Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

buying scroll saw question

Posts

buying scroll saw question

#1

buying scroll saw question

Barry Irby

There was a post recently on buying a scroll saw. What's the consensus? What do you have to pay? Is the Dewalt one decent? What do you want to buy, what features are important?

Re: buying scroll saw question

#2

Re: buying scroll saw question

Howard Norman

Barry, I have had the DeWalt for about ten years now. No complaints.

Howard

Re: buying scroll saw question

#3

Re: buying scroll saw question

Bayward

If you are going to do any scroll sawing at all, as opposed to an occasional cut or two in a piece of wood get the Dewalt DW788 at a minimum. For a better quality than the Dewalt look at Hegner and Excalibur.

To see what dedicated die hard scrollers have to say about the various brands go to http://www.scrollsawer.com/forum/

Bob

Re: buying scroll saw question

#4

Re: buying scroll saw question

Gary Smyth

Barry I take it you’re looking for a bench scroll saw and not a hand power jig saw that sometimes are also called a scroll saw. For some readers here you know that I’m a great fan of searching around for good deals. A couple of years back I found a pristine DeWalt DW788. I paid about half of retail. I was pleased. I never looked back. A month or two ago I was offered an old style Hegner Multimax 18 and stand for $325. For that price I saw no risk, so I bought the Hegner. I have yet to master the hand, eye, feel necessary to be even decent as I’ve used it only four times as the unique tool to go to when it is needed for a part. Of the two saws I have to say the Hegner is the better machine. I wish that my Hegner had a larger table (they offer one but it is expensive) but of the remainder of things I consider I find it is quieter, far less vibration, better dust management, and built better with a fit that is visibly superior. My experience is that when I needed a blade wrench the Hegner folks in customer service know their product and are better also. Premium tools are not very often in my vocabulary but the Hegner is premium. Finally, I have to write that had not the Hegner been the price I paid I would not have bought it because I simply don’t use it often enough to warrant the new tool retail cost. Still, if you have the funds, and the use, consider it.

Re: buying scroll saw question

#5

Re: buying scroll saw question

AZ in Colorado Springs

I have a black and decker scroll saw. Paid $100 for it at an outlet mall ten years ago. No complaints at all.

Useful features:

- variable speed

- location of on/off switch (mine is right up front)

- the larger the table you can get the better

- some saws advertize one handed blade removal or something like that, but I've had no difficulties with mine (it's got thumbscrews at each of top and bottom ends of the blade)

- also get a saw that accepts pinless blades (so you can use narrower blades for small interior cuts -- pinned blades require a large starter hole)

Re: buying scroll saw question

#6

Re: buying scroll saw question *LINK*

Janice Manuel

Which saw? Depends on how much you plan to use it and your budget...

I've seen all the currently available saws and I think the Excalibur is the best of the new saws. It is manufactured by General....you know the one that makes big table saws and stuff like that....

The DeWalt is what I use and I've done many hours of work on mine.

Hegner....you either love it or hate it...I would quit scrolling rather than use one...

Get good blades once you have a saw...


http://www.truecutblades.com

Re: buying scroll saw question

#7

Re: buying scroll saw question

George Colonel's Workshop

Good Afternoon Barry,

I am anythiing but an accomplished scroll sawer. I'd like to have a DeWalt, ut not so sure about needing its quality and capability, given the limited amount of scroll work I do.

A couple years ago, my winter project was making 10 chess sets/boards for my kids. I had owned an AMT 16inch scroll saw. It cost me a little over 100 bucks. Buying pinless blades at a locat hardware store, I was asked by the store manager if I wanted another scroll saw=one which he had had in inventory for 10 years in an unopened box. $25 for a 16 inch Ace Hardware clone, well made. I snapped at the chance. Now #3 son Ken has my old saw. Both were used on the projects, and each has some superior attributes over the other.

The less expensive saws satisfied my needs very well. I'd still like a SeWalt!

George

Re: buying scroll saw question

#8

Re: The older Dewalts were made in Canada

Jason Waters

The older Dewalts were made in Canada. See here:

http://www.scrollsaws.com/SawReviews/excalibar.htm

I have one and have been real happy with it. You might find one at an estate sale or similiar. I don't do a lot but I would start there before I spent a lot unless you have plans on doing a lot of scrollsawing.

The new Dewalt is the same I think, but made in China I believe.

Jason