Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Some stain results with ferric acetate

Posts

Some stain results with ferric acetate

#1

Some stain results with ferric acetate

John in NM

The ferric acetate solution was made using roughly a quart of vinegar and 1 biscuit of steel wool. After sitting 3 weeks or so, it was filtered with a coffee filter to remove any residual iron particles.

The order of all samples is the same in each photo, left to right:

1. 4 coats ferric acetate solution

2. 4 coats ferric acetate, followed by peroxide wash

3. 4 coats ferric acetate followed by lye wash, then peroxide -- this one looks most like the ferric nitrate stains I've seen.

4. 4 coats of ferric acetate mixed 50-50 with peroxide

All four samples finished with BLO thinned 25% with turpentine.

First two are in direct sunlight, the angle makes a big difference in the perceived color of the first and second samples:



This pic taken in shade, looks more like the eye perceives indoors:


Same shady location, but with the flash. This one is probably most accurate for colors, but you can't really see the grain in this moderately curly maple.


Now my chemistry is a bit sketchy, last class was 20 years or more back and I was really only paying much attention to the stuff I thought applied to mineralogy. So I won't attempt to explain how this works, I do understand the gist of it, but I'd have to fudge the details :D

We're sure to have a chemist lurking around here somewhere right?

Re: Some stain results with ferric acetate

#2

Would have been nice if,

Keith Newton

You had included a sample of untreated, to have as a baseline.

Did you write the other day that the FA turned some woods black? Did you do other wood samples along with this?

Re: Some stain results with ferric acetate

#3

Turns walnut black...

John in NM

Maple just a dark greenish grey. You can see the ends of a couple grey pieces at the bottom of the last pic. Those were the FA solution diluted 50-50 with vinegar and water. If I'd let the diluted solution stand for a few days the results would likely have been similar to the first and second samples, just not as dark. Pushing the solution more acidic causes the grey/green color, I think - ferrous acetate rather than ferric.

Baseline piece would just be regular maple, but I do know what you mean. I did this looking for a specific color, so I was more interested in comparing results than having a baseline for comparison.

Here's a pic of those other two pieces with the diluted solution:


The one on the left is diluted with water, then half of it washed with peroxide, the one on the right is diluted with vinegar and half washed with lye.

Re: Some stain results with ferric acetate

#4

Re: Turns walnut black...

Keith Newton

Thanks, The last time I actually used any of these kind of coloring processes was over 30 years ago, when I was in my old shop. I used lye to darken Padauk, which turns dark purplish brown, similar to East Indian Rosewood. After committing to it, I didn't know if I needed to do something to neutralize it before finishing. The vinegar would just turn it back to orange, so I rinsed it with water, which meant that it needed sanding again for raised grain, which then needed touch-up.

Finally I got it finished, but decided that it would have been a whole lot easier to just use a stain. Back then, I had a good paint store within a mile of here, that had a lot of depth of experience. I got them to mix me a stain for Genuine Mahogany that was really close to that color. But they are long gone now. I surely wish I had gotten that formula before they closed.

Re: Some stain results with ferric acetate

#5

I've nothing against stains

John in NM

They are often the best solution, I've just never found one I liked for maple. This stuff doesn't seem to muddy up the grain the way gel stains do, and it penetrates evenly the way minwax type stuff doesn't :D Thought of trying some dyes but there's that color fastness problem with some, and uneven penetration (again) with others - the transtint in alcohol that I have on hand.

Results here are quite good enough that I plan to use one of these processes on a maple stock that I'm making.

Re: Some stain results with ferric acetate

#6

craigd

Re: Would have been nice if,

craigd

Did you write the other day that the FA turned some woods black?

Here is some white oak (heart and sap) with FA and ammonia.



Left to right: branch, fumed branch, FA on branch + finish, heart wood w/sap + FA, heart stick cut in half to show how deep the color change is (not very), "raw" heart wood, some bits.

If I apply more than one coat, there is virtually no change after the first coat, like the tannic acid has all reacted with the first coat.

BTW, Apple + FA somewhat like the lower right chip, ie not very pleasing.

Re: Some stain results with ferric acetate

#7

Re: Would have been nice if,

Keith Newton

Thanks Craig and John. Looks like I might ought to give this a try, if my puppy hasn't eaten all my steel-wool. She has gotten large enough to start working on mid-level shelves, and shredded a sleeve recently. She will think I'm making her some pickles. Ha

Re: Some stain results with ferric acetate

#8

craigd

Re: Would have been nice if,

craigd

I have better luck making FA by putting "black" steel (the hot rolled steel you get about anywhere) or rusty steel in vinegar. The steel wool I get seems to be oiled, which inhibits conversion. I "pickle" sole plates before machining so I have lots of the juice, it keeps forever.

Re: Some stain results with ferric acetate

#9

Oil

John in NM

You can rinse steel wool with acetone or alcohol to remove the oil. I've even heard of burning it off, though I wouldn't try that having seen steel wool burn before - stuff makes a great fire starter if you get it hot enough.

I wonder if you get good results with mill scale because it's iron oxide? Could be that was more in line with what the fella who suggested burning the SW was talking about - oxide. The guy who told me that thought it was to remove oil, but as I typed that, it occurred to me that it could be to get it to dissolve more easily.

Does that white oak lighten a bit when you put the ammonia on? I would expect it based on what happened with lye, but then there's always a surprise or two with seat of the pants chemistry :D

Re: Some stain results with ferric acetate

#10

Steel wool as fire starter

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Add a bunch of Vaseline and carry a 9-volt battery in a separate baggie. It starts instantly and burns hot and long. It's an old boy scout leader trick :D

Re: Some stain results with ferric acetate

#11

craigd

Re: Oil

craigd

I wonder if you get good results with mill scale because it's iron oxide?

I believe you are correct as rusty steel works just as well.

Does that white oak lighten a bit when you put the ammonia on?

No, it gets "browner" (I put it in a plastic bag with a can of household ammonia). Nothing like the FA change but pronounced (and sapwood is quite different from heart). The sapwood change is underwhelming at first but with a finish and sun/time, is quite pleasant.

Here are the same pieces with finish:



Seven months later, the ladle is almost the color of lightish heartwood (finish was BLO + lacquer) and the black spoon hasn't changed.

Re: Some stain results with ferric acetate

#12

That's pretty cool Bruce...

John in NM

I remember a friend burning some years ago, but I can't remember now if he used a torch or just a lighter to get it going. Vaseline and a battery sounds like an improvement though :D

Bet you could use butter too - I like dual purpose stuff :D