Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

nitric acid stain for figured maple

Posts

nitric acid stain for figured maple

#1

nitric acid stain for figured maple

Russell Dahlquist

Dear Forum:

I've been experimenting with using the aqua fortis stain on some birds eye & curly maple I'm working with, trying to get a beautiful color and the 3D like "chatoyance" that comes with nice maple. From my experience of getting blotchy results I decided to use some straight nitric acid from a gold test kit I had and mixed the 18 k test with 1/2 water (always adding the water to the acid) and found that the result was much more uniform, without blotches and no need to apply heat. I got a nice deep golden color with the figure standing out nicely. The chatoyance remained and was improved.

My question, being fairly new to this is, why bother with the addition of iron in the acid as in aqua fortis and the heating if such good results come from simply applying the acid straight? Am I forgetting something?

Re: nitric acid stain for figured maple

#2

Re: nitric acid stain for figured maple

PaulSV

I can't help you on your question, but I believe when diluting nitric acid, you should add the acid to the water, not the water to the acid:

http://safetyservices.ucdavis.edu/safetynets/snml/sn14/sn14

Re: nitric acid stain for figured maple

#3

Re: nitric acid stain for figured maple

Bill Tindall

I have never used this staining technique, or any other stain that colors by chemical reaction. The possible problem is what the chemical remaining on the wood may do to the finish. Modern finishes are complicated mixtures of unknown ingredients and it is impossible for the woodworker to predict how the chemical stain may react with them. Therefore, I would suggest testing any finish you intend to use on a chemically stained test piece.

And, if you get brown fumes when staining hold your breath as they are quite toxic.

The "acid to water" thing is critical when diluting sulfuric acid and less so with the others. It has to do with the higher heat capacity of water and what will volatilize if it gets hot.

Re: nitric acid stain for figured maple

#4

Been doing similar, with mixed results...

John in NM

I believe you add the iron to the acid (and let it stand a few days at least) in order to get a more caramel color than you get with the acid alone. I've not tried the heat method, though I believe it will accelerate the oxidation of tannin - how the stain works AFAIK. If you are lucky enough to live in the land of tons of UV like I do, a day in the summer sun is more uniform and safer than a torch (no scorching, I don't mean OSHA kind of safe) :D

I've been using ferric acetate, vinegar and iron, to achieve similar results. I'm going for the darker color, and its more complex than using ferric nitrate. One feature I've noticed, you practically have to use a dunk tank to get a uniform coat. Wiping has caused me some problems where I come back around to where I started (on a gunstock) and that side has dried already - that gives you a noticeable line. For what I'm doing, a dunk tank - 5 gallon bucket - wouldn't be too tough to do. I may yet try the nitric acid, though I don't really like messing about with strong acids - I always end up with holes in my favorite shirt :D

Re: nitric acid stain for figured maple

#5

Re: nitric acid stain for figured maple

Russell Dahlquist

Sir, thank you for the correction. I was trying to make sure I got that important bit of info correct and somehow reversed it. Please DO NOT add water to acid, rather, add acid to water otherwise there could be a bad reaction and you could get acid splashed on you from from the reaction. Do it slowly too, drop by drop.

Thank you again for the correction.

Re: nitric acid stain for figured maple

#6

Don't go there John

Bill Tindall

A bucket of concentrated nitric acid is not something you want to have around. Without going into the chemistry details there are many things that could go very wrong with very bad results. A small jar and brushing it on some wood is not likely to get one into trouble but a spill of a bucket full, or dropping something unfortunate into a bucket full could do chemistry you don't want to be around.

To anyone messing with nitric acid. If you see brown fumes, be worried and get to good ventilation promptly.

better yet do all nitric acid chemistry outdoors. I have seen organic material sit in nitric acid and seemingly do nothing and then almost detonate without warning. Bad enough with an ounce. A bucket full could rearrange the shop.

Re: nitric acid stain for figured maple

#7

Actually...

John in NM

The dunk tank idea was for more of the ferric acetate, something I may try before I give up on it entirely. Maybe I should give up on the maple entirely :D

Using kitchen vinegar for these solutions, I'm starting with acid around 5% IIRC, if I ever do try the nitric stains I will be planning on a similar concentration.

But thanks for your concern and apt warning, given my record with shirts I would likely need to think several times before trying it :D

Re: nitric acid stain for figured maple

#8

Re: Actually...

Bill Tindall

When dilute, nitric acid is benign. I would have no concern dipping into a bucket of 5 per cent nitric but would still recommend outdoors. But I'll bet 5% won't do much because it is not very reactive when dilute. It is when it is concentrated that it can do exciting chemistry.

Add a little sulfuric acid catalyst to the nitric and one could make nitrocellulose. How cool would that be to make your own lacquer right on the leg? (or gun cotton if things get out of hand!)

Re: nitric acid stain for figured maple

#9

Finally!

John in NM

A use for my old jeans! :D :D :D

Re: nitric acid stain for figured maple

#10

I have to vivid memories of High School Chemistry

Barry Irby

One was a kid named Howard Said "Do like you aught to, add acid to water." Say it fast enough and you can make "Aught To" rhyme with "Water".

A mnemonic?

Re: nitric acid stain for figured maple

#11

Re: I have to vivid memories of High School Chemis

PaulSV

Ha! Good one. I know, intellectually, that you add acid to water. But every time I go to do it, my gut feeling makes me go back and look it up on the internet again, just to be sure.

Re: nitric acid stain for figured maple

#12

Re: I have to vivid memories of High School Chemis

russell Dahlquist

Thanks Barry, Sounds like the mnemonic? is a New Yawk ting.