Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Shop Vac advise, please -

Posts

Shop Vac advise, please -

#1

Shop Vac advise, please -

Ron in Eugen

I'm considering buying a new shop vac as I have had my current one for about 20 years and it just dosen't get the job done - duh. I can't afford the cost or shop space for a 'real' dust collector, but would like to get a vac that could really help with dust collection from the table saw and planner. I realize that no shop vac will not be as good as a real dust collector. Any and all input is welcome. Thank you for sharing your thoughts and experiences in advance.

Ron

Re: Shop Vac advise, please -

#2

Re: Shop Vac advise, please -

John McGaw (Bodger)

Can you give us an idea of what your budget might stretch to? There are some really fine super-efficient shop vacs out there but they tend to be seriously non-cheap. I've been very happy with my Fein Turbo II (old style with the HEPA option) for years but there are even better ones out there if you don't mind spending the money.

Re: Shop Vac advise, please -

#3

Re: Shop Vac advise, please -

Barry Irby

Both of those machines are problematic for dust collection. A cabinet saw might be easier, but a contractors saw needs some serious suction to do an efficient job of grabbing the dust. A planer generates a huge volume of chips and would stuff a smallish shop vac pretty quick. If I were doing this I would set up a trashcan separator for the planer. I have a Dewalt planer it does a pretty good job of throwing the chips, I think you could make a separator to go between it and the vac and take advantage of the larger capacity of the can, and they are easy to empty. I made one out of a Rubbermaid trash can and sometimes use it with my DC and it works well. Have not tried it with the shop vac, but I bet it would work well. I have an ancient Sears 32 gallon and a Rigid that is much smaller. I like both. I had a door buster special Shop Vac and it was a waste of money.

Re: Shop Vac advise, please -

#4

Re: Shop Vac advise, please -

George Colonel's Workshop

Good Afternoon Ron,

I augment my 1 1/2hp Bridgewood DC with two Ridgid 12 ga shop vacs. They take up lots of shop floor space, so I use one in each of my small shop rooms. I find the shop vacs do a good job evacuating dust from the router table fence, and dovetail/box joint jigs, and around my lathe. The shop vacs work well and last a long time: no complaints here. My newest one replaced a burned out Sears after 15 or 20 years. I prefer the 12 ga model since it can go a while without needing to be emptied. Consider What Barry said above. I agree.

George

Re: Shop Vac advise, please -

#5

JL

Re: Shop Vac advise, please -

JL

I can and do use my shop vacuum as a DC - for handheld routing or sanding. But IMO, a shop vac is NOT meant for continuous use. Maybe 1/2 hour at a time maximum, probably less. A shop vac does not have enough CFM to handle anything that produces large amount of dust (jointer, planer, etc.) or enough storage capacity.

I have a Ridgid - works well. Don't get the "door buster" specials - get the big guys. A Fein could probably go for longer times than the Ridgid - but if you could afford a fine, you could afford a 1 1/2 hp DC and a new shop vac.

Re: Shop Vac advise, please -

#6

Advice is worth what you pay for it...

doug f, san clemente, ca

but with that being said, the link below will show you what can be done for a couple hundred bucks, especially for a small shop.

Doug

http://www.julienlecomte.net/blog/2012/05/685/

Re: Shop Vac advise, please -

#7

Re: Shop Vac advise, please -

Ron in Eugen

Thanks for your thoughts and input. Sorry, didn't think about the added information being included. I currently use a Delta cabinet saw and would like to stay around or under the $200 number. The planner is, as I see it, always a problem unless you do have a DC system and not a shop vac. In my case the largest problem to deal with is the table saw even though I collect dust at the blade above the table. This particularly a problem when using soft wood or trimming a 'wee' bit off the edge of a board. Hope this added info is of some help. TNX again.

Re: Shop Vac advise, please -

#8

Re: Advice is worth what you pay for it...

Joseph Mulherin, sr

That Oneida mini dust collector is exactly the one I recently built for my own shop vac setup, and they move together as a unit. Use the 2.5" hoses all around, and also use the dust collector to clean up the floor around the shop. I also have the Shopsmith DC I bought several years ago which I use with the

Shopsmith when I am cutting with the table saw, but I think it is low on CFM....but it does do the job.

Cleaning the upper dust filter is a mess when I change out the plastic dust bag underneath.

Re: Shop Vac advise, please -

#9

Re: Shop Vac advise, please - *LINK*

mdclor

Ron, I don't have this unit and am generally leery of HF tools, but it seems to get decent reviews from owners. I don't think it would take any more floor space than a shop vac with separator and is (just barely) in your price range. Take a look and let us know your decision.


HF 2HP Dust Collector

Re: Shop Vac advise, please -

#10

What I would do...

John in NM

In fact what I do :D

I don't really find that vacs are much good for dust collection, outside of sanding and routing. They simply do not move enough air to really be effective with machinery (possibly excepting purpose built vacuum blade guards on a table saw - but even then you will still have to empty the cabinet). If you luck into a chop saw with a really good blade shroud you might find a vac will work there too.

So I just wear a mask when either wood type or quantity of dust bothers me. Just a 3M mask with the breather vent from Home Depot or where ever. That vent makes a huge difference in making a disposable mask effective - and I thank a member here (golfsteve I think it was) for convincing me to try one. I use the vac when sanding, there they are quite effective and extend the paper life considerably (2-3x at a guess). Also use a vac a lot for cleanup after machine use.

But I do understand that's not what a lot of people want to hear. I've simply not found that vacuums or even small DC's are worth the time to make them truly effective with machines, they simply do not move enough air to be effective at both chip and dust removal and preserving air quality. Now if you want to concentrate on air quality at the expense of larger chip removal, that may be possible.

So, from this point of view, really just about any vac will work ok. I have an expensive hose, they are more flexible and less annoying than the one that comes with the vacuum. I also plan to try one of the mini-cyclones to extend the time between filter cleaning/change. Aside from that, I don't really think there will be a lot of true choice in your price range. Once you get into the more expensive vac's the manufacturers start providing static pressure and cfm info, and you might be able to find one with a cast fan - the ones I've had fail all had cheap fans made of sheet metal, eventually the crimps and tabs that hold them together let go and the fan comes apart, pretty exciting when it happens, horrible noise :D

Re: Shop Vac advise, please -

#11

Re: Shop Vac advise, please - *LINK*

Lars Parrington

There's an interesting article on building a shop vac sized dust collector in progress at woodgears.ca. Might be worth checking out. It seems like a neat idea to me.

I've got a fein turbo that I love. I use a 1 micron filter in series with the cloth filter (not recommended by fein, but it works great). I use it for sanding and shop cleanup and small dust producers. Anything big I use a 1.5 hp DC with pleated filter.


http://woodgears.ca/dust_collector/blower.html