Re: Some elaboration
Bruce McCrory
Keith, Tom, All,
I didn't want to wear everyone out with details. I will add some. and elaborate, also..
I did use epoxy on a couple cedar and redwood fan-backs this summer. That stuff is tenacious! That's where my reaction to difference in the two glues came in. Titebond II happened to be available, and not so pricey as epoxy, so I was using it on the test/prototype wood. The wood is reclaimed fencing that acts like juvenile cedar but has no fragrance. I thought to use Titebond III for the final pieces.
The wood is not so much the question, as is how little penetration there is. Yes, there is wood fiber at the breaks--very thin, not even tissue thin. However, I would expect more leach into fibers, especially in such soft wood. Clamp pressure is enough for squeese-out, and some deformation of the wood.
When we used white and Elmer's Carpenter glue years ago, it was common to lay a thinned coat, immediately followed by full strength glue. I wondered if there was any merit to double gluing in this case?
I will try TBIII in the final pieces. I've never enjoyed working with polyurethanes, they're so slick and messy. The dried foam seems worse than PVA to remove, also.
Thanks again for your help.