His article in September Woodshop News - "Shellac as a sealer? It's all hype" reveals that all I've learned from reading about shellac for the past four decades is mostly just marketing hype. His conclusion is that shellac is great for refinishing work, but dosen't have much place in new construction. Oh well, I'm too old to learn something new so I guess I'll stick to what I know - even if it is wrong. (I looked online - Sep is not posted there yet.)
I took a course from Flexner some years ago at Peter Korn's school and learned a lot about finishing. I also went to CT Valley School on finishing taught by Teri Masachi. On new wood she recommend sealer coats of dewaxed shellac, specifically Zinsser's Seal Coat prior to stain (but not dye stains) and top coats, scuff sanding between coats. It reduces blotching (as with cherry and pine) and helps give a smooth finish. So there.
He was quite specific about where not to use shellac. To summarize, it makes no sense to seal with shellac when the top coat provides a sealing function, for example polyurethane over bare wood, or under lacquer where a lacquer sealer is available.
Personally, dewaxed shellac is an integral part of every flat wood finish I do. It is just too useful as a foundation to ever abandon. It is unmatched either as a sanding sealer, toner, or conditioner.
I saw a bumper sticker the other day "Don't believe everything you think." Wish I knew where to get one.
I will agree (mostly) with Bob, with Bill's clarifications. There are, however, times when a topcoat will penetrate unevenly into bare wood, and shellac evens that out. More importantly, there are times when a glaze would meld into the coat below and 'muddy' the color, shellac will usually help with that.
Lately, I have found shellac often to be an ineffective sealer against lacquer. Who knows what is in that stuff these days, probably some alcohol, because the lacquer seems to seep right through the shellac and mess up what lies below.
On any new finishing schedule, I use the technique Teri teaches. Find a scrap board of the same wood, put the first product in the schedule on, apply a bit of tape, add the second product to the rest of the board, more tape, repeat until all products are on the test board. This will show the effect of each product clearly. I am often surprised.
Kudos to John on that good NM country know-how, "If it works for you, don't let the expert talk you out of it."
Since I don't use varnish or conversion varnish, I never tried it so don't know.
When using lacquer, both solvent and acrylic, I apply fresh dewaxed shellac in tones from near-water white to dark Garnet, depending on the wood, as a sanding sealer, a color balancer or toner, and for porosity control.
IMHO, with the addition of TransTint dyes and LPLV spray application, it is unsurpassed as a means to match the color of a new piece to existing furniture in the same room, a task I'm often asked to do. Properly applied, it can be top-coated with anything, and it solves or prevents most any issue with top coat adhesion.
I have been using Charles Neils Blotch control (on my second gallon. sold by the quart) I used it on cherry, pine and now I use it on everything its the best I have found to date.
In the case of lacquer, what properties of tinted shellac are preferable to tinted lacquer when the top coat is to be lacquer? I am considering returning to spraying some lacquer so I am interested in these details. I have been finishing with varnish (regular and conversion) for many years for durability.
What does this mean? I don't understand the problem.
The first coat of anything has uneven penetration, including shellac. This fact is the basis of wash coating with anything from thin glue to thin shellac or thin lacquer. When I use the thinned top coat for a sealer (what Bob is advocating rather than shellac) the first coat penetrates the open pore areas and lays on the dense areas. Then one scuff sands and applies one or two additional coats depending on the desired build and in my hands all is well.
>>>> I have found shellac often to be an ineffective sealer against lacquer.
Lacquer thinner is primarily or heavily alcohol. However, there is no universal formula for lacquer thinner. The lacquer thinner you buy in a store catering to automotive finishers will be "hotter" than stuff you buy in a consumer store like Home Depot.
A lacquer top coat over shellac will partially or wholly dissolve shellac.
I don't think there is a problem. All I'm saying is that shellac is a valid sealer, among many others. Personally, I find it convenient and use it often. If diluting glue or topcoat is what you like, please enjoy it!
>>>> What does this mean? I don't understand the problem.
The first coat of anything has uneven penetration, including shellac. This fact is the basis of wash coating with anything from thin glue to thin shellac or thin lacquer. When I use the thinned top coat for a sealer (what Bob is advocating rather than shellac) the first coat penetrates the open pore areas and lays on the dense areas. Then one scuff sands and applies one or two additional coats depending on the desired build and in my hands all is well.
Bill, I couldn't agree with you more. For oil based finishes, a thinned top coat will perform the "sealing" function as well or better than shellac. Unless there is some sort of contamination on the wood, there is no need to apply shellac.
Shellac is greatly over-hyped and over used. I've been in numerous finishing shops and rarely have I seen shellac applied unless there was a specific problem being addressed.
I think most would agree that what you said is what Bob said. To summarize the article, shellac has many valid applications but it is unnecessary to use under some products on new wood, polyurethane as one example quoted.
most of all for his unvarnished ( un shellaced?) opinions. I'm gonna keep doing what works for me. One issue, in particular, which wasn't mentioned - finishing inside of drawers and casework. I'm not a fan of unfinished wood inside drawers and shellac is the best solution for this.
Tinting/toning with shellac is superior because of its ease and reversibility. In addition to the natural color range available for dry shellac, shellac can be easily tinted to any degree required using concentrated TransTint dyes.
Since the dye is "locked" in the coating, if you go too strong, a simple alcohol bath will remove some or all of the application; far easier than actually dying the wood. Plus, I would not like having to use that much lacquer thinner to remove a wrongly tinted lacquer.
When using shellac with dye to tint/tone a piece, I always always use freshly mixed Ultra Pale shellac so that the initial color of the resin doesn't interfere with my dye color choice(s). I used to use Zinnser's SealCoat, a dewaxed very pale ready-mix shellac, however I "lucked" into a batch bought from a big box that was well past its useful life; convenient, but since they quit using "born-on" dates on the cans, I can't trust the product's age and have decided to return to mixing my own as needed.