Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

OT-Concrete bathroom floor?

Posts

OT-Concrete bathroom floor?

#1

Alan Young

OT-Concrete bathroom floor?

Alan Young

I'm deep into remodeling our 2nd floor bathroom. (See Weekend Accomplishment thread below). Our plan all along has been to put down a tile floor. But I just started to think about concrete as a possible alternative. I know it's been used on counter tops and a basement floor would seem to pose no problems. But what if we wanted to do this on a 2nd floor? Is this a bad idea?

-Alan

Re: OT-Concrete bathroom floor?

#2

Weight and thickness

John in NM

I would guess its a bit too heavy for the existing joists, even when relatively thin like a counter top (say, 2"). If the floor can stand the weight, how would you deal with the bath floor being 2" or more taller?

Re: OT-Concrete bathroom floor?

#3

Re: Weight and thickness

John McGaw

I'd guess it would be doable but there would be quite a few steps backward to modify the structure before anything could be done safely. Both of the upstairs bathrooms and the entry foyer in my mid-60s ranch home have tile or slate floors laid over a mud bed (weighs the same as concrete). The secret seems to be that they left out the subfloor below these rooms and placed plywood between the joists rather than on top so that there was extra depth for the slab. They also used 2" deeper joists in these locations to support the extra weight.

If I wanted that look I think I'd go with plywood and cement backer with 24" square concrete-looking porcelain tile and thin grout lines rather than go to all of the extra work. Good chance to put in heating mat at the same time.

Re: OT-Concrete bathroom floor?

#4

Re: OT-Concrete bathroom floor?

NickinMass

I'd suggest you stick with your original plan with tile. As with the previous posters, I would worry about weight and depth, not to mention the existing structure's ability to meet the floor stiffness requirements (I imagine a concrete slab will need a very stiff floor to avoid cracking). Since you are talking about a second floor room, I imagine you don't have the ability to easily modify the floor structure.

CBUs or Hardibacker with vitreous or through-body porcelain tile (I personally like through-body porcelain - expensive, but you get the look of stone and only need to meet the floor stiffness requirements for porcelain tile). We've done a couple bathrooms and a kitchen with the through-body and have been very happy.

Re: OT-Concrete bathroom floor?

#5

Re: OT-Concrete bathroom floor?

Brian Aust

There is a product that has been used for quite a while in the hydronic heating industry called Gypcrete. It is a gypsum based concrete that is much lighter than normal 'crete, I believe it is also poured thinner than normal concrete.

Re: OT-Concrete bathroom floor?

#6

gypcrete

mdclor

We used this when we build our current house. It was poured 1.5" thick and had radiant heat lines included. It weighs about 4 pounds less than regular concrete per square foot at 1.5". We put porcelain tiles on top and haven't had any tiles crack. If you do use concrete, be careful about getting it too smooth because it would be quite slippery when wet. FWIW