Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Three Season Room Foundation-Footers or Piers?

Posts

Three Season Room Foundation-Footers or Piers?

#1

Three Season Room Foundation-Footers or Piers?

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Friends,

SWMBO has her heart set on a three season room built on the site of our screened in back porch slab. We have had estimates and can afford the expense, but my #3 son looked at the bids and told me there would be a lot of extra work not covered by the bids. He took a shovel and dug next to the slab and discovered there were no footings. Laying a footing on three sides of the room would be expensive. Further, we would not be using the entire slab for the room. The existing patio would have to be trenched parallel to one of the porch's side walls to permit footing installation. Cement work ain't cheap.

I believe we'll need a foundation to support the glass and screen panels of the new room. I wonder if we couldn't sink concrete piers and bridge them to carry the structure. Alternatively, I could just put up the glass and screen panels on top of the concrete slab, but that may lead to problems down the road. OTOH, the slab is several decades old, and has only a couple settlement cracks. It is stable.

What do you think?

George

Re: Three Season Room Foundation-Footers or Piers?

#2

Ooogie Boogie Boogie

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The Dreaded Codeman cometh.

You son is correct, you've got work to do. Footings will have to go below the frost line (here 3') and the slab must be supported. Stabil on fill will not get you (or your heirs) a CofO.

My group did one of these "conversions" for a member and when we got done with the planning stage and township approvals, it was cheaper to bust up the existing porch/slab and start over, footers to roof, from scratch. We wasted a whole bunch of time trying to get 'round code requirements. We wound up doing a slab-on-grade mono-pour for a 24x24 addition, complete with hot tub.

Re: Three Season Room Foundation-Footers or Piers?

#3

Re: Three Season Room Foundation-Footers or Piers?

Barry Irby

I see you are north and east of me. Probably slightly colder in winter.

The disadvantage of the pier foundation is that the wind blows under it in winter making the floor cold. Depending on the height of the floor off the slab below you could insulate under the floor and "skin" the underside with some sort of storm siding or plywood. You would want to seal it up well to to keep the cold out and to keep vermin out.

You could hang the joists off the house and then put a beam along the outer side to support the outer end. Assuming the joists run perpendicular to the house you would need little or no support on the "ends". Perhaps double or triple the end joists.

If you want to provide HVAC you might look into one of the little ductless heat pumps. If the room is "all glass" it could take a somewhat oversize system. Even a little HVAC would improve the usefulness of the room a lot.

Re: Three Season Room Foundation-Footers or Piers?

#4

Re: Three Season Room Foundation-Footers or Piers?

Joseph Mulherin, Sr.

George, I have to agree with Mark on the total rebuilding of the slab from scratch.

Since the slab is decades old there is no rebar inside it to prevent the cracks you

are seeing...even though you say it is stable now. You could put in some pier posts ( probably one every 8ft each way and raise the floor above ground, insulate it from the cold and heat like Barry says, but do not try to get around the codes and do a fix-it-whatever.

Re: Three Season Room Foundation-Footers or Piers?

#5

I guess I'll be the only one to say it...

John in NM

Are you planning to get a permit, inspection, and C of O? Some municipalities are very strict, and the lack of a C of O can cause problems when it comes time to sell. Others are not so worried about it, taking the view of the permitting process as more of a revenue stream than much else. Others do not have a code department at all, leaving the question to the county or state (that's where I live :D )

Putting a footer in for a bunch of glass is pretty much swatting a fly with a CBU - just my opinion, I say this expecting much dissent, but I am at least hoping for the low horsed type :D

Now given where I live, and knowing a lot about the soil and such, if the existing slab has been stable over the years I would likely go ahead and try it. However, I'm not you, and though I do share your taste for sparkling malt beverages (to swipe a Red Green line), you may not share my tolerance for wildcatting a structural feature or two :D

Re: Three Season Room Foundation-Footers or Piers?

#6

Re: I guess I'll be the only one to say it...

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Hello John,

My son and I are of the same mind on this one. We need to involve the township and meet whatever code governs. I do agree that the existing slab is plenty strong enough to support a glass and screen wall. But its going to be as the township engineer says.

George

Re: Three Season Room Foundation-Footers or Piers?

#7

George,  "As The Township Says . ."

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Translation: You're screwed, Buddy.

[But I seriously hope not. ;) ]

Re: Three Season Room Foundation-Footers or Piers?

#8

Now, now, they're not all like that

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'm blessed; our city's inspector really likes homeowner-remodelers, and is very supportive. He's a crabby old dude, but once you get past that surface, he's great to work with.

I can't say that of all his predecessors; and he's of an age that I'm hoping I can finish the work on our house before he retires (or, barring that, that his sucessor is as easy to work with); but I've been quite pleased with him.

But, of course, not everyone's so lucky. I'm sure, though, that the Colonel will exercise his charm on his township's inspectors.

Re: Three Season Room Foundation-Footers or Piers?

#9

Blessed Is Right

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

We don't get "blessed" here; we get "anointed".

Of course there have been enough screwed up inspections followed by serious injuries and High Dollar lawsuits that the guys putting their names on the CofO's have gotten more careful, not to mention intolerant of shortcuts and workarounds.

Job of building inspector used to be a pretty cushy gig, not to mention worthwhile. Not any more

Re: Three Season Room Foundation-Footers or Piers?

#10

Re: Now, now, they're not all like that

John in NM

Reminds me of getting a permit once, and as the water heater was on the plans, the guy doing the permit work insisted that it be "direct vented". "The plans call for an electric water heater" I patiently explained. "Still has to be direct vented" he says. This is how profoundly stupid most code offices have become.

To this day, I have no idea if the guy simply didn't understand the difference, or if he actually expected me to install venting on the off chance that one day someone would install a gas water heater and not realize he also had to vent it. Either way, it was stupid. Fortunately, the inspector simply muttered something about "office weenies" and told me not to worry about it.