I am considering purchasing a Steel City 40200H 13 inch planer.I purchased another brand yesterday it planed very well,but threw as many chips out the back as into the dust 2 1/2" dust collector(which worked well on my old unit) So it will go back Monday. I've read every review on the 40200H I can find,and as usual most reviews were of little help.I will be planing 400 to 600 BF a year of hardwoods from Butternut to Hickory.I'm not expecting perfection but I'd like to have decent surfacing,minimal snipe and a reliable machine.If anyone out the has or is familiar with this machine I would sure like have any info either positive or negative. Thank you.
Have you looked at the Dewalt dw735 ? It is in the price range of the Steel City planer you are looking at if you add the infeed and outfeed extensions to the Dewalt.
With my dw735 I do not plane any where near the board footage you are estimating. I do plane quite a bit for a craft and hobby shop though and I get real good results from the Dewalt. A bit of snipe when doing real short boards, <14", though. It is easy to almost eliminate the snipe on those short boards by gently lifting the leading edge of the board as it comes out the back of the planer.
Hi Bill, I have little experience with bench top planers but from what I see with the ones that friends have I would not own one in fact a lot of them come to me with there boards. I had a shop in a one car garage and I found a 20" Grizzly for the same price as a new bench top model and bought it. That was 5 years ago and I am so glad I took the step even though I did not have the room. You should have no trouble finding one in the six to eight hundred dollar range. I have put at least 2000 board feet through it and no snip its all in the set up.
It looks to be identical to my Ridgid except that it has a helix head whereas the Ridgid has 3 blades. I am somewhat pleased with its performance although I don't use it nearly as often as you plan. Get a lot of tearout at reverse grain or knots and the blades are very easily chipped and then leave "lines" in the finished product. I can only assume the helix head would take care of these issues. The rollers seem to build up dust and cause slippage every so often so you will have to keep them cleaned. This may be a typical problem with benchtop planers but this is only my first so it is all I know.
As for Steel City itself, my experience was not so great. I purchased their 17" drill press but the capacitor was bad on the motor. Had to pull teeth to get it resolved before they finally sent me a new motor about 2 months later. The armature vibrated so bad I ended up swapping it with the one in the old motor. A little better but not great. Seems to be working fine now but should not have been that hard to resolve the issue. This said, I hope you don't have problems with your new machine and have to go through what I did.
Don't get me wrong. I have a 5 hp Cabinet saw and an 8" Industrial jointer from Steel City. I like them both and would recommend them. I've put a lot of lumber through my DW735 and I really like it. I just don't know enough about the Steel City planer.
Another thought - are the inserts available in carbide as opposed to HSS?
I second the motion to look at stationary planers. I have an older Dewalt (733, I think), but my son bought me a 20 stationary from Wilke as a retirement gift about 5 years ago. He also purchased a Byrd head for the unit. There is no comparison between the benchtop and stationary units in my opinion. I have absolutely no snipe with the stationary unit. It is MUCH quieter, and the chip removal is almost 100% (tied to my 3hp Griz cyclone). I thought I might still use the bench top occasionally, but it has not been turned on since the stationary has been there. The thickness is much easier to adjust, and the boards are almost perfectly flat (+/- .002" parallel across the width). Mine came with a mobile base so really doesn't take up much more room than the bench-top with stand. The cost differential is not great between a smaller stationary and a good bench-top.
If you can afford it, I would really look at adding some money for either the segmented Grizzly or Byrd head as the amount of material you are estimating would require quite a bit of either blade replacement or sharpening and the carbide inserts would not even show wear at that time. Also the carbide head almost eliminates any tear-out. The carbide inserts are a breeze to set up - no measuring - no adjustment and have 4 sides to use.
I want to thank everyone for the input.I know I need a floor model planer but it would be impossible to crowd it into my tiny shop.So I made a couple of decisions.
!. To purchase a 735, and extension tables.
2. To stop planing lumber for other people.This should cut my planing load to less than half.
I went to Lowes returned the other unit and picked up the 735.Nice to deal with someone semi-local.I ran a couple of boards through with out the dust collector, that fan is just short of hurricane velocity.Boards were smooth and uniform thickness.
One more question,have any of you resharpened the 735 blades?I resharpened the blades on my old work horse Rigid 13" and they worked fine for most work.I kept a new set for serious projects
AFAIK, the 735's blades are not resharpenable, because there is no height adjustment in the machine. You use them until they dull, turn them over, use them until the other side dulls, and finally throw them in your tool steel scrap box.
The last time I looked, the DW-735 was the only "lunchbox" planer that Byrd makes helical heads for.
Your analysis on no height adjustment is correct,and is what the Rigid Tech people told me 7 or 8 years ago and also something about the blades being too thin(which I don't understand)I talked to a local machine shop and they said it was a ploy to sell more blades.He points out that after each sharpening the blades would be slightly narrower thus after a while making the depth stops inaccurate.He works on equipment for local saw mills(which produce many million of B/F of hardwoods per year) so I trust his judgement as far as the blades I've been using.I am guessing the original blades have been sharpened 15 or so times and still do a good job.I do use new blades on some furniture projects ,but honestly can't tell much difference.I will resharpen the 735 blades and let everyone no how it turns out.I would still like hear from anyone who has actually resharpened 735 blades
Of course, you are correct. A competent sharpening service can resharpen them, if they want the hassle.
The other side of the coin is that the manufacturer is concerned that the same precise amount of steel must be removed from each blade, because the blade height is not individually adjustable in the planer. If a sharpening service does not realize this, and relies on the user being able to adjust the heights on reinstallation, the blades will perform less than satisfactorily. This might lead to complaints against the manufacturer, instead of the sharpening service. So, if the customer wants the convenience of "set and forget," he pays for it with higher replacement costs. Evidently that is what DeWalt's market research has decided most of their customers want. Note that the earlier, less capable, 733, with resharpenable blades was replaced with the non-adjustable blade model 734, and the 733 was discontinued, even though setting its blades is a lot easier than setting the blades on a Delta DJ-20 joiner, for example, with gib screws to adjust the blade heights. One of these days, I'm going to get a Byrd Shelix head for my DJ-20.
This discussion could continue for a long time(particularly since I use a shop made jig to sharpen).
I asked if anyone had tried this with the 735.I was not suggesting that anyone try this process on blades they were going to throw away.As for all of the theories as to why it won't work I won't argue with any of them.However I went ahead and actually tried it and I was satisfied with the results for the last 7 or 8 years.
One thing though,I suspect the Market Research folks might have been looking for a way to do their job and make more money for Dewalt.This is all I have to say on the subject.
I don't have anything to add to the planer discussion, but I hadn't seen your name in a LOOOONG time and wanted to say hello. Where ya' hangin' your hat these days--geographically as well as site-alistically? We're still in OB or in OB, depending on what you knew from the last time we communicated.
Good luck with the planer, in any event.
LRod@pobox.com if you want to carry on via the back channel.
It has been a loooong time!You were in OB when we last chatted.I think I was in Virginia at the time.Time moves on,and so did we.I am now in our final location,Richwood WV which is located in the mountains SSW of Snowshoe(lots of snow here,also cool in the summer)It is a woodworkers dream, one huge saw mill and a smaller one ,both in town.Since this is sort of a remote area I've cut back on the furniture a bit and switched primarily to cutting boards,benches and small tables.I have a supplier of slabs and large and small burl slabs which allows different looks in the stuff I make.All is well,a few years older which happens if you are lucky.Take care.