for a settlement of a class action lawsuit for defective drywall. I had purchased drywall from them during the times at issue, and still had my receipt, so I submitted the claim over a year ago. I had completely forgotten about it till the gift card showed up in my mail today. So, now what to buy from Lowes? Any tool suggestions?
I would say they got off cheap. Did you replace the drywall? Some 20 years ago I sold a house and was sewed for 5M for having it in the house as well as lead paint. It was my grandparents’ home and they had passed away, my grandfather loved to paint so every year he painted and painted all this was before lead based paint was an issue. Seven years after the suit was filed the judge threw it out of court when one family member would not testify.
I don't know about this particular instance, but there was a bunch of drywall shipped to the U.S. from China some years ago that did a couple of bad things. For one, it was off-gassing toxic chemicals, and it was also somewhat corrosive--which meant very bad things where any sort of metal pipe went through a wall, you know, like gas lines or water lines...
And yet, at every turn, we seem surprised (as a whole) when this sort of thing comes from China, be it corrosive drywall or lead paint on kids toys. But we still keep trying to ship as much of our manufacturing needs over there as possible.
The defective drywall I am familiar with was made from fly ash from Chinese coal fired power plants. The coal was rich in sulfur and as a result the drywall out cases sulfur dioxide (?) and emits a rotten egg smell. It is corrosive to copper in articular and could damage the coil in your AC and your wiring. Locally, the only cure has been to remove the drywall and replace it with nonpolluting drywall. Can't imagine $250 would touch the cost of that unless you only bought a sheet or two.
There are tens of thousands of tons of fly ash and many people are seeking a good use for it. This was not it. There may be some new cements coming that make excellent use of it.
We buy that crap, we shop at Harbor Freight, and most places that sell US made products with cheaper equivalents from China along side, guess which they sell more of? Its much easier to blame some guy who supposedly made it this way for his profit, but the reality is that we buy the cheaper stuff and more of it than we likely need. The blame lies with the consumer, not the supplier, IMHO.
I say yes and no. I agree we are to blame for buying it, but sometimes, there are only a few manufactuers of items and when one moves offshore, the other follows to compete, leaving us with no option.
That's why I bought a made in U.S.A. Delta Bandsaw. Sure, it was used, and I had to refurb it. Many parts came from the U.S., but some, yep Delta parts marked made in China. But I bought something made here and supported a lot of U.S. businesses rebuilding it (Krylon, 6 cans of paint!!! comes to mind).
It can be difficult, but I do look and try to buy U.S. Made. Next time you buy batteries at the store, and trying to figure out what's the better deal, turn the pack over. If it says made in the U.S., I'm willing to pay a few more cents. And I've found that the U.S. made ones don't leak and corrode stuff as much as the import ones, at least in my kid's toys.
I would replace the drywall if you haven't done so.
I would buy U.S. made drywall though. Some companies decided to import drywall and some decided not to. Those that did import are finding out it wasn't a cost savings to anyone.
...powers that be cut trade deals with countries that they know have looser worker safety laws (which are expensive) and less overall respect for their citizens. There may be clauses about safety in those trade agreements, but 3rd world countries tend to cheat on them every chance they get. Then the other governments will heavily subsidize those industries until nothing is being produced elsewhere (like the U.S.).
In many cases the china made equipment is not well identified as such. Delta, Powermatic, Porter Cable and their associated brands are an example. Often the supplier just shuts down USA plants and starts producing the equipment in China (usually at the same or nearly the same retail price point). They certainly don't put out an ad campaign stating the new stuff is junk made in China. I for one buy a lot of stuff off the internet - no ID as china made. Often the only suppliers that is left in the US are small producers of equipment for industrial or commercial shops and way beyond the price point of the average hobbyist. It will be a cold day in HXXX when I buy another piece of new woodworking equipment from the (old top brand) suppliers that is made in China. I will spend more to purchase an older used piece of American equipment.
Just saying, HF and offshore production in general exists because the market is cheap and looking for a 5-10 year machine at a low price rather than a 50 year machine at 3x the price.
I've seen a similar phenomenon in peoples hiring decisions over the years - say a mechanic is retiring. The boss will often hire a guy with 1/10 the experience and ability for 2/3 the salary of the previous guy, and still think he's getting a good deal (didn't have to pay full salary after all).
The practice makes their product cheaper to sell, thus undercutting their competition. No surprise there. I'll say it again - it's because consumers in the US are cheap - perhaps consumers in Europe are cheap too, I have no idea.
Doesn't make any of these practices right or nice or patriotic, but businesses follow them because that is how they survive. If most consumers were eager to pay a premium for quality (as I tend to do), there would be no Harbor Freight and we would have a lot better choice of good tools available. Exceptions to the rule tend to occupy niche markets, where hobby meets industry.
Finding someone to blame doesn't change the reality of it.
It's odd to note that for a lawsuit settlement they can give you a gift certificate that's redeemable only in their store. Buy framing lumber with it, and if you don't need any framing lumber, trade the gift certificate for $250 with someone who does. I believe the lumber is their "loss leader" meaning they sell it below cost and make up for it on tools and hardware. By giving out gift certificates it seems that they're reducing their liability, maybe considerably, if enough people throw the certificates away in dusgust.
I'm in the same boat. I refuse to buy anything made in China unless I have no other choice. Every piece of woodworking equipment I buy, I will buy American and most of the time it is used. But unfortunately buying used American Iron doesn't do anything other than get you a better quality machine. It does nothing to take money away from the Chinese. Why? Because that 40-year old, US-made Powermatic planer that you bought doesn't make US jobs. That planer was built and sold a long time ago, and the people that made that planer are no longer employed at Powermatic unless their job title is Import Manager. What you've basically done is bought a planer that someone else didn't get a chance to buy. That person now needs a planer instead of you. Guess where he's going to buy it? That's right - He'll buy a new one made in China. If he holds out waits for another old arn to become available and buys that, he will be getting that planer instead of someone else. That person will have to buy a new one from China. No matter what... for each new person that needs a planer, a planer will be bought from China.
The only way that you could have an effect is to buy a brand new one made in the US. I guess then you'll be buying a new Northfield.
The fight against this Made in China crap has to be made on a governmental level. We need to overtax US corporations that outsource and slap huge import tariffs on Chinese goods. Bring the jobs back to America!