Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Cedar mailbox post,fasteners-23 yrs later *PICS*

Posts

Cedar mailbox post,fasteners-23 yrs later *PICS*

#1

Cedar mailbox post,fasteners-23 yrs later *PICS* 

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

Greetings folks, I haven't posted much lately. Some time back, there was a discussion about the types of posts that are best suited for direct burial for stuff like fences, mailboxes, decks, etc. I recently felt the need to replace my old cedar mailbox post that had begun to feel a bit loose in the ground. The piotures below clearly show why.

This is a cedar post direct buried in the soil that has been holding up my mailbox for 23 years. I jacked it out of the ground so I could keep it intact to show the degree of wood rot. I always heard that the most rot occurs in the first 8-14 inches down from the ground surface due to oxygen penetration. The picture verified that. The picture also shows the bottom to be pretty much ok, even though the bottom of the hole was visibly wet. I don't think the post would have stood another winter with snow from a plow being thrown against it.

The fasteners were a surprise too. Some of the deck screws were pretty much gone, while others seemed like they'd go another 20 years. Same with the nails. All fasteners were above ground, simply attaching the crossbar and diagonal brace.

Keep this is mind when you decide how to deal with your posts in the future. I would not want to have my deck column posts buried and wake up to this 20 years later. I decided to do the new post out of pressure treated timbers. Off I go to the local borg to pick up the straightest 4x4s I could find. Got them notched, cut and assembled and then set it in the garage, "just in case". You all know what happened. They proceeded to turn into a warped pretzel.

So I violated my own conclusion. Went back and got some select cedar posts and did the new mailbox with that. If I need to do this again in another 23 years, I can live with it. At least I buried the new post with crushed gravel this time.

Thanks for looking.

Re: Cedar mailbox post,fasteners-23 yrs later *PICS*

#2

Re: Cedar mailbox post,fasteners-23 yrs later *PIC

Galen Vetterick

I probably would have coated the in ground end with asphalt sealer and used stainless deck screws so it would last 23 years and 5 days more. :D

Sounds like a job well done.

Re: Cedar mailbox post,fasteners-23 yrs later *PICS*

#3

Kneale Brownson

I've stopped using 4X4 posts of any sort

Kneale Brownson

for mailbox service. I use a treated 2X6 with a treated 2X4 on edge screwed to the 2X6. The boards stay straight that way. I fill in the top where the mailbox is anchored with additional 2X4 material to have a larger area to screw the wood plate the box goes onto.

Re: Cedar mailbox post,fasteners-23 yrs later *PICS*

#4

want something that lasts......?

Bill Tindall

Go to your local farm store, or fencing supply store, or fencing installation business and get a 6" treated post. Do no cement it in the ground. Tamped gravel is good, or just tamped dirt, to firm it.

Re: Cedar mailbox post,fasteners-23 yrs later *PICS*

#5

PS

Bill Tindall

Do not use landscape timber or "peelers" (the core from making veneer). The treating chemicals do not penetrate the heartwood well so you don't want to use a post that has a large fraction of heartwood. What you will buy that is made for fencing is manufactured to last buried.

Re: Cedar mailbox post,fasteners-23 yrs later *PICS*

#6

Re: PS

Barry Irby

Bill is right. Do not use a "landscape timber" or peeler. They are the cores left over from making plywood. There are at least three things wrong with them. They were soaked in water to make the peeling process easier and they were probably not dried before they were treated. They have some heart wood in them and while it is naturally more decay resistant than non heart wood, it is not as decay resistant as properly treated wood. And the wood is most probably "juvenile wood" or the wood that grew while the tree was a sapling and it is not of the same quality as mature wood.

The industry produces tens of thousands of these cores each year and they discovered they could sell them by flattening two sides and giving them enough treatment to turn them green and sell them cheap.

I have used aluminum nails in cedar posts and they worked well.

Re: Cedar mailbox post,fasteners-23 yrs later *PICS*

#7

Re: PS

Jason Waters

Some are sold not treated either and are cores. You have to look at the wood you buy these days. Most people don't have a clue.

Jason

Re: Cedar mailbox post,fasteners-23 yrs later *PICS*

#8

Re: want something that lasts......?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Another option for a looong lasting post. Find a local sawmill that has some 8 to 10" Black locust posts. I have seen some last over 50 years.

Re: Cedar mailbox post,fasteners-23 yrs later *PICS*

#9

Re: want something that lasts......?

Don in Central Illinois

A good locust post will wear out three or four post holes.