Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

mortiser

Posts

mortiser

#1

mortiser

Cameron

I decided to use mortises in a bunch of cabinet doors that I need to make (have been using a matched router bit set but I get warped doors every once in a while on longer doors that I believe come from the minimal contact surface at the joint and I think a tenon would help eliminate this...) so I set up my old hollow chisel mortiser on my old drill press and started chopping away, I got to my second mortise and notice that my edge was slanting all over and determined that the run out in the drill press was wreaking havoc. Now I am thinking that I should finally bite the bullet and get a dedicated machine but the question is what one? My 2 top candidates are the following:

1. Powermatic PM701

2. Leigh Super FMT Frame Mortise and Tenon Jig

they both cost about the same (~$470).

Any opinions on which to buy (or others?)

Thanks

Re: mortiser

#2

Re: mortiser *LINK*

mdclor

I recently considered upgrading my mortiser and found a 2009 review by FWW. Below is a link if you have access. Otherwise, look for the July/August 2009 issue. You will need to make your own decision as to which better suits your needs.

I know that it is more expensive, but you might also want to consider the Festool Domino. It might provide more flexibility than either the PM or the Leigh options.

HTH,

Merle


FWW Mortiser Review

Re: mortiser

#3

Re: mortiser

William Duffield

Over the long run, cope and stick door frames really suck (but not as much as IKEA doors).

I think these are what you need:

http://www.toolsforworkingwood.com//Merchant/merchant.mvc?Screen=PROD&Store_Code=toolshop&Product_Code=MS-MORT.XX&Category_Code=TBMC

If not, Merle's Festool Domino suggestion is also sweet. Joel sells them, too. I do mortises both ways, but I've sworn off hollow chisel mortisers and mortiser attachments for drill presses. I might use the floor mount Powermatic, if I were desperate, but not a benchtop model.

Re: mortiser

#4

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: mortiser

#5

Re: mortiser

Jesse Cloud

When I found that I could make mortisers faster and better with a router jig, I sold my mortiser. Never looked back.

And yes, the Domino is sweet - a real game changer, but expensive.

Re: mortiser

#6

Re: Not fair, William. Those require skill.

William Duffield

The Domino doesn't. Heck, even I can make perfect M&T joints with it, first time, every time, and no sawdust on the floor or in my spiderwebs. And it's about the same price as the floor mount Powermatic.

Re: mortiser

#7

Re: mortiser

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Using a plunge router is the only way I've ever cut mortises, following a method described by Tage Frid in FWW. It works exceedingly well.

However, I lust after a hollow chisel mortiser for those pesky A&C square spindles, and I seem to do a lot of them.

A Domino would be pretty nifty, too.

Re: mortiser

#8

Re: mortiser

Tony-Memphis

I've had the Powermatic for a few years. I really like it. It is nice and heavy and works very well. The only issue I have had is the drive socket that the hand fits into stripped out. The teeth literally just crumbled. No, it wasn't my super human strength! It was out of warranty, but the piece was not too expensive and was easy to get. I wish the fence had a bit finer adjustment. I thought about makign a lever for it so I could move the fence a hair at a time. Nice tool - no regrets - would buy another.

Tony

Re: mortiser

#9

Re: mortiser

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I've had and used a bench-top JET (JBM-5) for a number of years. I use it to hog out the center of a mortice then cut the hole to final dimension with bench tools (+ a router for "through" work). I do not, however, use it to cut the holes to final size; that asks more of the tool than it can deliver.

It does just fine for what I do.

Re: mortiser

#10

JET mortiser

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

I too have the JET machine. By careful alignment of the chisel and fence, frequent sharpening, and tweaking the head/column fit, I consistently get mortices that require very little hand work. However, the tweaking does result in a pretty heavy pull effort and an inflated bicep by day's end.

Re: mortiser

#11

Re: JET mortiser

mdclor

Dave, be careful with the biceps. I just broke the cast iron fence where the set screw goes in from the back to hold the rod that the hold down attaches to. No, I am not superman either. I think the design is poor since there is very little metal in that area. My machine is about 14 years old so that may have been part of it. Good luck with yours.

Re: mortiser

#12

Bob

Re: mortiser

Bob

Cameron, just stay away from table top models. I have a Shop Fox I paid about $250. It does the job but you realy have to go back and over them to get them perfectly square. I think I could do better and faster with a drill press and Forstner Bits. Look at auctions and get yourself one that can do vertical and horizontal, OH and get a standing floor model. This place has them all the time.

http://www.irsauctions.com/?flash=9

Re: mortiser

#13

Rick L

Re:$310 http://www.dowelmax.com/


Re: mortiser

#14

Re: mortiser

NickinMass

Lately I've been using loose tenons in mortises made with a plunge router and a Mortise Pal jig. Works really well with a spiral bit (although thinner stock requires a bit of horsing around with shims). Runs around $200 these days, I believe.

Re: mortiser

#15

Re: mortiser

TomD

Hollow chisel mortisers can work well, but General changed the game when the introduced the model that has all the angle adjustments. I have heard good things about that, but it opened the door to a whole raft of shaky tools that even the salesmen are embarrassed to talk about.

I own both a sturdy Chinese, floor model, and the first bench top to be marketed in the US, the Delta, which was made in the UK. Both are really solid a work very well, though any hollow chisel unit has the disadvantage of all those separate "holes" that need to be cut. If I had access to something like the IRS auctions, I would get a real one. Quality is everything in these tools, but it can come in small packages as well as large. It just gets tedious dealing with the shortcomings of the lessors tools. My benchtop cuts great holes, but the workpiece has to be moved for each cut, and one has to deal with the dust produced. My floor unit holds the piece in a clamp. So that problem goes away.

I think there are more expensive alternatives to HCMs out there, that work better. But the HCM remains popular in industrial settings that still have to cut M&T joints. Culturally some places have not accepted cheaper alternatives and continue with the M&T. So i wouldn't buy into the idea that they don't work.

Re: mortiser

#16

Re: mortiser

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I have a Fisch 3/4 hp Bench top unit. I have built a base for the unit which holds and clamps the boards in place. The unit has been very accurate for me. I built one chest that had around 50 M&T joints in Oak and cedar. I do clean out the mortice with a chisel to smooth the joint, and make the tenons tight, then trim them for fit with a rasp or file. Usually just have to remove a thousands or two.

Re: mortiser

#17

Rick L

Re: Improved door joints

Rick L

http://www.woodcentral.com/shots/shot52.shtml

I'm assuming this is what you want to do. The loose tenon or dowel joint would be your best option. The Dowelmax gives you the best bang for the buck. The Horizontal Slot Mortiser is the best mortising system you can get. Chisel mortisers fall far short unless you really think you need square holes. There's several DIY slot mortisers in the articles site and FWW has publihed several over the years. The best in my opinion using simple drawer slides for the cross slide movements. All you want is the make mortises with the tool. Don't be conned into the bells and whistles of the Multirouter or Wirth machine.

http://woodcentral.com/articles/reviews/articles_729.shtml