Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

Posts

Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

#1

Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

Charles Jackson III

When I went to carpentry school I was taught to use hammers for framing and roofing, but we used 16 and 18 guage nail guns for installing fasic, sofffit, and molding. I have a 16 guage finish nailer and a 18 guage brad nailer. I am wondering is it worth investing in a framing nailer?

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

#2

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

Paul Blackwell

We just had a new house built last year, and when I look at the floor joists or exposed studs. I see 30-40% of the nails never even hit the joists or studs when applying sheathing or subfloors. Evidently the framers can't be bothered to use a tape measure and chalk line to lay out the locations. When you use a hammer, at least you can feel it when you miss a framing member.

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

#3

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

Charles Jackson III

I really pefer a hammer.

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

#4

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I think the problem is that people don't care about quality of the build anymore--in part because they don't know what quality is. They want two things: square footage and "looks good when it's done".

Couple that with tract home builders moving up the food chain into tract McMansions (due to the now-deflated housing bubble), and that's what you get.

However, if you were framing for a living, I think you would be cheating your customer to not use a framing nailer for at least any sheathing. You can tell if a nail misses the framing by the bounce/rattle of the sheathing (and sometimes the set of the nail). In terms of time, there is no comparison, and framing nails are often collated with a hot-melt glue that melts from the friction when it's driven by the pneumatic nailer at high speed. I've found they can be harder to pull out. So, provided they're hitting their mark, it's better in my judgment.

Jason

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

#5

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

Barry Irby

I used to be a builder. I came along at about the time nail guns got popular. I bought a framing nailer. Before that we all carried hammers and we all nailed. After that I noticed one guy did all the nailing with the gun and the rest waited on him.

Blaming missing the studs or joists on the nail gun is like blaming the archer missing the target on the arrows. (or maybe the bow)

Like every other tools they have their strengths and weaknesses. I can drive nails all day long with a hammer and in difficult situations. My son, not so much. He likes nail guns better than I do. OTOH, I have about ten.

If you get a framing nailer, make sure you get one that shoots full round head nails, not the clipped head ones. (I don't know if they still sell the clipped head guns, but they still sell the nails.) My understanding is that the building code now requires full round head nails.

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

#6

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

Dick Coers

Framing nailers cause me to pucker up. They go off like a 22 rifle, and it's rather unnerving when nailing rafters to the ridge beam right beside your head. My aging arm won't last now for nailing, so I have a framing nailer. Don't buy nails at the big box stores (China). Buy name brand nails, and keep the air tool oil handy. You'll be surprised how many strips of nails you can shoot through.

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

#7

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

Charles Jackson III

What do you guys think about the Plasode Cordless Framing Nailers?

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

#8

Compromise approach

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

My contractor son uses a lot of chalk in his chalk line; but, when he's nailing sheathing, he also sets the gun to leave the nail one hammer-strike proud, and drives the nail home with a hammer. This lets him confirm that he's nailing into wood and not air, while letting the gun do 90% of the grunt work.

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

#9

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

The guy who built my house had one of the Paslode butane powered, cordless nailers, and he built the entire thing alone, with the exception of putting up the roof sheathing. He told me he put up the whole house with 3-4 of those gas cartridges.

I inspected that house every single day it was being built, and believe me when I say that I would have halted the project if he had missed any nailing at all. He didn't. OTOH, he's the best carpenter I've ever seen, including me :D It's the carpenter, not the nail gun.

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

#10

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

They have their place.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I don't have any of the Paslode cordless nailers, but I have used some of them. If I were doing any type of carpentry full-time, I would have them in the stable, but they would not be the go-to nailers.

For one, I hate the smell of the exhaust gas from them, but their biggest drawback is that they do need to be serviced periodically--essentially just a thorough cleaning. If you catch a Paslode rep at a contractor lunch or breakfast, I've heard they'll usually do it on the spot for free, but don't quote me on that.

Jason

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

#11

Re: They have their place.

Barry Irby

I don't have one either but I would like to, if money were no object. I would want to know how much they weigh. if they are even a few ounces heavier than a regular gun that might get to you after a long day. OTOH, you don't have to drag a hose around and don't even have to carry the hose and compressor to the job. Very handy if you are only driving a few nails or don't have electricity on the job. I am suspicious that the gas cartridge would leak done during storage. And you would have to be SURE to have spares, or you are out of business. Do you have a local economical source of cartridges? Is there a pause between shots? Could be annoying.

Back in the day, I ran all my guns off a tank of nitrogen. Put a torch regulator on it and hooked up a hose and went to work. It was great. Silent, (no compressor noise) Cheap, $15 worth of nitrogen would nail on a hundred sheets of roof sheeting, and easy to have a tank on every job. Can't do it any more, they claim if the regulator failed the 2200 psi of the tank could blow up the guns. I am wondering about using carbon dioxide.

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

#12

Re: They have their place.

Charles Jackson III

The cordless guns have improve since they first came out. You can get 6000 shots on a single charge before you have to recharge the battery on the new one.

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

#13

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

When I built my shop I used nail guns - framing, light framing, 15, 16, and 18 gauge finish nailers and used an "auto screw gun" for the drywall. I would never again tackle any major framing project without nail guns. To me it is like questioning building with a hand saw VS building with a skill saw. A nail gun sets the nail with less splitting in a fraction of the time you can pound one in, and most use "cement" coated nails - the coating "melts" due to the friction of the high speed set and then "glues" the nail in place. They are much harder to pull - a good thing if you want the structure to stand. Not sure of the gas operated versions. The ones I have seen are heavier than the air operated models and quite a bit more expensive. If I were in the business, I think I would buy a gas powered compressor and use regular nailers. Then you can use the air for all the nail guns.

As far as missing the studs, you can certainly tell with a nail gun by the "bounce" and the depth of the set. As someone commented you really shouldn't blame a nail gun for poor craftsmanship - missing means you didn't measure/mark your work.

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

#14

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

Charles Jackson III

I have a small 1.5 gallon compressor that I use for my finish and brad nailer.

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

#15

You will probably need a bigger compressor.

Keith Newton

With the small compressor, you will probably get to take a couple of shots, then need to wait for it to catch up. So the internal combustion gun makes more sense for you now, unless you want to buy another compressor to go with the larger air powered nailer.

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

#16

Re: You will probably need a bigger compressor.

Charles Jackson III

I really hate buying another compressor.

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

#17

Michael

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

Michael

I am no contractor but the last project I completed on my home, a sunroom addition, a nail gun would have been nice. Imagine nailing exterior sheathing, holding the panel, a hammer, and nails, and only having the use of the 2 hands I was issued. A nail gun sure would have been nice, even if it collects dust for most of the year. You could always consider renting a nailer and compressor if it is available.

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

#18

Working Alone?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I have done plenty of carpentry by my lonesome (at home). Believe me, when you are holding a long 2X4 with one hand on a ladder you learn the value of a framing gun.

T.

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

#19

Both!

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

I have bulit several additions and a large shed using framing nailers. They work very well and make a nice strong joint if used correctly. The other posters are right - the nailer is only as good as the person pulling the trigger.

I found that for rough framing, the 2x's and such, it is hard to beat a nailer. Same for the sheathing, but watch for a bent rafter. Even with chalk lines you can miss if the rafter isn't straight. On my first addition I carefully chalked all the lines by starting a nail at the top and bottom of each rafter. I stretched a string between the nails,snapped the lines and carefully set the nails on the line. I don't remember feeling any bounce from missed nails, but the inspector pointed out a couple of rows of missed nails. Of course, I had to renail them to make it right.

All of this said, there are many times where a nailer just won't work. I found that on parts of the roof that the nailer was too awkward and posed a safety problem on the ladder. In places where I just needed one nail, it was usually easier to just get a hammer and nail out. It took less time than it would to go get the nailer.

Both have their place and I wouldn't want to be without either.

Robby Wright

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

#20

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

Brian from Monument

If this is the nailer I think your talking about there is a limitation on altitude that it can be used at.

My house is at 7000 feet and I read that one of the paslode nailers could not be used above 5000 feet.

So I have one of the nailers that uses compressed air.

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

#21

Re: They have their place.

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

Charles,

The battery may last for 6000 nails before charging but the gas/butane cylinders will not last that long.

The Paslode requires both a battery and a gas cylinder.

To help answer your question,you need to determine how much framing,sheathing,etc you are going to be doing.Also factor in the cost of the compressor,hoses,etc if you go with a conventional gun.

I'd bet some diligent searching on Ebay,Craigslist,pawn shops you can find a deal on a Paslode .

Even HD has returns on clearance now and then.

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

#22

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

Charles Jackson III

The highest mountain in Alabama is around 2000 something feet.

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

#23

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

Brian from Monument

Sounds like you wouldn't be affected by the altitude problem.

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

#24

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

TomD

I've had a framing nailer about 20 years now, and I really like it. I enjoy driving nails by hand almost as much as golf. To me the biggest advantage of a nailer is the ability to get a joint done while working alone, out of position, and with parts that might not survive the disruption of hammering. I understand how pros frame, but some of the more production oriented techniques are not solo work. I'm not lifting up a 20 foot wall that was fully framed, sheated and sided on the deck. I'm the guy building a stud wall in place, as they used to, or maybe dangling in some awkward position trying to fasten something. Sometimes nailing is a 4 hand job, hold on, hold the piece, hold the nail, hold the hammer. Sometimes with a gun you can get that down to 2 hands again.

So the advantage to me is in the flexibility it can allow me to work things out when working alone.

A hose is sometimes useful since it can be a tether to the gun.

Also, to state the obvious, some jobs require driving a lot of nails, like shingling, or maybe decking. Single and older, one needs the production help a nail gun can provide at times.

Some jobs are faster and easier with a hammer. Tap, whack, tap, whack. In go the 16 penny nails.

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

#25

Re: Nail guns vs hammers for carpentry projects?

Ralph Lipeles

When I had my first addition to the house put on, 45 years ago I had too much details on the drawings so no framers would bid on the job. The contractor built the 24' by 29' addition by himself. He preassembled the walls flat on the deck and then raised them with wall jacks. That way he did not have to build the walls in place.

Ralph