basic router question
Jerry Gibbs
What is the practical difference between using a router with a built in adjustment from above when the router in inverted in a table and using a separate router lift?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
basic router question
Jerry Gibbs
What is the practical difference between using a router with a built in adjustment from above when the router in inverted in a table and using a separate router lift?
Re: basic router question
George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA
Good Afternoon Jerry,
My router table is equipped with a Jessen Master Lift holding a big P+C 7818 machine. I never have to take the router out of the table as the lift is precise and I can easily make adjustments.
By design, some routers allow adjustment while they remain mounted in a table without a lift. I can't vouch for them in direct comparison to my own system. It would seem that the correct elevation and placement of the bit above the table would be achieved either way.
Other routers like my P+C 690 Standard Base require adjustment by popping them from the table, or adjusting them by eye while squatting in front of the table/cabinet. In my opinion, its inconvenient and less accurate.
I would go with a router lift, or buy a router which can be adjusted at the table top. Bit changes are also much easier.
George
Re: basic router question
JL
I've used my PC 890 series router "both ways" - with and without a router lift.
IMO, when I used the router with the existing base, it didn't have the "fine tuning" of the router lift. The adjustment seemed "more coarse". The handle for the above the table adjustments on the router lift is larger and is not "just a knob" - and it has a bigger handle on the shaft.
The other nice thing is the wide variety of inserts available for the plate.
Re: basic router question
Jesse Cloud
Good advice above!
I also have the Jessem router lift and I love it. Adjustment and precision is easy and spot on. I used to adjust my PC7815 from under the table. It was hard to lift, hard to lock in without loosing the adjustment, and often resulted in skinned knuckles. The Jessem took care of all that and allows bit changes from above the table. Ahhhhh!
If you have the time and patience, you can probably get the same precision from under the table, but I am short on both those. 
Re: basic router question
Bob
Faster and easier I think its repeatable as well if you have templets for profiles.
Re: basic router question
John Lucas
The router lifts are nice but awfully expensive. I use a Makita plunge router and bought an aftermarket crank handle to replace the knob. I do have to reach under the table which is not the most convenient thing but it allows for very fine adjustment and cost very little.
Re: basic router question
Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana
I have kind of a hybrid - I have a shop made table with the large Rockler insert, a Porter Cable 7539 plunge router and a Router Raizer. I have my table top hinged with a ratchet assembly so it stays in the tilted position for changing bits. The Router Raizer is very accurate - adjustable to within .002 or .003" easily. I have been very happy with the setup.
Re: basic router question
NickinMass
I've got a Milwaukee 7529 in a Woodpecker quick lift - so very infinitely easier to use than my old PC 690 in the aluminum PC router table. The Milwaukee base can also be used to mount to a table and has the ability to be adjusted from above, but the adjustment is much more coarse than my lift and it would be very difficult to do changes with the router in the table.
That said, no reason you can't do nice work without the lift, but its much more convenient with the lift. My Milwaukee weighs a ton, so I'm very happy to do bit changes in the table - it lowers the activation energy for swapping bits. I could also adjust from above the table without the lift, but the adjustment screw is pretty coarse compared to what is in my router lift, plus I've got good visual references, so I can raise/lower to a particular point reproducibly (nice when I'm making moldings).
wondered why...
Jerry Gibbs
people bought a lift when the bit height is adjustable from above with just the router. thanks
Re: basic router question
AZ in Colorado Springs
My router table is a Rockler high pressure laminate table, and I made a simple base for it. For a couple of years, I had an old skil plunge router mounted in it, and I added a shelf under the router and used used a bottle jack (hydraulic jack) as a lift mechanism. I could raise the router in fine increments, but going down was trouble. But, it worked.
Then I got a freud FT3000VCE (Woodcraft had a great after-Christmas sale a couple of years back) and mounted that. It is a plunge router and is adjustable through the base. It also has a shaft lock, and I can easily change bits above the table.
The freud router came with a knob that was not very convenient to use. The adjustment mechanism uses a 3/8" allen wrench, and the knob was a length of the appropriate aluminum stock with a small knob handle at the end. I found a socket in my tool box with a 3/8" allen wrench end. I use a ratchet and extension with that socket and I can make very, very fine adjustments in both directions. And, the ratchet handle, more so than the knob, makes it easier to make the finer adjustments -- 1/4 turn, 1/8 turn, 1/16 turn, etc. And when it's time to crank it up and remove the bit, I don't risk a repetitive motion injury to my wrist turning that small knob.
To get to your question, I've never used a separate screw-type lift mechanism (just my bottle jack). But the integral system in the freud router is great.
Re: basic router question
Joseph Mulherin, Sr
I have the same Rockler router table top, and use a plunge router underneath. When I need to I lift the entire router out, change the bit to the one I wish to use, then adjust the built in mechanism to just touch the square faced piece of wood to the bit and secure. Drop the router into the table and run a test piece...if it is OK then proceed with the work.