a critical point has been made...
Bill Tindall
"Living out in the country, it is normal practice to remove outdoor shoes in the pantry and use indoor shoes or slippers in the house."
One needs to decide on flooring after considering life style and what one is willing to tolerate. Any floor will work if you are willing to adapt your life style to accommodate it.
For example- I would be unwilling to remove work boots every time I entered the house only to lace them back up again a few minutes later when I returned to work outside. And the likelihood of sheep poop being on shoes is not remote. Hence, when we designed the house it was designed with robust, but attractive tile "sidewalks" that connect all outside doors and lead to the kitchen , "mud" room and a downstairs toilet. These sidewalks form a "+" with three legs at doors and the fourth at the kitchen.
Obviously not everyone's need but it illustrates the point. Figure out how the kitchen is to be used and what you are willing to tolerate for living with the choice. Then pick something that will be easy to live with.