Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

O.T. Kitchen Floor

Posts

O.T. Kitchen Floor

#1

O.T.  Kitchen Floor

Jerry Nicholson

Anyone up on the current trend in kitchen floors? I currently have (well stained) carpet over at least one (maybe 2) layer(s) of linoleum. More carpet is an easy way out but I was thinking of one of the laminated hardwood products. I hear that bamboo dents easily.

Jerry

Re: O.T. Kitchen Floor

#2

Re: O.T.  Kitchen Floor

Mark

I'd rip it all up and replace with tile. It's durable enough and certainly more hygienic then carper.

Re: O.T. Kitchen Floor

#3

Re: O.T.  Kitchen Floor

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

We have a floating floor ("Pergo," but a line made by Mannington), which we love. This particular line is impregnated with wax in the joint lines, so it can stand a little water (not standing water, but the level of water you'd use to wipe up crud with a wet sponge). The biggest problem is that the cats can't do a high-speed 90 degree exit from the kitchen - they slide and fall on their butts.

Re: O.T. Kitchen Floor

#4

Re: O.T.  Kitchen Floor

Bill Howatt

Any "wood" dents if you drop hard, heavy or pointy things on it. We have had engineered walnut in our kitchen for 2 years now. It has a few dings in it primarily in front of the refrigerator where bottles have been dropped on edge. A few spots in front of the sink where cutlery has fallen but they are not very obvious at all. My wife now has small rugs around the work area but why, I'm not sure.

I had carpet in a previous house and was surprised how well it hid the stains but that depends on the pattern.

Tile was suggested but if the suggestion is ceramic, I'd stay away from it. My opinion and shared by other people I know is that it looks nice but is hard on the legs and if you drop anything on it the falling object is history.

Cork seems to be liked by some.

Bill

Re: O.T. Kitchen Floor

#5

tile if you use the kitchen

Bill Tindall

Here on the farm the kitchen floor accumulates all manner of solid, liquid and sticky stuff. Can not imagine how nasty carpet would become. Porcelain tile surface is impermeable and durable. Sweep regularly and scrub at least weekly. There is no more practical surface.

Re: O.T. Kitchen Floor

#6

Re: tile if you use the kitchen

Nat Robison

Agreed on tile being my choice. Maybe I'm partial since I have 2 recently young kids. Can't imagine having gone thru that stage in life with a carpeted kitchen floor. Besides what's been mentioned about click-together floors, I think they're primarily MDF or particle board under the wear surface and would be bad news in case of water penetration.

That being said, my wife's parents have a Pergo kitchen floor and it's held up nicely (but no kids living in the house) but I don't think they've had any water problems.

Tile runs the gamut cost-wise but you can buy it for as little as $2 a sq ft. and depending on your age and usage, it could be the last floor you put in your kitchen. If you're up for trying it yourself, you might be surprised how nice it can turn out.

Re: O.T. Kitchen Floor

#7

Re: O.T.  Kitchen Floor

George Colonel's Workshop

Good Afternoon Jerry,

We did our kitchen with tile. Expensive but it really looks good, easy to clean up.

George

Re: O.T. Kitchen Floor

#8

Re: O.T.  Kitchen Floor

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Back in 2008 I decided we needed to redo the kitchen, bath, hallway, front door entrance, and side door entrance. Decided on porcelon tiles from Home Depot along with the thinset glue for tile. Ripped up all of the other floor coverings and set to laying the tiles.....360 of them. Laid out the main tiles; measured and marked each tile with a number and went to a small electric tile saw we purchased and cut all of the cuts with it.

Cut about 12 and then laid them, and went back and cut some more. Finally finished inside about 4 days, repainted seven rooms inside and three ceilings, then went outside and repainted(sprayed) the entire outside of the house, pit up some new shutters painted a contrasting color......all this work with in 6 weeks.

Install the porcelon tiles and you will be totall satisfied....and the SWMBO will be too.

Re: O.T. Kitchen Floor

#9

Re: O.T.  Kitchen Floor

Barry Irby

I personally don't like tile floors. Too hard. Anything you drop on it is likely to be ruined, and if the thing is big and heavy enough, it will break the tile. OTOH if you shop around, you can buy it for less than a dollar a foot. (Lowe's or Home Depot and others) I have laid a lot of it and it can be very attractive.

I have been buying houses at foreclosure and fixing them up. We find so many with laminate flooring we have started to joke that laminate flooring causes foreclosure. I like the flooring and there is a wide variety available. Do be careful to buy some that is more water resistant. We see it all the time that is puffed up from water. I think I remember seeing some that is impervious to water, but I am not sure. Some of it comes with the pad glued to the back and that was very nice. You can shop around and find it at very reasonably priced. Less than a dollar a foot. I suspect the cheap stuff is not very waterproof.

Re: O.T. Kitchen Floor

#10

Re: tile if you use the kitchen

Jerry Nicholson

".....depending on your age and usage, it could be the last floor you put in your kitchen...."

Age? Advanced! In fact, I am concerned about anything slick because my wife has leg and hip problems and doesn't get around all that well. My daughter and SIL put tile in a house they were trying to restore several years ago and had a lot of trouble with it cracking but it was an old house with very weak and springy floors.

And yeah, whatever we put in will probably outlast us!

Jerry

Re: O.T. Kitchen Floor

#11

Re: tile if you use the kitchen

Nat Robison

You can find tile with more "traction" than others but it's a valid concern since some can be quite slick if they get wet.

Your best bet for a floor that won't crack is at least 1 1/4 inches of subfloor (combo of plywood and tile substrate) underneath the tile. That's what I've done in my house with no problems yet.

Good luck with whatever you choose.

Re: O.T. Kitchen Floor

#12

linoleum!

Ronster

Lino-type flooring isn't cool these days, but let's see: impervious to liquids but not sharp objects; is easier to clean than anything else; doesn't crack; the high-end stuff is great looking and highly durable; flexes underfoot so a better surface for standing.

Criticisms??

Re: O.T. Kitchen Floor

#13

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

An alternative.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

There are some much better vinyl tiles being manufactured and sold today. You can get versions that look very much like a ceramic tile, even some that can be grouted. Or you can get some with a faux grout on two sides that looks very realistic. Some of these tiles seem to be denser and more durable than the cheap peel-and-stick vinyl tiles (or sheet vinyl), yet a bit more forgiving on dropped items. They would also feel warmer underfoot than ceramic.

Note that I am not talking about vinyl composition tile (VCT), which is what you see in grocery stores and requires lots of maintenance.

Jason

Re: O.T. Kitchen Floor

#14

tile not slippery

Bill Tindall

Our tile that is still good as new after 20 years of farm usage is not slippery when wet. The phony wood floor my son in law installed in their former house is slick as a banana peel. Now when wife waxes the hardwood floor that is another matter!

Re: O.T. Kitchen Floor

#15

Agree with Jason ...

Mike Farinella

Next time you are at Home Depot, check out a product called Allure in the flooring department. They are 1' X 3' panels of very durable vinyl. No grout, no adhesive (floating floor) , and easy to install. We installed Allure in our summer home and love it.

http://www.homedepot.com/webapp/catalog/servlet/Search?storeId=10051&langId=-1&catalogId=10053&keyword=allure&Ns=None&Ntpr=1&Ntpc=1&selectedCatgry=SEARCH+ALL

Re: O.T. Kitchen Floor

#16

Re: tile not slippery

Bill Howatt

Well, maybe yours isn't Bill, but there is a huge pile of it around that sure is. I have a sister with chronic pain because of slippery tile.

Bill

Re: O.T. Kitchen Floor

#17

Kneale Brownson

Re: tile not slippery if it's unglazed

Kneale Brownson

You need adequate support under the tile to prevent cracking.

Re: O.T. Kitchen Floor

#18

Re: An alternative.

Bill Howatt

We put down a product several years ago called Permastone which is a vinyl tile, 18x18", that has the faux grout. It has stood up well in an entrance hall and we have to keep correcting visitors who tend to think it is ceramic. It is completely glued down with an adhesive.

Bill

Re: O.T. Kitchen Floor

#19

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: O.T.  Kitchen Floor - Pergo!

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

The higher end stuff, not the cheaper variety.

We put it down directly over plywood subfloor (after removing cracked, nasty tile).

After three years, it still looks like new. Impervious to kitchen spills, tracked in mud, the the dogs' claws.

Re: O.T. Kitchen Floor

#20

Jesper, Denmark

Re: ...and now something totally different

Jesper, Denmark

My house was built in 1923. It has pine plank floors throughout, including the kitchen. I am not sure what treatment they have had over the years, but from the time the PO moved in 20 years ago, they were probably sanded down to bare wood and only treated with a rich soap solution.

I was very sceptical of this in the kitchen, but it has held up surprizingly well. Vacuuming and a weekly mop with soap and water keeps it up.

Living out in the country, it is normal practice to remove outdoor shoes in the pantry and use indoor shoes or slippers in the house.

Re: O.T. Kitchen Floor

#21

a critical point has been made...

Bill Tindall

"Living out in the country, it is normal practice to remove outdoor shoes in the pantry and use indoor shoes or slippers in the house."

One needs to decide on flooring after considering life style and what one is willing to tolerate. Any floor will work if you are willing to adapt your life style to accommodate it.

For example- I would be unwilling to remove work boots every time I entered the house only to lace them back up again a few minutes later when I returned to work outside. And the likelihood of sheep poop being on shoes is not remote. Hence, when we designed the house it was designed with robust, but attractive tile "sidewalks" that connect all outside doors and lead to the kitchen , "mud" room and a downstairs toilet. These sidewalks form a "+" with three legs at doors and the fourth at the kitchen.

Obviously not everyone's need but it illustrates the point. Figure out how the kitchen is to be used and what you are willing to tolerate for living with the choice. Then pick something that will be easy to live with.

Re: O.T. Kitchen Floor

#22

Jesper, Denmark

Re: a critical point has been made...

Jesper, Denmark

Outdoor mucky footwear here is typically wooden clogs - easy to slip out of and put on agan. Even tradesmen, who wear workboots, typically leave them untied, so they can slip them on and off as needed. Not common in North America, I know.

Another thought, which I am not so sure is relevent: Vinyl flooring has been treated with softeners in manufacture. Some of these may be PCB's, to which small children should not be exposed. If you have or expect todlers in the house, this may be a consideration.

Re: O.T. Kitchen Floor

#23

Your chemistry is amiss

Bill Tindall

PCB's, polychlorobiphenyls, have never been used in vinyl flooring, or any other kind of flooring. Their common use, before they were banned worldwide (well maybe not China) was in application requiring exceptional stability and non-flammability, for example transformer fluids.

Indeed vinyl must be softened, plasticized, and some of the commonly used plasticizers have been under attack from some quarters for the past 20 years. I don't know where it all ended. Many things children are exposed to contain plasticizers. If it is rubbery it is probably plasticized.

Re: O.T. Kitchen Floor

#24

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Senior moment....

Jesper, Denmark

You are of course correct, Bill. The reference should have been to Phthalates, such as DOP - dioctylphthalate.

Maybe the concern with flooring is still valid. There is certainly a brouhahah over phthalates in vinyl toys and eating utensils.