Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

OT Roofing nail question

Posts

OT Roofing nail question

#1

OT Roofing nail question

Barry Irby

A huge oak tree fell on one of my rental houses. The roofing is about 12 years old and is dimensional asphalt shingles and nailed with air driven coil roofing nails. My sons and I installed it and I think the nails were from one of the big box stores and were probably Grip-tite. Now I am stripping off some of the shingles to repair the roof. I am stunned to find the nails have rusted. Five or ten percent, the heads have rusted away. On 30 to 50% the shanks of the nails just below the heads have rusted away fifty percent or more. I am sure there is no way the nails will last the balance of the 30 year life expectancy of the shingles.

What the heck to do now?

Re: OT Roofing nail question

#2

Kneale Brownson

Re: OT Roofing nail question

Kneale Brownson

Did the tar on the shingles work? If so, they'll probably stay in place except for exceptional storms.

I never look for the "best deal" on fasteners.

Re: OT Roofing nail question

#3

Re: OT Roofing nail question

Barry Irby

Yes the seal down tar strips worked.

I've been thinking about this with the one active brain cell I still have. IIRC I rented the nailer from Home Depot and bought the fasteners from them. I think I will talk to them about this.

I am about to do several more roofs. I think I need better fasteners.

Re: OT Roofing nail question

#4

Re: OT Roofing nail question

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

Barry, have Home Depot double check on WHERE the roofing nails are MADE, and if they have galvanized coatings on them like they should have. I just feel that some Buyer made a "deal" for some products from overseas.

Re: OT Roofing nail question

#5

Re: OT Roofing nail question

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

Barry, Woodcraft has a sale on the roofing nail guns: Freeman model#PCN65; Item # 412956.

On sale for $169.99...savings of $30.

With that many roofs to do in the future it might just more practical to buy the gun instead of renting one

Re: OT Roofing nail question

#6

Re: OT Roofing nail question

Barry Irby

I have bought a gun, a Dewalt. Have been using Grip rite nails. I think they are the same ones I used on this roof. This is a little scary.

Re: OT Roofing nail question

#7

How does a roofing nail get wet to rust??

Dick Coers

Either poor ventilation causing condensation build up, or ice dams. Otherwise, how do they see water to rust? Nail gun fasteners have never had the coating that old hot dip nails did. Were they wire collated, or plastic collated? If wire, that wire was spot welded on, and is likely copper coated steel. That may be the point where the rust started.

Re: OT Roofing nail question

#8

Re: OT Roofing nail question

Ken Oakley Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

If you got the stuff from HD, it had to come from China--Nuff said??????

Re: OT Roofing nail question

#9

Re: How does a roofing nail get wet to rust??

Barry Irby

These were wire collated and sort of yellow colored.

We were very careful to nail them as called for by the shingle manufacturer. The shingles have a nailing line on them and we tried to stay on the line or slightly above. The roof has a 5 in 12 or slightly steeper slope.

Not happy with this.