Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

OT - TV above gas fireplace, & efficiency question

Posts

OT - TV above gas fireplace, & efficiency question

#1

OT - TV above gas fireplace, & efficiency question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Part one: We're remodeling a room in the house that's had a fireplace in it. The chimney's currently coming down (multiple issues), but the plan is to put in a new gas fireplace or heater, with a flat screen TV (and all the little boxes that go with a flat screen TV) above it, behind doors. My online reading vaguely talks about heat issues, and then seems to say it's OK except you should pay attention (useful advice). I'd be interested to hear what others have learned from their own experiences.

Part two: I have to spend some time measuring/drawing/thinking, and then time at the stores talking, but my impression is that a gas fireplace is less efficient as a heater than a free-standing gas heater (looks like a woodstove, but gas). If we go with a fireplace, I plan to make a space for it to fit, with insulation, air-sealing, etc., so that we don't lose heat to the outside world from the back of the fireplace; but to get the heat out from behind, we'll need to buy a unit with fans to push the air into the room.

I might have the room for an alcove below the TV, with a stove tucked into it - fully in the conditioned space, in other words. I plan to use foam insulation with a reflective barrier on one side, so I should be keeping most of the heat in the room. I don't know whether I should consider a fan to push the air out of the alcove.

Thoughts from the collective wisdom of this group appreciated.

-------

Bill, who knows he'll never match Barry Irby's record for OT posts, but is making an effort :D

Re: OT - TV above gas fireplace, & efficiency question

#2

JL

Re: OT - TV above gas fireplace, & efficiency ques

JL

I have a propane fireplace. It has heat exchangers under the "fire box". I've never noticed that the mantel (on which we have some candles) has gotten particularly hot. I figure if it isn't melting or softening candles, it should be okay.

I do not have a vented fireplace. Mine is just against the wall w/o a chimney.

Re: OT - TV above gas fireplace, & efficiency question

#3

Re: OT - TV above gas fireplace, & efficiency ques

Bob Lang

I've stayed in a cabin that was heated by one of the "gas heaters that look like a wood stove", and it kept the whole place toasty warm. I think the bigger issue may be the view-ability of the TV. Putting it above the mantel will raise it above eye-level, and that might put a crick in your neck. It's one of those things that looks good in a picture, but doesn't work so well in real life.

Bob Lang

Re: OT - TV above gas fireplace, & efficiency question

#4

Re: OT - TV above gas fireplace, & efficiency ques

Carol

Not necessarily true, Bob.

I have tri-focals. I look at a TV with the top - or distant- vision of my glasses. I REALLY get a cramp in the neck when they are placed too low.

Re: OT - TV above gas fireplace, & efficiency question

#5

Re: OT - TV above gas fireplace, & efficiency ques

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, FL

With the trash on TV today, best place for it would be in the fireplace.

Re: OT - TV above gas fireplace, & efficiency question

#6

Re: OT - TV above gas fireplace, & efficiency ques

Barry Irby

Since I love to post OT posts I Guess its only fitting I should participate and try to help answer one.

I have heard that the makers of flat panel TV's will void the warranty if it is installed above a fireplace. I don't know if it is really true, but it might be wise to confirm one way or another with the maker.

The people I know who put a fan in their fireplaces don't use them. The noise drives them crazy and they stop using the fan.

I think the stove version would be more efficient. Follow the building code and the installation instructions carefully.

Re: OT - TV above gas fireplace, & efficiency question

#7

Re: OT - TV above gas fireplace, & efficiency ques

John Veerkamp

Modern Gas fireplaces are designed with 0 or minimal clearance. There should be no heat issue for the TV. With outside air for combustion and no exchange with heated air , you'll get decent heat. Check BTU ratings to get the appropriate size for you. Also, it's a good idea to listen to the fans before purchasing. Simple 110 units so an extension cord and a helpful seller can resolve this question, There are good units and there are cr@@@y units.

Re: OT - TV above gas fireplace, & efficiency question

#8

Elevated TV report

Yonak

It's been about a year since we put our TV up near the ceiling and I must report that we quite like it that way. We have had no cricks in necks nor have we had any complaints. It's much like a movie screen, plus I feel it helps to see it from a distance.


Re: OT - TV above gas fireplace, & efficiency question

#9

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Principal differences.....

Jesper, Denmark

Hi Bill,

A freestanding heater - whatever the fuel - heats by convection and a fireplace primarily by radiation. The convection heater transfers much more of the energy to the surrounding air than the radiation heater.

Re: OT - TV above gas fireplace, & efficiency question

#10

Re: Very Good Dropper

William Duffield

Sebastopuddle is about 15 miles from the epicenter of the 1906 San Francisco earthquake, and just about on top of the Hayward fault. Big screen TVs are like jagulars--when you look up, they drop on you.

Re: OT - TV above gas fireplace, & efficiency question

#11

Re: OT - TV above gas fireplace, & efficiency ques

Bob Lasley

Bill,

We have had a TV and associated boxes above our ventless gas fireplace for 13 years with not problems. Of course, it is an older traditional TV, not a flat screen.

As for it's efficiency, the ventless gas logs pretty much heated our entire 1800 sq ft house during an ice storm power outage a few years ago. I think the key is ventless because there is no place else for the heat to go.

Good luck,

Bob

Re: OT - TV above gas fireplace, & efficiency question

#12

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

THE Bob Lasley?

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

No way!!

Long time, no see!

I remember meeting you at Ray's place in Anderson, IN. I think it was the End'o'Pond gathering. Haven't seen you online in quite some time--welcome back!

Jason

Re: OT - TV above gas fireplace, & efficiency question

#13

Re: THE Bob Lasley?

Bob Lasley

It are me. Yes, it has been a long time since the gathering at Ray's place and I'm not sure where all the time went. I'm afraid I suffered a major woodworking burnout and ran away for awhile, but alas the sweet odor of sawdust is calling me back. It's good to see some familiar names still about and kind of you to remember me. I'm looking forward to hanging out with you fine folks again.