Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Generators Revisited

Posts

Generators Revisited

#1

Generators Revisited

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I'm posting this as a new message because the older thread has moved down the list.

The question posed was: "Given a non-isolated generator backfeeding the utility line, will the neighbors' lights and air conditioner drain the backfed electrical charge (and trip the generator's internal breakers) before it can reach the guy working on the lines two blocks away?"

The answer from the Jersey Central Power & Light technical rep is as follows:

"No. Electricity is not water flowing in a pipe. When the backfeed occurs, the entire circuit past the transformer becomes energized and there is no appreciable time lag between that energizing event and the energy reaching the service person a mile away. The resulting charge may be quite sufficient to seriously injure or kill an unprotected person contacting the line even as the generator's trip would engage. The energy will discharge along the path of least resistance which in the situation described, would be the person in contact with the line rather than the neighbor's lights."

I do hope this puts the issue to rest.

Peace :)

Re: Generators Revisited

#2

Re: Generators Revisited

Tom Dunlap

Thanks for searching out the answer from an authority.

Tom

Re: Generators Revisited

#3

Thanks for setting us straight!


Re: Generators Revisited

#4

My Concern

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Hey Bill,

I wasn't looking to correct misinformation (there really wasn't any in the previous thread) but rather to not leave a question unanswered that could have such disastrous consequences simply by implication. Every time I hear about somebody getting killed through the misuse of a home generator, it never seems to fail that it was the result of ignorance or misleading information. We have a lot of people who read this board but never post anything. They deserve being able to rely on what they read here.

I'm truly sorry if my comments seemed a bit over-the-top previously, but if doing so might have saved just one person from serious injury, I'll take the blame.

;)

Re: Generators Revisited

#5

Follow-Up

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

JCP&L supervisor called me this morning. They wanted to make sure that I had gotten the correct information to the question I had posed. Very cooperative and concerned about the issue and even offered to send me some print material on the technical aspects. I thanked them but declined as I wouldn't have the knowledge base to digest the tech stuff anyway. Noted from the conversation that this whole generator backfeed thing has become an important problem for them. I got the impression that, while the people working on the lines were a real concern even though they have equipment for protection, a bigger danger seemed to be people contacting downed lines carrying the backfed charge.

Re: Generators Revisited

#6

Re: Follow-Up

bob murphy

Thanks for the very informative posting on home generator usage. In WV where I live, local radio stations broadcast PSA from the electric company, AEP, requesting users of home generators to call AEP and advise them that a generator is being used.

Very interesting that the concern is not only AEP workers but homeowners, as well.