Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

byrd cutter

Posts

byrd cutter

#1

byrd cutter

mikemcnerney

I bought the byrd cutterhead 2.5 years ago for my jointer & thicknesser & haven't looked back. It's still cutting great in domestic hardwoods & the occasional exotic wood.

I will be planing a moderate amount of figured bubinga and curly maple.

I thought maybe now is the time to rotate the carbide? But there is something in my memory that says "a little bit dull" regular knife can work better on curl ?

Any one out there with the byrd have an opinion?

MM

Re: byrd cutter

#2

Re: byrd cutter

mdclor

I seem to vaguely recall lightly dampening the wood, but I don't recall using slightly dull blades. Usually, sharper is better, however, I have been wrong before. :)

Re: byrd cutter

#3

All Wet

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Had a contractor friend helping me prep some stock for a kitchen r&r that I was helping him with. Had to plane some cherry that had some grain changes etc.

First cuts tore out, of course, so on the second go I asked him to hand me "that spray bottle of tear-out preventer" from the shelf.

I wet down the cut face and ran it through with a lighter cut and the board came out perfect. He was quite impressed and asked if that preventer stuff would work of softer woods.

I replied "Sure, but it's pretty tough to find in a lumber yard or woodworker's supply."

He looked a bit disappointed and asked, "The next time you order some, can you get me a gallon of so?"

I replied "sure, but I've got an extra gallon now if you really need it."

When he nodded, I took an empty gallon jug, went to the shop faucet, filled it with fresh cold water, and handed it to him. He then knew he'd been "had" but learned something valuable at the same time. We still laugh about that magical planing fluid.

Re: byrd cutter

#4

And You Were Deluged With Gratitude!


Re: byrd cutter

#5

Ellis Walentine

Good question -- Wish I knew the answer

Ellis Walentine

My empirical approach would be to try it on a sample piece of the wood you intend to plane and see how it works. I always err on the sharp side, but it would be interesting to have some firsthand reporting. Let us know.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: byrd cutter

#6

Re: byrd cutter

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I have a Byrd head on my 20" planer (and a similar Grizzly head on my 8" joiner).

I do recall reading about some people changing their planer knife cutting angle on regular tool steel knives by adding a back bevel to reduce tear out. Obviously this is not feasible on the carbide inserts. I have rotated my inserts on the planer due to getting some lines in the finished wood due to minor chips in some inserts - this was after more than 4 years of moderate home use with some pretty hard woods. I have ran curly Maple, figured cherry, red and white Oak, Purple heart, Walnut, black Locust, etc. all with no problems at all. One of the worst woods I ran was some Honey Locust - had a pretty gnarly grain and really tore out with my old straight blade planer / joiner. I did spray some water on some of the worst but had almost zero tear out using sharp carbide insert heads. I can't see why a dull insert would prevent tear out as you can't change the cutting angle and I would think being dull would actually increase the problem. My experience with these heads indicate you won't have much problem at all - if you do a little water will probably prevent any issues.