Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

A few recent shop test.

Posts

A few recent shop test.

#1

A few recent shop test.

Keith Newton

I have a young fellow helping me now. He likes the learning process, so I try to explain, or even back up certain things with experiments.

A while back, we were using some epoxy, and I stated that I really like the one that I use now, in that it is a 1 to 1 mix ratio, and is very forgiving, if you don;t get it perfect. One thing I didn't like back when I used the pumps, was that as they aged, or too cool, air would get drawn into the pump chamber, which could throw off the ratio, for a very unforgiving formula.

Back when I first started using this brand, I remembered the sales rep telling me that this formula was so forgiving that it could be off as much as 1 to 2, or 2 to 1, and still would kick. But one of those ratios would make a more flexible plastic.

I had never tried that, so we mixed up two batches to those ratios, and mixed half of each thick as peanut-butter. Ben guessed that the 2 resin, 1 activator would be the flexible one, but I told him, I thought it would be the other, and I was right. That is why I'm the boss. ha ha.

Then last night, we were discussing the hp listed on the shop vacuums. I told him about a little experiment I did a few years ago, where I sandwiched my bath scales between two 12" x 12" pieces of mdf, with a window cut out so I could see the weight when I put them in a clear drum-liner bag. With no leal, just holding the bag tight around the hose, a little 1 gallon, 1 hp, and a 6.5 hp 16 gallon, both Sears, drew ~ 200 pounds.

I had a piece of 1/2" clear vinyl hose, so we tested it another way, including another 5 hp 16 gallon Sears, and a small 5 hp Rigid. The Rigid, an 6.5 tied for the most, pulling 47" of water up the tube, with a wet rag for a seal. The other two were 45". This works out to ~ 235# to 250# pst. which was better than I expected.

Re: A few recent shop test.

#2

You've Now Found Out

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

That all that mumbo jumbo about horsepower in shop-vacs is pure BS. Suction ( there is no "vacuum" involved) has always been measured in inches of water-lift, but the gauge used was standard at 1" ID with no rags involved. The usual method was the test the motor/fan unit when removed from the tank as the design and fit of the canister varied too much between brands and models.

Good post.

Re: A few recent shop test.

#3

Re: What is pst? Is that a typo?

William Duffield

200# on a 144 sq. in. surface is about 1.4 psi, or about 0.1 atmosphere. That's no where near enough for an effective vacuum bag, or even for a lot of vacuum clamp applications.

One atmosphere, at sea level (and not much less in LR at ~300 ft. elevation) is 14.7 psi. This is enough pressure to lift water about 34 ft. You cannot lift water any higher than that using a vacuum in atmosphere. (You could get it a smidgen higher in Death Valley or on the Dead Sea.) 45" is again about 0.11 atmosphere.

Re: A few recent shop test.

#4

Yes, I meant pst. Per Sq. Ft.

Keith Newton

William, I am aware of how much a real vacuum pump will evacuate, having been bagging for around 25 years. As for not being enough for veneering, I normally pull 28" of Hg with my favorite pump. However, I use epoxy for my veneering, which doesn't require any more pressure than bringing both sides of the glue-line together, and that would be more than enough, if the veneer was flat.

And there are certain circumstances where I have needed to use low pressure. A while back, I needed to veneer over some plane hollow core doors to match the cabinets in a master closet which were Karelian Burl. 28" Hg would crush a hollow core door.

Re: A few recent shop test.

#5

Re: Yes, I meant pst. Per Sq. Ft.

William Duffield

OK, psf. Yes, I agree, too much vacuum (or however else you apply the pressure) can squeeze the very slippery epoxy out of the joint, or crush the form. I'm just not used to working in psf (1 psf = 144 psi, for those reading along who don't want to do the math :) ). I understand why you would use those units, because if you think about a person who weighs a hundred pounds or two or three with a footprint somewhat less than a foot square, standing on a veneering form you have constructed or on a hollow core door, the results can be pretty intuitive, without a lot of calculations and the chance of misplacing a decimal point.

I guess I should ask myself why am I comfortable working in psi and inches of mercury? I should have learned in college to work in Pascals, or at least in millibars during hurricane season. (Isaac is currently 1002 mbar mcp, while Andrew was at 922 mbar when it obliterated Homestead. Here's hoping you don't get torrential rains next week.) My air compressor, brad gun, die grinders, auto and tractor tires and well water pump talk to me in psi, so I suppose that's reason enough for now.