Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Independence Day request

Posts

Re: Independence Day request

#26

Re: Interesting comments

Gary Camp, Bend Oregon

When I was in school we were frequently reminded that anyone who lived on the North American continent was an American.

I was on Vancouver Island some years back in Lumber company sponsered visitor information center. I commented that the Pacific Northwest was one of the lumber capitals of the world. The host took a bit of exception to my comment. He asked my what about B.C. I responded that from my perspective B.C. was part of the PNW as I was speaking of a geographical area not an political area, and who did he have more in common with, someone from Oregon / Washington or Quebec. I got a funny look, and an "I see your point"

Re: Independence Day request

#27

Re: Hope 17/20 is OK for a Canadian

Cameron Hood

I would like to respond to the "American" and "Canuck" question. Up front, I would like to assure everyone that my comments are not meant to offend anyone and if you are, please put it down to my poor use of my writing skills.

First off, I am proud to be a Canadian or "Canuck" and I have never been offended by the term, even when it was used and meant as derogatory. A case of an apparent insult wasted on me. Heck, we refer to ourselves as Canucks so I fail to understand how we can be offended when others refer to us that way.

Second, the term American. Yes, I understand that technically, the term american refers to everyone living in north and south america, however, given the huge influence of the United States in all that goes on in Canada and elsewhere, the term has become more commonly used to refer to a person from only the United States. And now this is where I may offend. I constantly get this feeling in the pit of my stomach that it is rather arrogant for US citizens to refer to two hemispheres as "theirs". And while economically, this might be partially true, (begrudging admission on my part :-) ) we non-US people would still like to think of ourselves as Canadians or Mexicans or whatever.

And now to get this back to woodworking, I also think that the original Robertson screw (Canadian invention) is king and that a "square drive" screw is just a cheap "american" knock off. And yes, you have full rights to take offence at that one! (With tongue firmly planted in cheek!)

Re: Independence Day request

#28

Re: To Be An American

Paul Blackwell

I've taken the test twice, and can't find out how I did. Where are the results?

Re: Independence Day request

#29

Careful Paul

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

You obviously failed and the ICEman will be knocking on your door any day now. :D :D

Re: Independence Day request

#30

Hemisphere

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Cameron,

The Monroe Doctrine has fallen into disfavor, if not disuse since the Cuban Missile Crisis. NAFTA for all of it's ills, undermines the theory of Yankee economic control, but US citizens, with their almost genetic propensity for consumerism, remain the largest market. That position is being eroded by the Chinese who are exerting great influence south of the Canal.

Re: Independence Day request

#31

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Hope 17/20 is OK for a Canadian

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

I agree with you Grant, being generalized like that does not sit well with me either. Having said that I find it amusing that a survey or quiz created by someone from another country trying to phrase a question in such a fashion that is defining from only their point of view. The past few weeks I have been in Minneapolis, Philadelphia and New York City, I have encountered many wonderful people in these cities who are from the US and other countries while there. Each city has it's own special character and I loved my time there.

I will say that there is a strong misconception to Americans that we are the same, but to others I met on these trips from places like Australia, Denmark, Germany and others they DO know that Canadians are different than Americans. Grant the way I see any survey that tries to categorize ourselves to be anything other than ourselves as Canadians is a loss to that point of view, we have so much more to us that maybe only we and few others understand. It's our piece of heaven and I am fine if it stays our secret.

My response to that question in the survey would be, Canada is North of America...

Take care my friend,

Jim

Re: Independence Day request

#32

Re: Independence Day request

Brian Anderson Gunsmith

And all this hoopla over a simple sequence of questions that misconstrued and misinterpreted.

People jumping to conclusions not really available.

So here is my take on this.

First of all non of what happened should have been misinterepreted as offensive to anyone.

1. The starting point was a test with questions like the one to become a US citizen.

2. A canadian chimed in with his score.

3. a dumb us citizen chimed in with a question.

dO canadians refer to themselves as americans, canadians or what?

(my caps key is having problems perhaps time for a new pc.)

4. a Canadian not addressed in the question by (3) responded that he was offended.

5. some apologizing by (3) didn't make all happy.

Now for the record had I been asked the same question I would have responded.

1. i was born in the usa, so were my parents and their parents.

2. the most distant ancestor was allegedly from scotland so the or what qualifies.

3. his son was born in a small town near albany ny in 1763.

he fought on the side of the british along with his brother and father.

at the end of the american revolution he fled the 13 colonies to new brunswick.

he got a kings grant near a town now called woodstock.

he married and had several children including the one i descend from in new brunswick so I descend from canadians so the canadian part is true also.

bottom line is that i qualify for all 3 of the parts of my own question.

of course the term american could well refer to anyone who lives in any of the countries on either of the two continents with the word america in them.

in a way much like some in europe could refer to themselves as europeans and also whatever country they are actually from.

tHe question was genuine do canadians ever refer tot hemselves as american.

the answer to that appears to be no.

personally i have never seen anyone other than citizens of the united states of america refer to themselves as americans. but i have not met alot of canadians in person. only a handful.

i have met a few brazilians. who also refer to themselves as brazilian and not american.

why all the anger/hostility? a simple question that could have had a simple answer got blown way out of proportion and i am suddenly public enemy number one.

Well guess what I am a US citizen I descend from several generations born in CAnada and I my most ancient ancestor is most likely from sCotland. So I am an American , Canadian descent and scottish descent.

why can't these emotions come forth with something that really matters (relative to this website) like whether you cut the tails or the pins first in a dovetail?

Re: Independence Day request

#33

the next time you're in Minneapolis

Bruce, a MN Galoot

let me know, and we can meet for coffee. Or something.

Re: Independence Day request

#34

It really wasn't all that bad, Brian

Bill Howatt

The problem was that us Canadians reading your reply jumped to the stereotypical conclusion that Americans feel that everybody wants to be American. Granted, your question could have been worded better and once you explained your intent about the word American as in North America your point became clear and actually was a good question.

Canadians feel that Americans, except for those Americans who live in the border states, know very, very little about Canada and this also contributed to how your question was read.

We have our sterotypical view of Americans too, such as showing up at the border in July with snowshoes strapped to the roof of their car. Good story but I don't know if it really happened.

Bill

Re: Independence Day request

#35

Snowshoes in July

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"We have our sterotypical view of Americans too, such as showing up at the border in July with snowshoes strapped to the roof of their car."

There are parts of the U.S. - I'm thinking Tioga Pass out of Yosemite, in the Sierra in California, but there are others - where, some years, snowshoes would be useful footwear in July.

Re: Independence Day request

#36

Our last day of Public skiing...

Gary Camp, Bend Oregon

Was July first this year.

glc

Re: Independence Day request

#37

And then we have Crater Lake, Oregon

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

which has recorded snow on all but one date, sometime around July 10. Not, you understand, every year - but over the years.