Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Working With Ash

Posts

Working With Ash

#1

Working With Ash

Tom Rex in TX

My wife would like a corner cabinet 42" across the front, 21" deep and 80" tall made of ash.

It will be in 2 pieces, a 30" bottom and 50" top.

I've not had experience with this wood so I would like some feedback as to the pros & cons of ash.

Is it easy to cut, shape plane, etc?

How does it sand?

How does it stain?

Is it durable enough for this project.

Thanks for your response,

T Rex

Re: Working With Ash

#2

Re: Working With Ash

paul in AZ

Works pretty well. Very much the same was as white oak -maybe red too but I never use that so can't say.

You may need to fill grain. No idea of how it stains though.

Re: Working With Ash

#3

Ellis Walentine

If the open pore look pleases you...

Ellis Walentine

... you shouldn't have any trouble with any of the other characteristics of the wood. It saws, planes and sands nicely, it's hard (think baseball bats), and it takes dye stains and bleaches beautifully. I wouldn't recommend pigment stains as the strong ring-porous nature of the wood will take on a garish appearance. Finishes nicely.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Working With Ash

#4

Kneale Brownson

Ash is strong and pretty and now it'll

Kneale Brownson

become rare because of the emerald ash borer infestation.

Re: Working With Ash

#5

It once was a premium wood

Bill Tindall

Many years ago it commanded the same price as cherry. Then it fell from favor, I know not why. As it becomes extinct I predict it will once again command a premium price. I have worked thousands of feet of it and here are my thoughts......


Finished without stain I think it is one of the most beautiful woods for modern furniture.

It is one of the worst woods to pick put when planing it. Most boards will do fine but some are impossible to plane.

I have never successfully stained it and had it look good. It does look sharp though with milk paint on it. The grain comes through and the result is pleasing.


Right now it is one of the cheapest hardwoods, but that won't last as the last of it is killed and it becomes rare.

Re: Working With Ash

#6

Love the cabinet--Question about the back

Henry Higginbotham

Really nice cabinet. Is the back plywood or solid? It matches the rest awfully well, which makes me suspect it's resawn from the same stock. But the pieces appear glued, not lapped, so how did you handle expansion if in fact it's solid?

Re: Working With Ash

#7

Ellis Walentine

Wow, you had a Krenov period!

Ellis Walentine

Nice work on that cabinet, Bill. I like the optical illusion of the shelves looking like muntins.

Re: planing. With potentially flaky woods like ash, I have had better results with high-speed, smaller diameter cutterheads (i.e., lunchbox planers, Inca planers) than big planers.

Ellis

Re: Working With Ash

#8

answers

Bill Tindall

Until one gets into building a Krenov like piece, and especially so construction getting advice from a former student, Krenov's engineering genius may not be revealed. The back is in fact structural. Plywood is created for it and it is fit to the back rabbits with glue joint precision and glued in.

I was in question of my ability to build this thing. This is in fact the second after a "practice" run which turned out ok. To look good the joinery must be precise so it was a stressful build.

Re: Working With Ash

#9

David Barnett

Beautiful cabinet.


Re: Working With Ash

#10

Re: Working With Ash

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I used ash for my drawer boxes and other pieces parts when I built my kitchen cabinets 8 or 10 years ago. It was cheap. Works well.

The only thing I did not like is that it STINKS when milling/cutting it.

I think the stuff smells horrible...

:)

Joe

Re: Working With Ash

#11

Beautiful work Bill!

mark Hennebury

Ash is one of my favorite woods.

Re: Working With Ash

#12

Re: Working With Ash

Rob Sandow

Similar to oak in workability and pore characteristics. Closer to white oak in color, closer to red oak in grain pattern, very plain with none of the cross-grain stuff that is prevalent in quarter or rift sawn white oak.

Re: Working With Ash

#13

Beautiful work!

Jim Dillon

Bill,

As usual a little late to the parade, but just wanted to say that is really a nice cabinet. One of my goals in woodworking is to build a Krenov-style piece as I've always admired the cabinet portion, less so the skinny legs. Thanks for the inspiration!

I wish I could contribute to the original posters query regarding ash, but I have no experience with it. It is a tragedy regarding the impact of the ash-borers.

Jim

Re: Working With Ash

#14

help if it is needed

Bill Tindall

I learned several non-obvious construction details from Finck (the plane person) who lives nearby. If when you get into it you have any questions send me an email.

I keep pestering David to write a book on Krenov construction details by so far he is resisting.