Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Going natural with oak?

Posts

Going natural with oak?

#1

Going natural with oak?

Stephen Kirk

I'm working on a set of three bookcases, which are for me. These are big frame and panel jobs. They are made of red oak. The oak, as it likes to do, put up a fight and enjoyed giving me lots of tear out. I corrected much of the tear out, but there is still quite a bit. For the panels, I'm using birch ply.

My original thought was to leave the panels natural, then color the oak pieces, then assemble, then shoot a finish. Now, I'm looking at the huge stack of pieces (72 all together) with some tear out issues and I'm thinking I don't want to color all of these prior to assembly. So, I may color the birch ply, then assemble and shoot a finish, or I'll leave everything uncolored, assemble and finish.

I like to spray waterborne (in a home shop, I don't want to deal with excess chemicals). Has anyone seen any finishes that can help enhance this? I quite like natural (or minimally) finished pieces and have several already. I also thought of shooting a bit of garnet shellac to add a bit of color prior to the finish coats. I use the little Earlex and it works well. Given the size of these, I don't think I want to brush or hand finish. I've had good luck with General's waterbornes, and wondering if one of those might give some nice ambering.

Re: Going natural with oak?

#2

I'm flummoxed

Bill Tindall

I have run thousands of bdft of red oak through a planer and only a tiny amount of it ever experienced tear out. I regard oak as the most reliable wood to plane. Something is wrong!

Then there is the birch plywood with oak combination. I can not imagine any finish that will rescue these clashing grains and colors. Why not oak plywood with oak?

Dilute any finish and it will produce a close to the wood minimalist finish.

Re: Going natural with oak?

#3

Re: Going natural with oak?

Joseph Mulherin, sr

My thought on the tear outs when you are using the plane...... did you run the wood thru with the grain going with the blades or was it against the grain? This would explain the tear outs if it was run incorrectly.

Think of it like running from the stem of a leaf down to the end where it flares out....with the grain...not against.

Re: Going natural with oak?

#4

Re: Going natural with oak?

Stephen Kirk

I had some reversing grain which gave me problems.

Re: Going natural with oak?

#5

Re: I'm flummoxed

Stephen Kirk

Maybe I'm unlucky. Lot of grain reversal going on. My hand planing isn't the greatest, but I do ok. Still had to do a lot of flipping of boards. Cabinet scraper on unruly parts, then sanding to 220. When sanding I can see little spots where sawdust collects. Few areas of tear out I can't fix easily as its right at a joint.

I can still make them look good. I went with birch to put some difference in the look. Dry assembled I liked it. I was looking for some contrast.

This is a project that started back in Feb that kept getting moved around. I really need to just complete them.

Re: Going natural with oak?

#6

Re: Going natural with oak?

Dave Paine

The only water borne finish I have used which adds any colour is General Finish's Enduro-Var. I really like this product. Not cheap, but it goes on very easy. You will even be able to brush with good results.

Give this a test and if needed, use a first coat of shellac.

Re: Going natural with oak?

#7

Bob

Re: Going natural with oak?

Bob

Someone gave me this formula.

Go to Woodworker's Supply at WWW.woodworker.com and order J.E. Moser's golder Amber Maple water-based aniline dye 4 oz. item # W14904 $18.29 you mix it in boiling water and it goes a long way.

You also need to purchase from www.mohawk-finishing.com the Heavy-bodied glaze Van Dyke Brown quart, item #M506-14786 at $11.08 or gallon #m506-14787 $33.44 it to goes a long way. Just follow the instruction on both

It looks real nice on white oak and makes the piece look like it was fumed. I don't know the look your going for but you can fill the tare out with this. But use 1 pound cut of Shellac as a sealer then do the finish above. http://www.woodcraft.com/Product/2020580/24849/Timbermate-Wood-Filler-Water-Based-8oz-Red-Oak.aspx

Re: Going natural with oak?

#8

Bob

Re: Going natural with oak?

Bob

Watch this on YouTube from CN. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zn2uv3BP358

Re: Going natural with oak?

#9

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Going natural with oak? WB lacquer & Transtint

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

I use GF's Enduro WB lacquer, and a few drops of Transtint 'honey amber' to get the look of an oil-based varnish. It yellows the finish just enough to add some warmth and depth.

The Enduro waterborne lacquer sprays beautifully in my HVLP gravity gun, with a 1.2mm tip.