Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

(Message Deleted by Poster)

Posts

(Message Deleted by Poster)

#1

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#2

What always cracks me up...

John in NM

Them digital guys just don't get it :D

"Anyone who has tried to build a piece of furniture from scratch knows the frustration of painstakingly cutting pieces of wood, only to discover that they won’t fit together because the cutting was not quite accurate enough."

Never had that particular frustration, guess I never expected "perfect" and just learned to correct the mistakes rather than gnash teeth and wring hands over having made one. I do however, know the frustration of attempting to come up with a digital model for some fancy pants piece of compu-router -- I can carve by eye much faster than I can make a digital model :D

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#3

MIT

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

When you need to believe that technology, and specifically "hi-tech", can solve everything, it becomes an exclusive, self-validating path. The boys and girls up there have a marvelous understanding of machinery and industrial processes, but their understanding of woodworking as an activity may need some work.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#4

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

But...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

...that's probably only because they haven't applied themselves to it. I'm neither a fan nor critic of MIT in particular, so here's my take. I think they've only taken a cursory look at machinery as it applies to woodworking. After all, from a logical perspective, it's an archaic practice, using archaic tools--it's not "sexy" in the minds of many in the scientific world. Should, however, they turn their sights on it, I would think there could be mastery of some aspects of woodworking in short order.

After all, there are many minimally-educated woodworkers out there who turn out beautiful work. What they do is either a result of techniques learned from someone else, or that they've figured out for themselves. Folks at MIT (or any other technical/scientific school), should they get the notion, would approach woodworking on an experimental basis, perhaps from the starting point of observing a master at work, then researching where results and efficiency could be improved--either by technique or machine.

That router looks to me to have the potential to be a sort of "poor man's CNC". Perhaps one could add various designs to their pieces without first having to master the art of marquetry. It all depends on what a given woodworker wants to learn or spend.

Jason

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#5

Bob

Re: Must have -- fancy-schmancy guided router

Bob

It may be OK for industry but It takes the fun out of woodworking and requires no skill in the craft which is the whole point. I would never buy one.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#6

Re: Must have -- fancy-schmancy guided router

John McGaw

It is all a matter of what level of technology you are applying to your woodworking and all of us are using some technology unless we are gnawing our furniture from trees with our teeth. Sure. some people are using hand tools and some are using CNC but it is all technology. Somebody using self-made flint tools for cutting might look upon the guy using 18th century metal tools as an effete dilettante and not worthy of the description 'woodworker'.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#7

Well . . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

[putting on my best Jack Benny face]

I happen to ascribe to the Effete [snob] Dilettante School of Woodworking as I find my dental bills are way less :D

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#8

The problem statement ...

AZ in Colorado Springs

... in the article alongside the you tube video was that the guy couldn't build a picture frame. We still don't that he has ever done so.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#9

Re: Must have -- fancy-schmancy guided router

Carol

Seems to me the fly in the ointment is the user, who presumably can't use a router accurately, has the onus of applying the contrast tape accurately. :\ :D

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#10

David, I'll get one after you get yours.

Keith Newton

I didn't catch where it said what happened if the user got outside the bounds of that 1/2" fudge factor. I would guess that if you guided it into the zone too far, the router would still screw up.

It would have been more impressive, if the young fellow knew how fast he should be going with that bit.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#11

Re: Must have -- fancy-schmancy guided router

Chuck Jurvelin

Although I do appreciate using quality routers, table saws, and other tools, I can't see what self-gratification someone could get out of using this computer aided router. It is like using a laser

rather than carving or hand woodburning. How do you look at the finished product with a proud

look on your face and think "I created this" ??? Incidently, I can remember back forty-some years

at the miserable failures I had trying to make my own picture frames. I guess a new woodworker should look for progress rather than perfection.