Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

OT: Solar Power anyone????

Posts

OT: Solar Power anyone????

#1

Jesper, Denmark

OT: Solar Power anyone????

Jesper, Denmark

I am seriously considering installing a 6 kW photovoltiac solar panel on the hose. With current legislation, the power company will have to install a new meter and accept excess power being returned to the grid as "storage" during times of excess power production, and return it at night etc.

About 400 sq.ft. of monocrystalline panels on a southfacing 45° pitch roof, which is close to the ideal angle of 38° in our latitude.

This size unit in our climate should provide something close to my annual consumption of about 5.6 mWh, reducing the electricity bill to an annual fee of $200.

Anyone tried this? Experiences???

Re: OT: Solar Power anyone????

#2

Re: OT: Solar Power anyone????

Barry Irby

I have not done it, but recently stopped by a company calling themselves Off Grid and talked to them about it. They suggested a 6 Kw system. Said they would arrange for a meter similar to the one you mentioned. Total cost would be $24,000. Since my electric bill is less than $150/mo on the average I am still wondering f this is a good deal.

Several things bothered me. The company looked a little "fragile" to me. Just a woman sitting in an over sized building on the side of the road waiting for stragglers to stumble in. I seriously doubt they will last as long as the system. (Who will honor whatever warranty when that operation folds?)

It bothered me that their name was Off Grid when in fact it was essential you be on the grid to have someone to sell the power to and to buy it from when your system falls short. No backup during a power failure. Power failures here seem to occur during fowl overcast weather and at night.

And I wonder if the system will ever pay for itself. How long do these things last? Do they degrade over time?

I asked them about a solar thermal water heater and they were dismissive. The only one they had was $9,000. I had a homemade one years ago that cost $200 and provided 40% of my water. I would have thought I could do a lot with $9000.

Re: OT: Solar Power anyone????

#3

Re: OT: Solar Power anyone????

Mark Nowicki

"Total cost would be $24,000. Since my electric bill is less than $150/mo on the average I am still wondering f this is a good deal. "

You don't have to wonder, Barry. It is a simple investment analysis problem using either Net Present Value (NPV) or Internal Rate of Return (IRR).

Mark

http://www.datadynamica.com/irr.asp

Re: OT: Solar Power anyone????

#4

JL

Re: OT: Solar Power anyone????

JL

Our community playhouse is contemplating installing a 50 KW system on our roof.

A group of investors would like to install it and pay us "rent" for our rooftop.

After investigation, I found out why they will be able to "make" money.

Tax breaks and write-offs - using a combination of these the entire system would be paid for in five years - they have to come up with the money upfront, but in five years they will "recoup" their investment.

The local utility (and TVA) will pay them a premium for their generated power (about 50% more than the current rates).

Our lease payments would come out of what the utility pays them.

Without the tax breaks and write-offs, this would take 15 years (or more) to pay off the cost of installation and maintenance.

Our location is pretty ideal - no trees and above the surrounding area. The roof parapet would keep the solar panels from sight of the surrounding community.

The husband of one of our board members has a small system. His will pay for itself in four years.

Re: OT: Solar Power anyone????

#5

Re: OT: Solar Power anyone????

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, FL

I'm waiting for Solyndra to put it's product on the market. Should be soon now.

Re: OT: Solar Power anyone????

#6

Re: OT: Solar Power anyone????

Dave Paine

I have had a domestic hot water system in use since mid 80's.

2 @ 4ft x 8ft panels and an 80 gal tank which pre-heats the water going into the normal 80 gal electrically heated tank.

So far the only maintenance has been to replace the pump (I think the capacitor went bad) and the propylene glycol fluid (during a really cold winter without sun for many days).

I live in eastern PA and even in mid January with a sunny day we can get the 80 gal pre-heater tank up to 135 deg F.

I have no idea how long the photo-voltaic panels last. I hope the efficiency improves and the price becomes reasonable.

Re: OT: Solar Power anyone????

#7

Re: OT: Solar Power anyone????

John McGaw

I hope that it wasn't a Gundfos pump that failed. (Just kidding, Jesper!)

Re: OT: Solar Power anyone????

#8

Kneale Brownson

Check around for differing arrangements

Kneale Brownson

I have neighbors who paid in full for their systems and get the "reward" from the utility directly and I have neighbors who make a small monthly payment to a company that supplies the system and gets the "rewards" from the utility and gummerment. The monthly payment is somewhat less than their average billing rate and the equipment becomes theirs in 10-15 years, at which point they supposedly pay nothing more for electricity.

Re: OT: Solar Power anyone????

#9

Re: OT: Solar Power anyone????

Dave Paine

Ouch.

Yes it was a Grundfos pump, and was replaced by the same.

Quiet and reliable. I expect I could have fixed the electronics but it was faster to replace the pump.

The only problem with passive solar, is that I do not control the sun - unless I cover the panels with plywood or a tarp.

Re: OT: Solar Power anyone????

#10

Re: OT: Solar Power anyone????

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

I looked into it last year, when the government incentives were quite high, even with the tax breaks and energy credits, the payback for the initial investment was about 15-20 years and it didn't seem to be a wise investment for someone of my age (62). Granted, increases in energy prices would shorten that, but it just didn't seem like the way to go.

Also the idea of having a billboard sized installation in our back yard wasn't appealing.

Lee

Re: OT: Solar Power anyone????

#11

Re: OT: Solar Power anyone????

John E. in SC

For $24,000 cost, even if it reduced your electric bill to $0, it would take 13.3 years to break even. And of course that assumes you wouldn't have made any money by investing that $24,000 in some other venture. I can't imagine that in 13+ years you wouldn't have had to do some type of maintenance or replacement of the solar panel, which would push out the break even point even further. Doesn't sound like it would remotely be worth it.

Re: OT: Solar Power anyone????

#12

Re: OT: Solar Power anyone????

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Sounded kind of interesting so I did a little research on the web. The panel manufactures have a very optimistic view of the operational life of the panels up to 50 years - (gee wonder why?). Other sites with scientific backgrounds and no financial interest are not quite so bold. Per all sites I have looked at the panels lose 1/2% of their efficiency per year. So in 20 years you have lost 10% of the amount of power a new panel can produce. The other issue is that the electronics that convert and sync the power to the grid is very expensive and complicated - most sites estimate a reasonable life of 25 years (obviously with less and less power produced as the panels age). This does not include the possibility of damage to the panels due to tree limbs, hail or storm derbies. I looked into this several years ago thinking it might be an alternative to a generator as back up power - at that time I was looking at storing the power in a battery pack and using it as a backup type system. The costs astounded me so I didn't do much research - I take a very dim view of any project that only can be made (questionable) economically feasible only by getting tax rebates and forced purchase of the power by the power company at twice the normal cost.

Re: OT: Solar Power anyone????

#13

Re: OT: Solar Power anyone????

Barry Irby

Wow! That bought back some old dim memories. I used to do commercial Appraisals and I had not thought of those terms in years. IRR my butt.

To many variables for me. What about the degradation of out put? Storm damage. What do you do when you want to replace your roofing?

A serious question. Wonder if you can use the system during a power failure? There would be no place for the excess to go.

Re: OT: Solar Power anyone????

#14

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Thanks for your comments......

Jesper, Denmark

The various scepticisms more or less mirror what I was concerned about initially. After some research and checking the experiences in Germany, where this idea really took off some years ago, I am fairly well convinced that the technology is sound.

The economics are OK. About a straight 10 year payback without any incentives other than forcing the power company to buy back at the same price they sell at. Add to that a tax write off for depreciation, and the expectation that power costs will escalate over time.

The roof is clay tile, so a life expectancy of 60+ years. There are 40+ years left. My life expectancy (at 68) says "don't worry".

It will not work as standby power, as I suspect the inverter needs excitation from the grid, just like wind or gas turbines. The inverter technology is not new - basically the same as battery powered back-up systems. The installation has to be "without shade", so no trees around to drop limbs on the cells. I am more concerned with pigeon poop contamination :(

All energy here is heavily taxed (Gasoline twice that in USA), so the cost of heating, power etc. have a great effect on property values.

And for the ecology minded, there is a saving of a few tons of CO2......

Re: OT: Solar Power anyone????

#15

My system

Craig in Silverdale

I have a 120 watt system at my cabin in the Olympic Mountains in Washington. I have an unfettered southern exposure just shy of 2000 feet. The system is totally off grid. The electrical storage is in the form of 4 golf cart batteries. I have had it in use for the past eight years. The solar panel is warranted for 25 years. I have seen no sign of reduced output since the initial purchase. This is for weekend use and has always had electricity enough even on dark rainy long weekends in the dead of winter.

The system your talking about is much more demanding and of course needs to be much huger than mine. But, the components are basically the same with the exception of my battery bank. The only thing I need to change on my system are the batteries every 8 to 10 years. Perhaps the charge controller could be updated from time to time for more efficiency, but not essential.