Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Heating and Cooling

Posts

Heating and Cooling

#1

Bob

Heating and Cooling

Bob

I suffered through the summer in my shop with the heat compounded by the fact I have 36 4 foot T-8 lights generating 32 Watts each for a constant 1200 Watts. I also keep the doors closed most of the time because of the noise and I don't want to disturb my neighbors. The heat I can take but the winter is coming and I don't like the cold so I want to come up with a heating solution that will not break the bank. My budget is about $1,500.00 tops. I have 100 AMP service and its all insulated and has 5/8 fire code sheet rock. My shop is 24X28 with 10 foot ceilings all suggestions are welcome for Heating and Cooling.

Re: Heating and Cooling

#2

Re: Heating and Cooling

John McGaw (Bodger)

Location? Alaska or Florida or someplace in between? If I lived in a cold climate and had access to gas service, I'd lean toward a ceiling-mounted gas-fired warehouse heater. A 50,000 BTU unit can be had for around $500 so even if you had to buy two and pay for the hookup you'd likely be within your budget. Of course that leaves you the problem for next year of what to do about the heat and humidity which are not only rough on people but on wood and tools.

Re: Heating and Cooling

#3

Re: Heating and Cooling *LINK*

mdclor

Bob, you might look at split AC/heat pump units. The link is to one such unit. This is not a suggestion since I have no first hand knowledge of the system. FWIW


Ductless Heat Pump Air Conditioner

Re: Heating and Cooling

#4

Re: Heating and Cooling

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Bob, this is just a suggestion...do not know if your local building inspector would approve...

Rig up a fan coil unit in one upper corner of your shop and run some hot water to it being circulated with a 1/6th HP circulating pump from a 40gal water heater. The heater can of course be either electric or gas....which would be cheaper.

We used these pumps on some rather expensive houses in the 80s and I did it on a doctor's office to his remote wash basins in his various exam rooms. Can be setup to be run via a room thermostat.

Water heater is regulated by its own thermostat, and stays warm all the time....does not have to be at 140 either...just mediumwarm.

Re: Heating and Cooling

#5

Re: Heating and Cooling

Barry Irby

Bob, aren't you in Virginia or nearby? If you are in a moderate climate like that the heat pump he suggested might work for you. 9000 BTU's might be a little small, bot some of those units are incredible. Not sure about LG for anything, but the other brands are good.

Just saw one of these demo'ed at out home inspector meeting. If your shop is well insulated and not too leaky a heat pump would be good, but they don't have rapid recovery so you would want to leave them on or at least not turned down too far and not too small. I was Impressed.

The gas heater is also a good idea, but does not give you AC.

Re: Heating and Cooling

#6

This won't help with the cooling, BUT *LINK*

Bruce, a MN Galoot

the heat is free (after building and installation)

The author says they maintain the shop at 65+ in Iowa in the winter. Granted, that may not be all that cold, depending on where you live.


Home-built passive solar panels for a shop

Re: Heating and Cooling

#7

Bob

All good suggestions

Bob

If my shop was bigger I would consider solar but I still have to think about cooling and over all climate control year round.

The hot water idea sounds like a good option for supplemental heat and I will look into that.

I need 1.3 ton for a heat pump, so maybe a 1 Ton unit will cut it. I guess I will call a HVAC guy tomorrow and see what they get to install one before I close in the ceiling.

Thanks for the suggestions.

Re: Heating and Cooling

#8

Bob

Re: Heating and Cooling

Bob

Thanks, I will look into it and see how the operating cost compares.

Re: Heating and Cooling

#9

Insulation First

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

When I built my new shop last year I decided to take the plunge and get blown-in celulose insulation. My walls, roof etc. all have blown-in celulose. I have an HVAC system but I am amazed how little I use it.

This summer with our horrible heat the shop commonly was upper 70's or low 80's. I would turn on the AC for a little bit and the insulation retained that cooler temp for hours.

In January (I'm in Illinois) the only time I ran the furnace was when I was working. The temps rarely went much below 50 degrees.

Yes, the insulation is a cost. But I swear by it now. It will pay for itself quickly.

T.

Re: Heating and Cooling

#10

Bob

Re: Insulation First

Bob

Unfortunately the walls are up and insulated already. Cost is of concern and I did it all myself so I could afford heat and air.

Re: Heating and Cooling

#11

Bob

Re: Heating and Cooling

Bob

I got a quot today. The guy wants $3,500 to install a 2 Ton ductless split unit. Seems a little much right?

Re: Heating and Cooling

#12

Consider this

Henry Higginbotham

How often do you work in your shop? Now, how often to you really have to work in your shop?

Here's what I'm getting at: That size shop, well insulated, can be cooled most days with a 5000 to 8000 btu window unit. Not when it's 188 degrees outside, but do you really have to use the shop that day? Same with heating.

The difference in price between your recent quote and a window unit that heats and cools will buy a fairly nice stack of prime northern cherry, or a nice used 12" jointer, or a CD paying 0.008% (OK, maybe not that one), or lots of other things you can use on those few days you're not in the too cold/too hot shop.

Your shop is similar to mine in dimension and insulation, and a 5000 btu window unit works the great majority of the time here in Alabama.

Just a thought.

Re: Heating and Cooling

#13

Bob

Re: Consider this

Bob

I was looking at this unit Samsung Model#: AQV18NSD

http://ecomfort.com/aqv18nsd-neo-forte-wall-mounted-mini-split-heat-pump-18000-btu-4710.html

its $2100.00 without the lines, box and a few feet of wire and its the same one that the guy gave me a $3500 price on.

I mean come on $800.00 for a days work?

Re: Heating and Cooling

#14

Re: Consider this

mdclor

Bob, I cool my shop by opening a couple windows and running the exhaust fan in the spray room at night, then close it up during the day. However, I don't have the humidity that you enjoy. You might be satisfied with a smaller unit for cooling.

Re: Heating and Cooling

#15

Re: Consider this

Jason Waters

Have you considered a through the wall heat pump, similiar to a window unit A/C? (Old ones were A/C and heat strips, you don't want that) You see them at Hotels. You can frame in a box through the wall, and connect with a 240V plug usually, no need for that pesky installation cost. You might however, need a permit....

Re: Heating and Cooling

#16

Bob

Re: Consider this

Bob

I figured out that I need a 1.3 TON unit or 17,000 BTU st least thats what I calculated it at. "Through the wall heat pumps" I am woundering what the day to day cost will be for one vs. a split 2 Ton unit. I spend an average of 6 hours a day in my shop so I don't want to be penny wise and dollar foolish. I cant seem to find a 18,000 BTU through the wall unit though. I have been reading reviews and asking around and everyone seems to say go with a name brand.

Re: Heating and Cooling

#17

Re: Heating and Cooling

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Bob, I don't know what your level of expertise is but if you have the room upstairs, you could self install a regular gas fired furnace with central air. In my area we have a discount place that sells overstock, dented etc. furnaces and air systems. I did spend a bit more than you are discussing (around $2000 in material and $100 for air charge) but the operating costs are very low compared to most other type systems. My shop is 30 X 30 with 10' ceiling and the trusses were made to allow me a partial (about 10 X 30 X 8' room upstairs with knee-walls. I installed my unit upstairs with a single air return in the ceiling and 6 ~ 6" runs to the perimeter of the shop then buried the runs in the insulation. The furnace has a sealed combustion chamber and is vented with pvc pipe for both intake and exhaust air. As I have a lot of cast iron in the shop and also store paint etc. that could freeze I keep the shop heated and air conditioned year around for less than $50 a month.

Re: Heating and Cooling

#18

Bob

Re: Heating and Cooling

Bob

No gas here only propane and I would have to have it inspected I wish that was my option I would do it. I am only at 24 X 28. I have a few more guys coming out this week. It looks like its going to be a bit more then I had hoped but Im not paying 3500 dollars.

Re: Heating and Cooling

#19

Re: Heating and Cooling

Pat Riley

Bob,

I had the same problem about 8 years ago. I went about it a bit differently.

I mounted a propane shop heater at the ceiling:

http://www.northerntool.com/shop/tools/product_200577748_200577748#

And used the vent kit that you can purchase along with it. It exhausts all the combustion air to the outside so there is no water vapor buildup to rust your tools.

Then I got a regulator and extension hose:

http://www.northerntool.com/shop/tools/product_53127_53127

http://www.northerntool.com/shop/tools/product_200332727_200332727

And used a large portable propane bottle to supply it.

I had to fill it every week or so, but it wasn't all that expensive a heating bill. For cooling I bought a small window mounted AC unit at Costco and cut a custom hole for it high in the back wall. It was a bit of a hassle to get all up and running, but in the end the overall cost was less than $1000.

Something to consider at least. And there was no need for inspection.

Re: Heating and Cooling

#20

Bob

Re: Heating and Cooling

Bob

WOW 50,000 BTU how big is your shop. How big of a tank do you use. I live in a gated comunity and I would have to get a permit do you think that would pass? (standard building cods) I like the price tag.

Re: Heating and Cooling

#21

Re: Consider this

Jason Waters

I understand your concern about penny wise, pound foolish.

I usually look on grainger to get an idea of what basic units cost. The largest through wall I found is 12,000 btu, so maybe it's not for you. I'd be more concerned about the heat than cooling capability. I noticed in another post that you are in a gated community, and many do not allow through the wall units (ie, window units). I don't live in a gated community, and I can't have one.

The mini split systems you are looking at are good. Seems like you could find someone to install for less. Most are probably made in China. Grainger had a unit for about $1800, so $2100 seems right, particularly for a Samsung name.

I would think you could find someone to do this install for $500-600, as some mini units are precharged. But you will have to shop around, it won't be one of the big boy advertisers. Usually you can get a home unit installed for about $1000 over the cost of the unit, including some duct transition to the unit, and hook up wire. Major changes, or putting one in an attic will cost more.

That's been my experience, but I would think a mini unit would be easy to install.

I know someone who put in a new A/C last year, and called 3 Trane dealers (in addition to a few others) here in the Tampa bay area. The cheapest by $1,500 for the same unit acted the most professional during the quote, and performed everything fine. It pays to shop around. It was more than 25% savings.

Re: Heating and Cooling

#22

Bob

Re: Consider this

Bob

Thanks Jason. I lived in New Port Richey and about 2 years ago I had a 3 ton Train installer for $4K they took out the old one puled all the ducts out and put everything new breaker and thermostat included. I moved to VA last Nov

Labor is very hi here but then the houing market is much better the house I bought has gone up in value $1000 in value as compaired to the house in FL which lost another 5K.

Re: Heating and Cooling

#23

Re: Consider this

Jason Waters

Bob,

that's where I actually am. that's why I'm still in my house. I'm not upside down, well I don't think I am, but I bought a while ago. Let me know next time you are down and maybe we can have dinner or a beer.

Jason

Re: Heating and Cooling

#24

Bob

Re: Consider this

Bob

I took a short sale and lost a lot but it was worth it to leave Fl. I don't have any plans to return but if I do we can have breakfist at Jimmy's I was a regular there for 6 years every day just about.

Bob

Re: Heating and Cooling

#25

Re: Heating and Cooling

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Bob, that Maxx seems to be the one you should consider. They also have one at 60k at $450 and another at 80k btus at $500.

So, with the savings you are going to have by using one of these units....go buy a 2HP A/C and install it in the wall or window and just be comfortable at reasonable costs.