Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Varnish suggestion

Posts

Varnish suggestion

#1

Varnish suggestion

Henry

Hi,

I am new to woodworking. Please bear with me if I ask silly questions.

I purchased a handcrafted wooden chess set during a holiday trip. The chess set is covered in a thin layer of non-glossy varnish. The black pieces were painted before they were varnished. I have no information about the original varnish the craftman used.

Now I want the set to have a glossy appearance as if they were covered in a thin layer of glass. I want the varnish's shiny appearance to be durable, non-yellowing, and easy to apply, especially since the set is a heirloom-quality set with many small details. Any suggestion what kind of varnish I should choose? Or should I leave the set as is?

Thanks.

Henry

Re: Varnish suggestion

#2

Ellis Walentine

Re: Varnish suggestion

Ellis Walentine

Hi Henry,

There are no silly questions here. Yours is a good one.

There are a few variables here that you may not be aware of. First, the term "varnish" is a loose one. It is just as likely, perhaps more so, that these pieces are coated with something other than varnish as we know it, such as some sort of lacquer. What this means is that you want to test the compatibility of your topcoat with the existing finish; otherwise you could end up with a mess.

One way to avoid compatibility problems is to apply a "barrier coat" of shellac over the existing finish. Shellac is compatible with most finishes and will provide a good base for your topcoat. I'd recommend using Zinsser Seal Coat, thinned about 20% with alcohol. If you have an airbrush, you could spray the shellac, otherwise a small bristle brush should do the trick.

As for the topcoat, consider function first. If this set will be played a lot, you want something that will be impervious to contamination and wear. High-gloss lacquer would be a good bet, as it is easy to apply if you have an airbrush or small spray setup. You'd want to make a little turntable to spin the piece as you spray, to ensure an even coating. To preserve those fine details and prevent runs and sags, you need to adjust your spray for a light coat, and build it slowly with several applications.

If you want to try an actual varnish, there are plenty of them out there to choose from. You would thin it somewhat and apply it with a brush, again making sure to keep your coats thin in order to prevent sags. The downside of varnish is that it dries comparatively slowly, so the film does tend to sag and puddle in the details. Also, since it dries slowly, there's more time for airborn dust to settle into the film, and this will prove to be a real headache, as sanding between coats is out of the question.

There are heavy, glossy finishes sold for decoupage that could do the trick, too, but they are so thick that I don't think they would retain the details you want to preserve.

So there's my two cents. I am sure there are others.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Varnish suggestion

#3

Re: Varnish suggestion *LINK*

mdclor

Great advice, as always, Ellis. I would only add that spraying lacquer can also be done with aerosol cans. It would be prudent to test prior to using it on the actual pieces both to get a feel for how it works and looks. Here is one product, but there are others that will work as well. HTH


Deft spray lacquer

Re: Varnish suggestion

#4

Aersol lacquer and fine finish are not equal

Dick Coers

The nozzles in those cans are horrible, and an invitation for orange peel. I also hate Deft, well Deft from a regular can anyway. They put lots of retarder in it so it can be sold as a brushing lacquer. I don't know if the formulation is the same between the aerosol and the can. It seems to be "soft" compared to traditional lacquer. My friend used Deft on a walnut desk, and a doll craddle. The Deft reacted to the desk protector and it melted into the desk. The Deft on the doll cradle melted the foot of the doll that was in contact with it. I now use Sherwin Williams only.

Re: Varnish suggestion

#5

non-yellowing?

Bill Tindall

Ellis you need to add some more information if non-yellowing is a requirement. Nitrocellulose lacquer yellow a lot and so does most varnish.

Re: Varnish suggestion

#6

not varnish

Bill Tindall

varnish's shiny appearance to be durable, non-yellowing, and easy to apply,

Those requirements eliminate every possibility I can think of. Lacquer and varnish typically yellow significantly. Wipe ons are easy to apply and not durable. Many water based finishes aren't bright like lacquer and varnish.

Anything that gets used will need to be refinished some day so I would add ease of refinishing to the list. I would probably spray the pieces with blond shellac. Butyrate lacquer (stays water white) would be another choice. If you have never sprayed a finish these pieces are not the place to practice. Hire someone to do it or practice on something else until proficient.

Re: Varnish suggestion

#7

Re: Varnish suggestion

Henry

Thanks for the reply. Both you and Bill recommend using shellac on top of existing varnish/lacquer. Is shellac easy to apply, and non-yellowing?

I have heard a lot of nasty things about various types of varnish and lacquer. Yellowing/discoloration is one of them. Another one is the inability to fix if the varnish goes bad at some point in the future. So I am still not too sure what to use as the top coat.

By the way, is shellac alone adequate for my need?

Thanks.

Henry

Re: Varnish suggestion

#8

Re: not varnish

Henry

Thanks for the reply. You brought up a good point on the ease of refinishing. I mean I don't mind doing refinishing once a year or so, as long as it is convenient to apply.

I am still concerned about the yellowing factor, especially if the finishing is going to be permanent and hard to fix at some point in the future.

It looks like the more I know, the more concerned I become. Now I am thinking that it is possible the existing finishing that the craftman used is the yellowing type. :(

I don't know what to do now.

Re: Varnish suggestion

#9

Ellis Walentine

I wouldn't worry

Ellis Walentine

All finishes have a cast to them. Lacquers are the only ones I know of that are "water white." Regardless, I wouldn't worry too much about the aging of the finish, as I suspect a chess set will be functional no matter what finish you apply.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Varnish suggestion

#10

Re: I wouldn't worry

Henry

Thanks for the advice. I'll start working on it right away. =D

Re: Varnish suggestion

#11

nitrocellulose lacquer will yellow substantially

Bill Tindall

Butyrate lacquer doesn't yellow much and acrylics don't typically yellow. Common lacquer is based on nitrocellulose and it will make a light colored wood a most undesirable yellow color after some time.

Re: Varnish suggestion

#12

You mentioned Black paint.....

Barry Irby

If the black pieces are painted black, what are the chances its black lacquer? Are they stained black with the wood showing or are they opaque black? You can buy black lacquer. Once you test the surface for compatibility, you can over coat them with black lacquer or you could apply a barrier coat of shellac and then coat them with the black lacquer.

Are the white pieces painted white? White lacquer is also available.

Automotive lacquer/finish might be a good choice. What are the possibilities of finding a person in an autobody shop to do this for you?

Re: Varnish suggestion

#13

Re: Aersol lacquer and fine finish are not equal

PaulSV

I have had pretty good luck spraying small items with the Preval Sprayer:

http://www.preval.com/what-is-preval

It works much better than the rattle cans, tho not as good as a decent airbrush. If you happen to know a high school art teacher, it would be a source to borrow an airbush and small compressor.

For a fairly non-yellowing finish, you might look at water based polyurethane. I believe it could be thinned and sprayed with the Preval sprayer.

Re: Varnish suggestion

#14

Re: not varnish

Howard Acheson

My preference would be an alkyd/soya oil varnish like Pratt & Lambert 38. You want to avoid linseed oil and tung varnishes both of which are significantly amber and become more amber over time. The P&L 38 has minimal yellow cast when applied and does not yellow significantly over time.

Varnish would be the most durable finish particularly for items that will get handled frequently. Oils in and on fingers will ultimately damage most finish, some faster than others. The P&L 38 is an excellent finish.

Re: Varnish suggestion

#15

where can you get it

Bill Tindall

I am a fan of varnish for many items. This varnish has been recommended and used for decades but I have never been able to locate a place that even knows about it. Thinned and sprayed on I agree it would make a dandy finish but I am not so sure shellac would not be another good one for this application. When it came time to refinish the pieces could just be soaked in alcohol, brushed with a tooth brush, rinsed and recoated.

Re: Varnish suggestion

#16

Kneale Brownson

STOP!!!!

Kneale Brownson

You call this chess set an heirloom version. Does this mean it has a dollar value or an artistic value? If dollar value, you may not want to refinish it unless you don't care about the dollar value.

If you're going to refinish, I'd use shellac. As someone else mentioned, it's easy to refinish repeatedly by removing the old with alcohol.

Re: Varnish suggestion

#17

Re: where can you get it

Howard Acheson

I get it here: www.hardwoodlumberandmore.com/eStore/ProductDetail/tabid/119/rvdsfpid/278/rvdsfcatid/45/Default.aspx

But it should be available at any real paint store. Pratt & Lambert is a old company.

If you live in California or some other VOC restrictive area, you may not be able to get it.

Re: Varnish suggestion

#18

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Varnish suggestion

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Against the grain, a bit, I'd suggest cleaning the pieces thoroughly, and de-glossing them a bit, then spraying them with a water-borne pre-cat lacquer. It'll dry/cure water-clear, glossy, and hard and durable.

I've been using the M.L. Campbell waterborne Pre-Cat stuff, and I like it a lot.