Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Problems Finishing Maple

Posts

Problems Finishing Maple

#1

Problems Finishing Maple

Chuck

I'm trying for stain some maple drawer fronts for a dresser. I have sanded them down to 220 (320 on the ends) and every time I apply stain I get black spots & black lines. They look terrible.

I tried a coat of seal-coat prior to the stain, but then can't get much color from the stain.

I see all this nice even colored maple furniture, how do you do it?

Re: Problems Finishing Maple

#2

Questions

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

1. What kind of stain are you using?

2. Can you post a close-up photo of the problems?

If, for instance, you're not cleaning the surface very well between grits and/or not following good grit progression, part of your problem could be stray sanding marks. Pigment stain will pick up and amplify any stray scratches, whereas dye stain, will not.

3. If you're not doing a grain-raise and light abrasion prior to application, you may also be dealing with some abrasive "glazing" that will tend hid defects until they pop out during finishing.

Re: Problems Finishing Maple

#3

Re: Questions

Chuck

The Stain is a can of Cabot that I picked up at Lowes. I believe it is mostly dye since I don't stir up much mud off the bottome of the can.

I can't provide a photo of the problem at this time, I have already re-sanded the drawer front.

As far as grit progression: 80, 100, 120, 150, 180, 220

I use a random orbital sander all the way to 220 and then hand sand with 220.

It's not swirl marks from the sander that are giving me problems.

I intinded to raise the grain with the stain, then sand.

The dark marks go in a ways, I have to start over with the 80 grit to get the boards clean again.

Re: Problems Finishing Maple

#4

Steps

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

What you didn't mention is careful vacuuming between grits. Abrasive papers shed grit during sanding, and if you don't remove them when you change grits they'll continue making scratches at the courser size. That you have to go to 80 grits to get things "clean" again suggests this is part of your problem.

Cabot's stain is a tung oil product that uses a fair amount of pigment for color-fastness. If you're looking for an even tone rather than highlighted grain, you'd do better to buy or make some NGR dye stain. TransTint dye concentrate in alcohol will do very well on maple. It's available from Rockler or you can go direct to Jeff Jewitt at homesteadfinishing.com. You can also pose your question and problem to him. Great guy.

Re: Problems Finishing Maple

#5

Re: Problems Finishing Maple

Dick Coers

Mark is giving good advice. As far as all that nice looking stained maple furniture, they don' buy their stain at Lowes is the big answer. Borgs don't carry good stain, they carry easy to use stain. Go to a good Sherwin Williams or similar that carries professional stains. Production furniture factories use dyes, washes, glazes, etc......Usually a dye first, then maybe a wiping stain, or dye then wash coat of sealer, then toner............Lots of color schedules, but they aren't starting with cheap wiping stain for the first color coat.

Re: Problems Finishing Maple

#6

Re: Problems Finishing Maple

Tony - Memphis

I built a tea table out of curly maple a while back. I used a water based dye stain (honey amber from Lockwood or Moser - ?). I do usually raise the grain first with water. After the dye, I applied a wash coat of shellac (seal coat thinned). After that, I glazed with a brown mahogany gel stain very lightly. I then applied my clear coat, which was gel poly. I don't normaly sand past 320 or so and I try to remember to pre wet the end grain so it doesn't darken as much (doesn't always work anyway). You might try some dyes. They aren't hard to use and you can adjust the color without muddying up the wood. Lee Vally is a good source for Lockwood dye or you can get it direct. You might take a look at Glen Huey's techniques for maple - his maple finish is beautiful. Sorry you are having trouble. I feel your pain. I'm finishing a veneered top and the nice glossy finish has pointed out some bubbles! Then I have to try and match the base to the top (lots of different woods involved). I worked with various dyes all weekend. Little of this...little of that....

If you Google finishing maple, there have been multiple articels on the subject. I think Lonnie Bird wrote one that was pretty good.

Tony

Re: Problems Finishing Maple

#7

JL

Re: Problems Finishing Maple

JL

I usually do what Mark recommends (sort of). I use Transtint dye in alcohol.

When I sand, I usually vacuum or brush between grits - but mostly I have my ROS hooked up to my shop vac, so I sometimes don't bother. As I use alcohol, I usually raise the grain w/ water first. I usually use 90+% isopropyl alcohol as it evaporates more slowly.

Re: Problems Finishing Maple

#8

Darker colors

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

If you want darker tones, don't sand to 220. Stop at 180 or even 150. Maple doesn't absorb much stain, it mostly coats the surface. Leaving the surface slightly rougher will make it hold more color.

You may need to use a pre-stain wood conditioner sold at the same Borgs. Follow the directions on the can and you will get a more even stain with less blotches.

Lee