutting Boards

#9

Re: Wood vs. Plastic Cutting Boards

paul in AZ

There is a lot of mythology out there about this. Much of this is based on the seemingly logical idea that a porous material such as wood would naturally suck up and harbor bacteria. Research doesn't support this the way you'd think.

Hard data is sometimes contradictory in that varying methods were used to study bacterial survival. Research like this is pretty standard Bacteriology 101 lab material. We all did it in one form or another.

Here is a decent review article:

http://www.naturalhandyman.com/iip/infxtra/infcuttingboard.html

The moral seems to be keep wood oiled [and therefore liquid resistant]; but more important -wash and dry it. As safe as food preparation can get.

Re: Wood vs. Plastic Cutting Boards

#10

Wood is just as safe as plastic

Pat Riley

I agree with Paul and the study he quotes. Wood has been shown over and over to be just as safe as plastic. Any live bacteria that is not washed away tends to get captured by the wood's cell matrix , and then the wood sucks the moisture out of it and kills it.

If you are careless, you will get sick. It does not matter if you are using wood or plastic. The fact is, an old beat up wooden board is safer than an old beat up plastic board. The Government regulations on restaurants and butchers were made based on conjecture with no actual data to support their decisions.

Re: Wood vs. Plastic Cutting Boards

#11

Re: Wood vs. Plastic Cutting Boards

Chris Friesen

Actually, the US FDA Food Code says:

4-101.17 Wood, Use Limitation.

(A) Except as specified in ¶¶ (B), (C), and (D) of this section, wood and wood wicker may not be used as a food-contact surface.

(B) Hard maple or an equivalently hard, close-grained wood may be used for:

(1) Cutting boards; cutting blocks; bakers' tables; and utensils such as rolling pins, doughnut dowels, salad bowls, and chopsticks

So a maple cutting board would be totally acceptable in a restaurant.