Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Diamonds and sharpening

Posts

Diamonds and sharpening

#1

Diamonds and sharpening

Bill Tindall

I had a productive chat with the person in the EzeLap diamond sharpening products booth. As an aside, diamonds were everywhere at IWF. GE has a process for making a diamond film. It can then be cut into small pieces and low temperature brazed to the face of a carbide cutter. Tool edge life increases 100 fold more than carbide!

Think diamonds are exotic? In large quantity single crystal diamond costs 15 cents per gram while the better performing polycrystalline diamond is 50 cents. The cost of the diamond on our sharpening products is almost insignificant. Cheap sharpening products have single crystal diamond while faster cutting, longer lived products have polycrystalline diamond.

Diamond sharping plates are made by etching holes in a substrate, filling the holes with diamond particles and then nickle plating the substrate to bond the diamonds to the plate.

At the show one could buy a 3 x 12" diamond plate for $60. It is the cheapest, fastest route to a sharp edge.

Re: Diamonds and sharpening

#2

Bob

Re: Diamonds and sharpening

Bob

What does that relate to in the grit world? Is it 1000, 4000, or 8000 I use water stones and have 1000 and 4000 I hope to get 8000 soon. BUT I would get a dimond stone if it was the same as the water stones.

Re: Diamonds and sharpening

#3

Re: Diamonds and sharpening

Ralph Lipeles

The tan ones are 8000

Re: Diamonds and sharpening

#4

Bob

Re: Diamonds and sharpening

Bob

Really? I understand dimonds cut better then water stones and as a result they are faster? How about the cost?

Re: Diamonds and sharpening

#5

Re: Diamonds OT departure

Gary Smyth

After reading Bill's post. Remember spending a month's pay for that diamond ring you bought?? Keep in mind that .02 grams = 1 carat. The absence of rarity supports a story I got from a gemologist (he was in the oil business, not jewelry) who told me that gem quality diamonds (except for the largest) ought to cost no more than $20 a carat. His opinon was that cutting and polishing should triple that price, but nothing like the cost that DeBeers used to charge and award to "only special DeBeers" gem buyers who had no choice of what DeBeers would "award" them in an annual package. That stranglehold was largely broken when Canada, Russia, Brazil, and Australia began mining gem quality diamonds -- as well as lots more (numerically) of the industrial type. Now DeBeers has taken steps to control the market for gem quality once again by threat and exclusive contracts with Antwerp and Indian cutters and polishers. Still, quality diamonds are not as rare (and should not be as expensive) as they once were thought by the general public to be. Also, check out a product called Moissanite which is manufactured and only the slightest bit less hard than a diamond, with better reflection and under half the price. Big industry and jewelry manufacturers are looking at them as a alternative. Industrial quality Moissanite are not diamond, but harder than everything else and as Bill pointed out, the industrial quality is much easier on the pocketbook.

Re: Diamonds and sharpening

#7

Moissanite...

John in NM

Is nothing more that silicon carbide :D

I agree that gem diamonds are vastly overpriced, though perhaps not to the extent your oil gemologist friend thinks. The breakup of the Soviet Union in the early 1990's was reputed to give DeBeers a lot to worry about, as there were thought to be a huge quantity of gem quality diamonds hoarded by the Soviets, and the fear was that they would flood the market and crash prices. Same thing happened with the discovery of the Yellow Knife district in Canada and it's purchase by BHP rather than DeBeers. What always happens though, is that the new operators in the industry quickly figure out that they'll make more in the long term by following DeBeers' lead than through hostile competition :D

Better off spending the same money on a really nice ruby, sapphire, or emerald, IMHO.

Five carats per gram, btw, as Bill said.

Re: Diamonds and sharpening

#8

Re: Diamonds OT departure *LINK*

William Duffield

Moissanite?

I (and all the galoots on OldTools) have been using that stuff for years, for sharpening tool steel, for sanding furniture, and for rubbing out finishes! It's nothing more than Silicon Carbide (SiC), the abrasive in Norton's SandWet wet/dry sandpaper.

The quality in diamond that lights up your lover's eyes is refractive, more so than reflective. If you want reflective, just use silver. It's a lot cheaper.

Exotic, and hard, doesn't stop with polycrystaline diamond. If you follow the links in some of the comments to the linked article, it gets even more interesting.

Of course, right now, crushing fullerenes between diamond anvils yields only one bit of grit at a time, so it is sure to be a while before Joel starts carrying stones made from anything like this.


New Forms of Carbon

Re: Diamonds and sharpening

#9

The trouble with mesh sizes... *LINK*

John in NM

Is that when they get fine enough they become quite hard to characterize accurately. There are also many "standards" for mesh sizes that do not quite agree - because the gauge of wire used to make the mesh starts having a huge influence on the number of holes per inch once you get past 600 mesh or so, and thus each early manufacturer of mesh sieves had different fine screens.

However, if you use micron instead the figure used is the actual mean diameter of the grit, so it's much more consistent. The conversion I'm most used to is 1 micron = 14,000 grit - that is more or less the standard. For sharpening purposes, I very much doubt that anything finer than 5 micron (4,500 grit) would be necessary, but I'm sure there are those who feel differently about it.

How waterstone numbers line up with all this I can't say, just not into them enough to do the research. In the end it just comes down to results.


Micron vs. grit

Re: Diamonds and sharpening

#10

I'm a little dubious of their results...

John in NM

But only because the hardness data seems to be based on a single, accidental, data point with no theory as to the mechanism for the hardness of the material. I would agree with the mineralogist that they quoted, that the expectation is the isometric crystalline solid would be harder.

I would take a guess that there is something about this new material that is not so much harder as less brittle and almost as hard as diamond. The weakness of diamond is it's easy cleavage (fracture) along certain planes in the crystal matrix. This is much of the reason polycrystalline diamond grit lasts longer - if the crystals are oriented randomly to one another, it reduces their tendency to fracture into ever smaller grit under the pressure of use.

Incidentally, graphite is almost as hard as diamond in two crystal directions but cleaves very easily in the other, making it a fantastic lubricant.

Re: Diamonds and sharpening

#11

You're correct.  I absolutely

Gary Smyth

know better. I checked that post twice and did one edit and I still ignored that decimal point. That's how rockets sometimes blow up on the pad. Duh.