OT- Here's the problem. I have a large Pine tree right beside my shop that sheds pine needles like it is raining needles. I have to periodically climb up and blow them off with a leaf blower to keep them from ruining the roof. My worser half doesn't like for me to do that. Also they clog the gutters, downspouts, and gutter guards. Then I have to completely clean them by hand. I am thinking about removing the gutters and letting the rain wash them off. Cutting the tree is not an option as it is on the property line Question is what are the pros and cons of not having gutters on a 24x 40 shop.
Is there a basement to this building or is it on a slab? It seems common around me for buildings to have gutters only if they have a foundation underground.
I'd probably opt for gutters in either case but if the building won't suffer any damage from the water falling from the roof, you might be OK.
You'll get more splashback onto the walls of the shop, requiring more frequent painting/maintenance on the siding.
If you get serious rainfall (as we do around here), you'll wind up with a little trench on the ground directly below the eaves, as water falling off the roof erodes the dirt.
Also, how's the grading around your shop? If it slopes away from the shop all around, a no-gutter approach is safer than if it's level to the shop.
Alternatives:
1. You can get various gutter "caps," some of which guarantee that they'll keep needles out. I'm trying one of these, strips of what looks like those plastic scouring pads (but a little more open "weave") that you glue into the gutter; jury is still out, mainly because I haven't had time to get out the ladder and go look.
2. Although it's a pricey choice, you can get a sort of horizontal louver arrangement to put in place of the gutter that, according to the advertising, causes the rain running off the roof to disperse as droplets rather than a stream of water.
Thanks . I had already thought about the trench and don't think it will be a problem but if it is I can handle that easier than climbing on the roof 4 times a year at my age(80). And I have a good slope on both sides. Any other downsides?
I do not believe any gutter guard scheme can defeat pine needles. They are amazing in what they can clog.
It is worth the effort to try a no gutter approach on a shop without a below ground foundation. A 2x4 barrier filled with stone between the drip line and the shop will prevent a trench and much of the debris from bounding up on the siding.
You can also fill that trench with 1/2" gravel as it grows. It doesn't sound like drainage is a problem but if it were you'd have to dig a sloped trench and then fill that with gravel to get the water away from the building.
I've never been fully convinced that gutters are the best way to deal with water problems, but then I live where there's enough relief to be able to arraign some drainage away from the building, and there are lots of places where that is not so easy. I've yet to see gutters anywhere that do not require considerable up keep when there are trees around.
Even though the main part of a tree is on another property, a property owner can, at least in these parts, trim any part of the tree that encroaches onto his property, without permission. Neighbor relations is another matter.
My neighbor has no gutters on his shop (I do, on mine.). What he did was dig down 3~4 inches under the eaves - out about a foot beyond the eaves - and put in coarse gravel. The rain falls off the roof, onto the gravel, and soaks in, leaving no trench. It also makes his mowing & edging easier.
When I re-roff (in a few years), I may remove the gutters and do the same.
+Doug, as a home owner I hate my gutters as much as anybody else. As a Home Inspector I highly recommend them. I have seen tens of thousands of dollars worth of damage done to houses because of the lack of gutters.
I call it rot and splash damage. Actually, its rot caused by splashing water. On frame houses I have found thousands of doors with water seeping in under them, rotting out the band and sill, subfloor and joists. The door jambs also rot.
It appears that any door that lacks sill flashing and gutters above will rot. If either is present the chances for rut under the door is reduced. If both are present the chances are reduced by about 80%. The other variable is the direction the wind blows. If the prevailing wind is toward the wall, the damage will be accelerated. If the winds blows out away from the wall, it carries the water out with it and minimizes the damage. Can's tell you how many neighborhoods there are where it is rotting under the doors on the back of the house on one side of the street, but not under the front doors, Across the street its rotting under the front doors, but not the back.
Another variable is how wide the overhangs are and how tall the walls are. There is a "drift" angle. We seldom see rot on second story window sills but often on first floor ones on two story houses. Wider overhangs decrease the amount of water that reach the wooden parts below.
Two messages to you. The other thing to consider is what the building is made of. If the materials are rot resistant such a masonry or vinyl siding, these things are less important. You may need to protect the wooden parts such as door frames and doors. A second possibility is to keep the gutters and install the gutter guards that look like solid sheets of metal or plastic with a rolled edge. Or replace the gutter with the "closed" ones like "Leaf Guard" or Englert. They are more expensive than open gutters, but they are guaranteed not to clog.
I just saw a garage yesterday with splash damage down one side.