Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Table find (house sale)

Posts

Table find (house sale)

#1

Table find (house sale)

Gary Smyth

I’m stuck. After checking more than a couple of references and opinions I still need a bit of help on the pictured table/dressing table/washstand/sewing table. I’m looking for a comparable table for name, style, and date and value if one cares to volunteer one. This weekend find has an slightly more than ¾” thick, 18” wide single board top, is 36” long and 30” high at the table top, not including the drawers or detached scroll work. It is made of varnished pine. It is not fine furniture by any means, but it has hand cut dovetails on all three drawers (at both front and rear). The drawer bottoms undersides have hand planed bevels to fit into the drawer sides. The drawer bottom is tacked at the rear with cut nails. The scroll work back is 3/8” thick held to the back by three screws. The top drawers frame’s back have 1” holes drilled to relieve pressure. There may have been a mirror at one time as evidenced by the horizonal black mark on the back. Except for the drawers and scroll work the table does not disassemble. The drawer runners are scored but not deep and the inside wood has the grayish brown of age. The legs are turned, tapered (not exactly identical) and appear to be mortised to the apron, but there are cut nails (holes filled with putty) located at points that I would not typically expect to see them like on the top directly over the legs. I have seen the tapered and bulb leg shape on Sheraton furniture style, and one instance of Shaker but the Sheraton is much finer and fancier and the (similar style) Shaker leg doesn’t belong to a table (Milligan desk, Pleasant Hill, KY). The brass hardware is not new but probabably not original. The home it came from was all Italian modern except this and the home was in a "good" neighborhood. There is a lot "right" about this but suggestions, opinions welcome.

Re: Table find (house sale)

#2

Re: Table find (house sale)

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

According to an article by Bob Flexner in the October 2012 issue of PW, the beveled drawer bottom and hand dovetailing yields a pre-1870 date .

Re: Table find (house sale)

#3

Thanks. That helps. I like that.

Gary Smyth

With that supporting information I'm hoping for going back another fifty years -- pre civil war, perhaps 1815 - 1848. I have no proof (yet) other than my collection of American furniture books and gut. In searching I can get similar elements from other photo examples -- not the whole. When I first saw it it jumped out from the surroundings. It almost had a halo around it. I thought I recognized it, but where, was and is, lost to me. I've seen this table or its relative somewhere, perhaps as far back as fifteen years ago when I lived in Virginia and made the rounds of colonial and Civil War sites. If push comes to shove a set of photos off to Winterthur may be in the offing.

Re: Table find (house sale)

#4

Re: Thanks. That helps. I like that.

William Duffield

You might get interesting results if you sent the photos to MESDA, too.

Re: Table find (house sale)

#5

I'm unfamiliar with them but a

Gary Smyth

letter will go out this week. Thanks.

Re: Table find (house sale)

#6

Re: I'm unfamiliar with them but a *LINK*

William Duffield

The DuPont collection at Winterthur is vast, and they are very knowledgable, but their furniture tends towards the high end stuff commissioned and owned by the upper echelons of society in the big cities. MESDA's collection, OTOH, tends more towards what may have been built and owned by regular people. For a sample of the charming, but more vernacular furniture in their collection, look at Bob Lang's and Glen Huey's Furniture in the Southern Style.


Furniture in the Southern Style

Re: Table find (house sale)

#7

Thanks,  I have Huey's "Fine

Gary Smyth

Furniture for a Lifetime" but not this one. It's getting so that I have so many books and so little retention. This one looks to be on my search list.

Re: Table find (house sale)

#8

Re: Table find (house sale)

Merle

FWIW-I didn't see it in Wallace Nutting's Furniture Treasury. Sorry!

Re: Table find (house sale)

#9

As Paul Harvey used to say....And now

Gary Smyth

the rest of the story: I receieved this reply. My posting got a big response. Thanks to all.

Dear Gary,

I showed the images of your table to Brock Jobe, professor of American Decorative Arts at our museum. He believes your piece is a New England dressing table, 1820-1840, and probably originally painted or grained because it’s pine.

The attached is a page from Dean A. Fales, Jr.’s book “American Painted Furniture 1660-1880” published by E.P. Dutton & Co. in 1972 illustrating similar painted tables.

Hope this helps. If you have further questions, please let me know.

Jeanne Solensky

Librarian

Downs Collection, Winterthur Library

Oddly, I have this book but never pulled it because it is titled American PAINTED FURNITURE. I purposely passed over that book because I never once considered it to be painted in an earlier life. Here are the photos of page 194 of that book she sent and the book dustcover. I knew I had seen it. 1815 -1848 was a good guess.


Re: Table find (house sale)

#10

Re: Table find (house sale)

Hank Knight

Gary,

I'm hardly one to challenge the librarian at Winterthur, but I think if your piece had been painted in an earlier life, you could almost certainly find evidence of it. It's hard to remove ALL evidence of paint, I don't care how careful you are as a refinisher. My guess is that the piece was finished originally much as you see it today, probably with shellac. I would guess 1840 t0 1870 time frame.

I got my love for American furniture in Kentucky in the 1960s. I was fortunate enought to have had a landlady when I was in college who was in her 80s and had collected American antique furniuture for the better part of 60 years, much of which she picked up off junk piles or was given by people cleaning out their attics. Her house was furnished with beautiful pieces - mostly by early Kentucky or Virginia craftsmen. I used to go to estate auctions with her and see real American antique pieces in cherry and walnut sell for a song compared to today's prices. I wish I'd had money and forsight enough to have taken better advantage of those opportunities.

During those years I came to recognize a style of furniture that is sturdy and elegant in it's simplicity. I've researched it off and on for years but have never been able to pigeon hole it into a recognized style. I call it "Kentucky" because that's where I first noticed it, but I see it in many of the Southern states - North and South Carolina, Virginia and elsewhere. It has elements of a number of named styles, like empire, Victorian, American Colonial, Federal, Shaker and probably others, but without much ornamentation. Lots of cherry and walnut, some pine and oak. I would guess your piece comes from one of the Southern states because it has elements of many "Kentucky" pieces I've seen over the years. I suggest you follow up on the recommendation from William Duffield to contact MESDA. Their stock in trade is Southern decorative arts. They will surely be able to help you. I'd be interested in what they have to say too.

Thanks for posting this.

Hank

Re: Table find (house sale)

#11

Hank, I appreciate the comments

Gary Smyth

The (email) letter went to MESDA yesterday. They plainly state online that they don't do identifications or appraisals but I'm anxious to find if they respond. They got the information that was posted here as well as the photos. They might ignore me but I'll see. I find no trace of paint and what Winterthur was kind enough to provide me was quite a bit fancier than my posted dresser, but at least I did get the proper name for it. Now when I ask, I'll at least be able to tell someone what it is. I remain hopeful for pre-civil war, but if the dresser goes to 1870 I won't feel bad. Like you, I used to sit and watch good furniture go when the big houses and town houses in Pittsburgh and DC were broken up, At first I didn't have knowledge or a practised eye, also, no money, and later still never the space. While I kept a few pieces over the years, some eight moves, all over, took it's toll based on location, style choices, and moving cost. Water over the falls, but I sure wish I had kept one wood wheeled red/orange tansu chest -- no matter the style of the rest of the (then) home interior design. Oh well. There's a lot more out there. Thanks again for the comments. If you get any leads pass them on..

Re: Table find (house sale)

#12

I'm with Hank

Bob Lang

If it were ever painted, I think you would find a trace or two somewhere that no one but a woodworker would think to look. As suggested, this is the type of "real people's" furniture that MESDA is full of.

Bob Lang

Re: Table find (house sale)

#13

More information and a contact

Bill Tindall

It looks like white pine from the picture and if that is the case I would think the piece is from the northeast or at least north. It would be yellow pine if it was southern.

Here is a someone to contact...... Use my name as reference. Buddy specializes in KY/TN furniture.

Buddy Floyd buddy@furniturewith history.com

Re: Table find (house sale)

#15

MESDA reply

Gary Smyth

Thank you for contacting with your question about your newly acquired piece of furniture. It is an unusual form, and we have no comparables in our Object Database of Southern furniture. The pine used in this piece looks like white pine, which may indicate a Northern provenance. After conferring with colleagues, I was originally thinking the piece could possibly be a sideboard table, as I am unfamiliar with a “backsplash” on other forms; however, in Dean A. Fales, Jr’s American Painted Furniture, 1660-1880, there is a very similar form as yours although it is paint-decorated. On page 194, two New England paint-decorated dressing tables are illustrated, and although yours is not painted the forms are very similar and worth looking into. I hope this information will be helpful in the research of your table.

Kim Wilson May

Manager, MESDA Research Center