Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

What's with the crumby chucks????

Posts

What's with the crumby chucks????

#1

What's with the crumby chucks????

Barry Irby

My family gave me a 12 volt LION Bosch drill for Christmas. (and the matching impact driver, I already had the Multimax tool)

The chuck is a disappointment. Very difficult to get the bit to stay in it. It rattles loose and the bit falls out. It a rubber covered keyless chuck.

Recently bought a PC 18 volt Lion set. The drill also has a keyless chuck, this one knurled steel. Same thing. It rattles and the bit falls out. (The PC set is obviously not of the same quality as the Bosch tools.)

I have three Makita 12 volt cordless drills and a corded Dewalt one and have no trouble with any of them. So what's up with the new one's?

Re: What's with the crumby chucks????

#2

Re: What's with the crumby chucks????

Bayward

I have read and heard many people complaining about the new keyless chucks. Myself being one of the complainers.

Back around Christmas time I bought a new smaller and lighter Rigid 18V drill for the bench. One month later, and with light use, the chuck would not hold a bit. Home Depot swapped it for a new one and a week later the same thing again. This time Home Depot got one from a different lot number and it has been good.

I am well past the HD return policy but at least I have a Rigid service center somewhat close to the house. Hopefully I will not need to check them out.

Bob

Re: What's with the crumby chucks????

#3

Sounds like the loose nut on the handle end.

Keith Newton

Are you sure each time you change bits that the jaws are seated in the center of the flats of the hex?

I usually hold the new bit loosely in outer portion of my hand, while holding the chuck with my ring and little fingers, then motor forward to close the chuck. Sometimes it tries to grip out on the tips / corners of the hex heads. If I don't look to make sure it is seated right, it will vibrate out when it is torqued. After a quick inspection that the jaws are seating right, I can usually get about another 1/3 turn against the brake. Is that how you go about it?

Re: What's with the crumby chucks????

#4

Re: Sounds like the loose nut on the handle end.

Barry Irby

It could be technique, but I am 63 and have been dealing with chucks for about 50 of them. As I mentioned, I have at least four other keyless ones I have been using happily for at least ten years. And yes, I hold the bit in two fingers and and the chuck in two or three others and use the motor to spin it in. I have been known to get the bit between two jaws rather than gripped by all three, but that becomes rapidly apparent when you turn the drill on and discover the bit is on some wild eccentric path.

Incidentally, With the cheap Chinese bits I find they run much more accurately if you chuck them on the round parts of the shaft rather than on the flats. At least on some of mine, the flats are not ground very accurately and they have serious run-out, especially on the drill press.

Re: What's with the crumby chucks????

#5

Re: Sounds like the loose nut on the handle end.

Jesse Cloud

I'm a newbie with only 46 years experience using chucks. I do it pretty much the same way you do. I have had very bad experience with Bosch keyless chucks, but usually only after a couple of years. I had thought that they weren't putting quality into chucks figuring that customers were going to toss their drills once the batteries wouln't hold a charge. But after six months???

By the way, I replaced that Bosch a couple of years ago with another German brand, the one that this forum loves to hate, and I have never had a bit come loose from their keyless chuck. Keeping my fingers crossed.

Re: What's with the crumby chucks????

#6

Re: Sounds like the loose nut on the handle end.

Tony - Memphis

Well, I'm only 46 years old, so maybe I should just stay on the porch! Ha! I just bought a Hitachi set from Lowes last year (amazing deal - big drill little drill flashlight for ~$150?). The chucks in those work very well so far. I'm not a heavy user (if not for the deal I would not have a cordless). I do change bits a lot, but less now with the to drills. Before this, I had a DeWalt that had a good chuck. It didn't lock as good as the Hitachi's do though. Anyway, its frustrating to spend good money and things not be what you expected. Especially when you buy a brand that you think you can trust.

Tony

Re: What's with the crumby chucks????

#7

Re: Sounds like the loose nut on the handle end.

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Has anyone just thought to change the chuck out and use one that they are satisfied with?

Re: What's with the crumby chucks????

#8

Barry . . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

may have a handle on things and may even be something of a nut, but "loose" he's not.

:D