Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

OT-Replacing entry door

Posts

OT-Replacing entry door

#1

OT-Replacing entry door

doug f, san clemente, ca

We need to replace the entry door of our house after 12 years of weather, sun, salt spray and general crude.

I love the engineering and design of Pella products, but the price is just insane.

We want something that's going to last at least 15 years with little or no maintenance so fiberglass is probably our best bet.

So, does any have an opinion on companies that have the same relative merits as Pella without the exorbitant cost.

Thanks for your help.

Doug

Re: OT-Replacing entry door

#2

Re: OT-Replacing entry door

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Not sure if any match the quality of Pella. However you may want to price Pella at Lowes, I think their Pella (at least the windows I have purchased) stock is sold for less than any other supplier I have seen. I have a side entry door we use more than any other in the house. It is a Patio door that I installed about 35 years ago in the end of our kitchen, replacing the original windows. I first installed an Anderson rolling track type door. It lasted about 10 years with fairly heavy traffic. Then I installed a cheap ($300 - $400) one side hinged style door. It lasted less than 6 years, Replaced with a little better grade ($500+) hinge style door - again lasted 7 - 8 years. I finally bit the bullet and replaced with a Pella door about 9 years ago. It still looks as good as it did the day it was installed and has far better weather sealing and heating insulation. The door cost $1000 to $1100 at Lowes and was by far the best investment of all the doors I have used.

Re: OT-Replacing entry door

#3

Do the check before you decide

Gary Smyth

but Pella doors and windows from the big boxes are not the same as the product from the Pella store.

Also, For a rental replacement I just priced install from Lowes and HD and two local lumber stores in Western PA. Minimum install cost was $275 and the high was $420. The reinstall of a storm door was $97 additional. The low end was for a single exterior 8" jamb 36" x 80" x 1 3/4" fiberglas solid core pre drilled prehung door from the floor of the big box

Re: OT-Replacing entry door

#4

Re: OT-Replacing entry door

RobCarr

The entry doors on my place are 6-panel solid wood, painted exterior (w/storm doors) and stained interior (I think it may be mahogany) these doors are at least 50 years old and still going strong -- I don't see why even the cheapest door won't last 15-years?

Re: OT-Replacing entry door

#5

Re: OT-Replacing entry door

Barry Irby

You did not state exactly what was wrong with the door you have. Did it rot? Rust out? Crack?

What I see locally is the jambs rot before the door fails. Most of them are steel doors in wood jambs. Also, water infiltrates under the doors and rots the subfloor and framing below. On my inspections, if I don't find a rotted jamb I go look again because I probably missed it on any house over five years old. Not doing many high end houses these days that would have Pella doors. Have seen some that have become decrepit with age though. Better, but still decrepit and begging for replacement due to being Dated.

I know you can order doors through Lowe's that are shipped with superior rot resistant jambs and you can upgrade some of the other features such as the glass.

An important part of this is to protect the door from the weather. Doors on porches, protected by a roof, do MUCH better that doors on decks or stoops. Even an awning helps. A protected door will out last and unprotected one two to one.

Also, most manufacturers frown on glass storm doors. (I think some of them void the warranty on their products, but you should double check this.) The problem is that the storm door turns the door into a solar collector. I have seen the plastic parts melted on doors and the knobs so hot you could not hold your hand on them.

Re: OT-Replacing entry door

#6

A bit more information

doug f, san clemente, ca

Because of the configuration of our front door, the replacement will have to be a custom installation. The question I'm asking is what companies should I be looking at that, while not Pella, at least have an excellent reputation for longevity, construction and engineering.

I've looked at Lowe's and Home Depot, but they insist on trying to make their stock items work in my configuration. It just doesn't work.

The prior door was not sealed well on the bottom and you can guess what the bottom 6" look like after 10 years. It was a good door, just lousy installation and finishing techniques.

Thanks for the suggestions.

Doug

Re: OT-Replacing entry door

#7

Take a look at Peach Tree Doors

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

We had a Peach Tree Door installed on the west side (weather side) of our house here in NW PA. It sees the blast of winter and the heat of the sun. Other than replacing the bottom wiper the door has held up well for 8-10 years now. I'll probably repaint the exterior next spring as our Brittany has rubbed the paint off the window molding from peeking in to get let in the house. I'm very pleased with the door. This is a metal door, painted on the outside with a wood grain on the inside and a thermo pane window with interior grids. It seals out the cold very well. I can't speak if they do any custom doors or not.

Lee