Romex in conduit?
Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa
Good morning,
Is it legal (electrical code-wise) to run Romex in conduit? (Notice I didn't say, "economical".) How would fill limits be affected?
Al
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Romex in conduit?
Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa
Good morning,
Is it legal (electrical code-wise) to run Romex in conduit? (Notice I didn't say, "economical".) How would fill limits be affected?
Al
Re: Romex in conduit?
Jesper, Denmark
I don't see any electrical problem with Romex in conduit, but why would you? It'll be a bitch to pull.
Re: Romex in conduit?
Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa
Good morning Jesper,
My new shop has metal panelling inside and out. I will run conduit from the breaker panel, up through the ceiling, Romex (no conduit) across the attic, and then back down through the ceiling in conduit at locations where the outlets, etc. will be. Will make a much cleaner looking installation.
Al
Re: Romex in conduit?
Jason Waters
Al,
I would check your local codes, as some locations have additional restrictions/requirements. This subject always brings a lot of debate.
I like the idea of conduit drops, but why don't you want to run conduit the whole way? It's not that bad. I had to do it in my concrete garage, and it was fine.
If it were me, I would use a large conduit up into the ceiling to a box, and then distribute it via smaller conduit in the ceiling to each drop.
I guess you could go into the ceiling with conduit and THHN, into juntion boxes to romex, then to the drop with a junction box and THHN down to the outlet again. Seems like too much work, and connections to cause problems.
Re: Romex in conduit?
John in NM
Strip the Romex back to where the conduit starts, so that only a couple inches will stick into the conduit, and use a conduit end bushing to prevent chaffing. Or just run conduit all the way as Jason says - I'd probably do that.
Re: Romex in conduit?
Bob
I just had a conversation with the inspector the other day about that. First, Nowhere in the NEC does it say you can or can not. We were talking about how an inspector in another county failed a job that used #12 in 1/2 pipe. It seems the inspector has some room to pass/fail if they think the work was unsafe even if it does not violate the code directly.
Re: Romex in conduit?
JL
My shop (which really was inspected, BTW) has Romex in conduit. I have cinder block walls. I stapled the Romex in the overhead joists above the ceiling and I have the conduit on the walls below the ceiling.
I didn't want to run metal flex conduit in the overhead, so I used Romex. It actually pulled quite easily - except for the ones where I doubled it up or used 10 gauge.
A little fishy
John in NM
"We were talking about how an inspector in another county failed a job that used #12 in 1/2 pipe."
Unless there is a more strict local code, he should not have failed that, it is well within the NEC limits for conduit fill (roughly 9% conduit fill where 31% is allowed). Depending on wire type, you can stuff a couple #8's in 1/2" EMT (assuming you can pull that, which would be a workout). If that was the reason for failing the inspection, the builder should have called the supervisor and appealed. More likely, there was something else that failed and the story got garbled.
Re: A little fishy
Bob
I don't know what the circumstances were. Could have been used romex with kinks for all I know it just came up in conversation. When I was having an inspection I mentioned I was going to use romex because I had so much sitting around (I have 2000 ft of 12-2, but actually did the job with 10-2 and had to buy it so the conversation started off about cost). Then he told me about the job that failed.
Maybe it was the "pipe"
Bill Howatt
I was told by an electrican many years ago you cannot use regular (at least non-plastic) pipe for conduit because there is no guarantee in the manufacture that there is not rough/sharp places in the surface that can damage the insulation. This is a bigger problem if the pipe is galvanized and then bent causing the galvanizing to separate.
FWIW,
Bill
Re: Maybe it was the "pipe"
Bob
I wish I knew why he failed it. By the sound of it he used all recycled stuff. I have seen a number of inspectors fall jobs but its been my experience to just do the job as they require, its makes life easier down the road to not get in pissing matches with them.
That could be it...
John in NM
Kinked wire is frowned upon, so a lot of recycled stuff could do it. Wouldn't be the number of wires in the conduit so much as the state of the wire itself. I hope all the other inspectors who heard this story got the right reason, I'd hate to think they were running around thinking that 2 #12's was excessive in 1/2" conduit 
Re: Romex in conduit?
Rick Christopherson
A government inspector cannot create law on the spot. That would be the equivalent of a police officer deciding that the speed limit for red cars should be 35 mph today. Your State's constitution prohibits it for this very reason.
Most of the time when these stories come up, it is a miscommunication between what an inspector was enforcing, and what a DIY'er assumed was being enforced. Simply asking for a code reference for the red-tag is generally sufficient to resolve that. However, inspectors are not infallible, and they have been known to falsely fail an inspection. Asking for a code reference usually fixes these cases too.
The other thing that happens is that these stories get repeated on the internet as hearsay, and a critical piece of information that seemed trivial to one observer was overlooked in the later retelling. A pertinent example of this is that it is a code violation to put romex in conduit and bury it underground feeding a garage. It isn't the romex in conduit that is the violation, but that romex cannot be used in wet locations, and underground is considered a wet location regardless whether there is conduit or not. So a person may hear about this and incorrectly assume it was the romex inside the conduit that caused the failure, when in fact it was simply because you cannot put romex underground.
Re: Romex in conduit?
Bob
Rick, these were the works directly from the inspector. The told me during my inspection that the inspector failed a job because the guy used "Romex in Conduit" I don't know what else was wrong, as I said "the guy may have used recycled wire with kinks and twists" or there may have been breaks in the insulation for all I know. Go back and read how this came up and you will understand where it came from, no disrespect intended.
Re: Romex in conduit?
Rick Christopherson
Bob, no disrespect perceived....nor intended on my part either. All I was pointing out is that these stories frequently omit the critical details that may be considered trivial, but were in fact the root-cause.
As you just pointed out, the true cause for the inspection failure may have been from utilizing used materials, kinks in the conductors, or even buried romex. Unfortunately, another reader of this anecdotal information will skip right past these details, and more likely than not, conclude it was failed due to having romex in conduit, which may never have been a factor.
I can't even begin to tell you how frequently I see postings from people suggesting that their local jurisdiction has amended the NEC on the basis of, "My electrician told me...such-and-such..." or "My inspector told me...such-and-such..." However, a quick search or further inquiries reveals that their local jurisdiction does in fact adopt code without amendments.
These anecdotal re-telling of stories is the number-one reason why there is so much electrical misinformation on internet forums. This whole topic of "romex in conduit" is a prime example. This topic has raged on for years on non-electrical forums, but if someone were to ever post this discussion on something like the "Mike Holt Electrical Forum", it would get quashed so fast, it would be done before you ever saw it coming.
Re: Romex in conduit?
Bob
How true, how true. I really has gotten out of hand.
Re: Romex in conduit?
Richard Jones
Yes, legal, under 2008 NEC, 334.15 (B) Protection from Physical Damage.................. if it's an approved conduit type.
Rich
Re: Romex in conduit?
Chuck
Under NEC each conduit is limited to the number of conductors which may be placed inside. This is because there must be enough free space to accommodate several wiring factors.
When you place romex inside the conduit (pull it through) you effectively "fill" the space with materials that have no practical value (plastic cover, filler for the conductors, etc.). This is ok except that doing so places a severe limit on the number of conductors that may be placed in that conduit. Pulling romex in 1/2 inch conduit means(from a practical standpoint) that you cannot put anymore conductors in that conduit.
So the real issue is the tradeoffs between ease of installation using conduit for its protective qualities versus practical issues of more circuits (conductors) being allowed in the conduit when pulled as separate wires and not romex. Take your choice.