Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Whimpy Titebond 11??

Posts

Whimpy Titebond 11??

#1

Whimpy Titebond 11??

Bruce McCrory

I have been messing around with some glues recently looking for something I can use on outdoor cedar. Western Red Cedar has a propensity to split easily. Well, the Titebond II I have been using straight from the nipple has little penetration into wood fibers. Breaking the joint is no more than what seems a light tap with a hammer. Before I thin and double glue, I thought to canvass you good folks.

Has anyone a recommendation for a water proof (or close to) glue with good penetration into wood fibers?

Thanks for your suggestions.

Re: Whimpy Titebond 11??

#2

Re: Whimpy Titebond 11??

Hal

I use Titebond III for everything. A little more expensive than II, but a bit more open time and billed as waterproof. I haven't tried it on redwood which may have some characteristics that require a different glue. Dunno.

Re: Whimpy Titebond 11??

#3

Re: Whimpy Titebond 11??

mdclor

+1 for Titebond III. However, have you looked closely at the breaks to see if it is the glue line that is breaking or is it the wood beside the glue line? My understanding is that even Titebond II should be stronger than the wood.

Re: Whimpy Titebond 11??

#4

Re: Whimpy Titebond 11??

Howard Acheson

Any of the aromatic cedars do not glue well with most adhesives. Try your adhesive on some non-aromatic woods like pine, oak or maple. Clamp tightly and let the glue fully harden for 48 hours. See if the adhesive still fails.

I think you problem is the wood, not the adhesive.

Re: Whimpy Titebond 11??

#5

Re: Also

Howard Acheson

According to Wiki, It glues well with epoxy resin or resorcinol adhesive.

Re: Whimpy Titebond 11??

#6

Re: Whimpy Titebond 11??

Thomas S Stockton

I'm not a huge fan of guerrilla glue mainly because it is overhyped, but this is one of the uses where it really shines. They sell really small containers cheap so it would be worth testing, otherwise I would try a good quality epoxy like west system or one of the others.

I used to work at a place that made outdoor redwood furniture and I would see failures where the joint would kinda peel apart leaving a thin layer of wood. Cedar isn't much different pretty soft and like you said prone to splitting.

Tom

Re: Whimpy Titebond 11??

#7

A couple of possibilities for cause

Keith Newton

Western Red Cedar is normally shipped green, and can be full of water, making it too wet for gluing, so be sure it is dry before you glue.

Also, joint preparation is always a good thing. Dull jointer knives will compress the top layer, keeping the glue from getting good penetration on clean undamaged cells. And lastly, these type of glues like both sides to be tight against each other, without a gap.

Epoxy on the other hand likes loosely fitted even rough surfaces give it a better mechanical grip, and not too much clamp pressure. But it would not like wet wood either.

How long did you let the glue dry when you broke it apart?

Re: Whimpy Titebond 11??

#8

Re: Some elaboration

Bruce McCrory

Keith, Tom, All,

I didn't want to wear everyone out with details. I will add some. and elaborate, also..

I did use epoxy on a couple cedar and redwood fan-backs this summer. That stuff is tenacious! That's where my reaction to difference in the two glues came in. Titebond II happened to be available, and not so pricey as epoxy, so I was using it on the test/prototype wood. The wood is reclaimed fencing that acts like juvenile cedar but has no fragrance. I thought to use Titebond III for the final pieces.

The wood is not so much the question, as is how little penetration there is. Yes, there is wood fiber at the breaks--very thin, not even tissue thin. However, I would expect more leach into fibers, especially in such soft wood. Clamp pressure is enough for squeese-out, and some deformation of the wood.

When we used white and Elmer's Carpenter glue years ago, it was common to lay a thinned coat, immediately followed by full strength glue. I wondered if there was any merit to double gluing in this case?

I will try TBIII in the final pieces. I've never enjoyed working with polyurethanes, they're so slick and messy. The dried foam seems worse than PVA to remove, also.

Thanks again for your help.

Re: Whimpy Titebond 11??

#9

Re: Some elaboration

RobCarr

>> When we used white and Elmer's Carpenter glue years ago, it was common to lay

>> a thinned coat, immediately followed by full strength glue. I wondered if there was

>> any merit to double gluing in this case?

I don't think that will work with any 'yellow' type of glue - that is a unique property of white glue.

Re: Whimpy Titebond 11??

#10

Re: So noted on my glue matrix

Bruce McCrory

Thanks, Rob.

Re: Whimpy Titebond 11??

#11

Bob

Re: Whimpy Titebond 11??

Bob

Try using Titebond III and wipe the joined surface with acetone. It works well on cypress so why not cedar/

Re: Whimpy Titebond 11??

#12

Ellis Walentine

Re: Whimpy Titebond 11??

Ellis Walentine

There is a physical reason for the lack of glue penetration. The following quote is from a publication called Growth, Properties and Use of Western Red Cedar, by Josefina S. Gonzalez...

Western red cedar heartwood is highly

impermeable to water and water-borne

chemicals. This con di tion is at trib ut ed to

crusty deposits in the membrane of bordered

pits (tracheid open ings that allow the passage

of fluids), thus impeding the inter-tracheid

fl uid move ment (Krahmer and Cote 1963)

and resisting fluid penetration of the wood.

Heavy deposits were noted in the heartwood,

but were also present in the sapwood in lesser

amounts (Krahmer and Cote 1963).

Personally, I've not had adhesion problems with PVA on western red cedar, but with woods that are acidic or full of aromatic extractives like this, I like to plane the gluing surfaces just prior to gluing, as I have seen crystallization and glazing on surfaces that have been exposed for a while. Maybe this technique would work for you. It might be worth making up a couple test samples.

Ellis

Re: Whimpy Titebond 11??

#13

Re: Whimpy Titebond 11??

Bruce McCrory

Sorry for my delay... I am redoing my desktop pc, with a new board. Grrrrrrrrr!!!!!!!!!!!! And, it has only been a year! When did software turn into Freddy Krueger's Revenge?

Ellis, I am supposed to be the one to find and file obscure information. I don't know how I could have missed the source of yours. ;)

Of course, Salts... And, Bob's wipe with acetone advice. I have only recently been using Titebond products; and cedar is a first, deliberate glue effort--never a fan (trusting) of exterior glue products. Anything earlier was only concerned with staining. I bet end-grain butt-glue attachments will be better with this material.