Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Tung to be applied over linseed Oil

Posts

Tung to be applied over linseed Oil

#1

Tung to be applied over linseed Oil

Luke

I am installing new Acacia timber kitchen bench tops which came pre-treated with a well cured light (but inadequate) coat of Linseed Oil which has a lovely colour but is still too porous for a kitchen. I would much prefer to finish the bench tops with a Tung Oil (without any polly or varnish). Can I apply the Tung Oil over the Linseed Oil? Will I need to do any special preparation?

Re: Tung to be applied over linseed Oil

#2

Re: Tung

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Pure tung will take a month to dry, way longer to loose its sent, and will have a pretty soft (non-durable) finish. You're better off with Waterlox which either sealer or gloss, has some varnish resins in it. Remember too, since this is a kitchen, if a hot pot gets put on the top, you can plan on refinishing the ring-scar. DAMHIKT :(

Re: Tung to be applied over linseed Oil

#3

Re: Tung Can Be Groovey

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

But not in kitchens.

George

Re: Tung to be applied over linseed Oil

#4

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Tung to be applied over linseed Oil

Jesper, Denmark

To answer your question, there is no problem using tung oil on top of linseed. Thin with turps or mineral spirits and use a little Japan drier.

Like others, I think it is not a good finish for a kitchen countertop. My preference is a durable semigloss or almost matte finish. What I have used successfully is the type of varnish used for basketball court floors - I like the old sovent based, but you may have a preference for water based materials.

Re: Tung to be applied over linseed Oil

#5

Re: Tung to be applied over linseed Oil

Howard Acheson

Neither pure tung oil or linseed oil are a good choice for a surface that is going to be frequently wiped off with dishwater or supermarket cleaning chemicals. Neither have any real water or water vapor resistance and foods stains will soak right in. You will need to be constantly cleaning and refinishing no matter which oil you use. Basically, pure tung oil is only marginally more water tolerant than linseed oil. Both are lousy finishes and are best reserved for coloring under a better, more durable film finish.

Re: Tung to be applied over linseed Oil

#6

Poor choice for finish 


Re: Tung to be applied over linseed Oil

#7

So Luke

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Do you detect a pattern here? :D

Good Luck on your final choice.

Re: Tung to be applied over linseed Oil

#8

Its not the water, its the abrasion

John in NM

I agree with those who say the two oils are more or less the same, whichever you use, there will be either semi-annual refinishing or frequent maintenance coats.

However, I won't go so far as to predict all the doom and gloom and "the end is near for you countertop" if you use either oil.

I refinished a maple salad bowl 10 years ago with linseed and wax - it has held up fine with frequent washing, better than the original shellac or whatever it was.

Work surfaces do see a lot more abrasion than salad bowls though, and that is why you will have to maintain the finish. But one thing to consider, several times a week, we clean our stone counter with ammonia and alcohol after doing the dishes for the evening. You could do the same with a thinned oil easily enough, maybe once a month would do it. Drying time might be a problem, depending on your climate, then again it might not.

I've never tried BLO on a kitchen counter, however some of the color samples I've made lead me to believe that a well thinned oil will penetrate quite well, and the maintenance coats will be just that - maintenance. I don't believe you'll have any trouble with water or detergent on such a countertop.

Worst case, if the oil doesn't penetrate nicely, next year maybe you'll have to strip and refinish with some kind of film finish, and that's really not so bad, IMHO.

Re: Tung to be applied over linseed Oil

#9

Re: Its not the water, its the abrasion

paul in AZ

John: do you think the oil in salad dressings has anything to do with that?

Re: Tung to be applied over linseed Oil

#10

Re: Its not the water, its the abrasion

John in NM

Personally I don't, but of course I have nothing to back it up :D

The finish on this bowl has changed over the years, because I have not re-coated it. It's lost most of the almost tacky feel of linseed on the surface of the wood. I can only speculate that any surface coating has worn off, leaving just the dried oil that soaked into the wood.

On a counter, I would do more initial coats than the bowl got, those color samples I did a couple months ago soaked through the ~1/8" maple after roughly 6-7 applications over the course of a week. I'm not sure if letting the oil dry longer before re-coating would diminish that effect or not.

Now that I think of it, since my wife is out of town for 3 weeks, I should re-coat that bowl. Bachelors don't make salad :D