Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Tree's botanical name

Posts

Tree's botanical name

#1

Tree's botanical name

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

There is a North American tree (whose name I have forgotten) whose scientific genus and species are the same. Can you help me from going crazy trying to think of it? No prize. ;^)

Al

Re: Tree's botanical name

#2

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Tree's botanical name

#3

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Tree's botanical name

#4

Re: Tree's botanical name

mark Hennebury

Magnolia

Rhododendron

Laburnum

Re: Tree's botanical name

#5

Re: Tree's botanical name *LINK*

Tom Dunlap

Would it be like this for oak:

Quercus quercus

Or elm:

Ulmus ulmus

I can never remember seeing this for any genus/species. If I understand the process for naming plants I don't think that it is possible either.

I found this in the linked page:

The ICN, the plant Code, does not allow the two parts of a binomial name to be the same (such a name is called a tautonym), whereas the ICZN, the animal Code, does. Thus the American bison has the binomial Bison bison; a name of this kind would not be allowed for a plant.

Tom

PS Without looking it up, is anyone familiar with this animal: Testudo aubreii


Binomial nomenclature

Re: Tree's botanical name

#6

JL

Re: Tree's botanical name

JL

Tortoise named after Jack Aubrey. I forget which book in the Aubrey/Maturin series.

Re: Tree's botanical name

#7

Ellis Walentine

Re: Tree's botanical name

Ellis Walentine

Sorry, Al. I'm not aware of any such Genus-species combinations. I have more wood books than most folks, but there's no good way to look it up that I can see. Let us know if you find what you're looking for.

Ellis

Re: Tree's botanical name

#9

Ellis Walentine

Good grief

Ellis Walentine

I'm not quite interested enough to spend the rest of the afternoon gazing at that list, Mark, but it looks like a good resource. Thanks. ;)

Re: Tree's botanical name

#10

JL

If you mean common name and scientific name...

JL

then yes, I would agree.

But genus and species are somewhat different. That was the question that he asked. So as an example you would look for Quercus quercus as opposed to Quercus alba or Quercus rubra.

As Tom said, that isn't likely to happen.

Remember

Domain

Kingdom

Phylum

Class

Order

Family

Genus

Species

All are "unique".

Re: Tree's botanical name

#11

Ellis Walentine

What about...

Ellis Walentine

Homo sapiens sapiens? In that case, subspecies are not necessarily unique.

Ellis

Re: Tree's botanical name

#12

Re: If you mean common name and scientific name...

Mark Hennebury

I stand corrected.

Re: Tree's botanical name

#13

Maybe it is like this,

Keith Newton

A year or two ago, I wanted to start learning all of the frogs and toads in my area, and get good pics of each, just to add to my knowledge, and woodsman-ship.

Across the SE, we have Green Frogs, Rana catesbeiana, which look a lot like a Bullfrog, but never get as large. Through parts of the same area, the Bronze Frog, was named, Rana catesbeiana catesbeiana. It seems like I read why the two catesbeianas, but I'm not sure if it was a husband and wife team naming it, or if it was just a sub-species, later described by the same person as the first.

I have only found scattered, lingering males, which probably got missed during their main breeding period. Their Gunk gunk calls add a nice little gumbo flavor, when mixed in with a chorus of several others species. They make a beautiful music, when lots of males are singing their asses off, hoping a female will come along and choose him to fertilize her eggs.

Maybe you are thinking about a new sub-species. Nothing popped up in my memory of tree species, but my inquetible bwain aint what it used to be.

Re: Tree's botanical name

#14

BarbS

Re: Tree's botanical name *LINK*

BarbS

It isn't North American, but Ginko biloba "took an early form 150 million years ago. This is why botanists give this one tree the unique honor of one species, one genus, one family and one order, all for itself."

This is according to Thomas Pakenham in


Meetings With Remarkable Trees

Re: Tree's botanical name

#15

Meetings with...

Tom Dunlap

...was one of my tour guide books on one trip to the UK. The other was one that had listings for old, wooden sailing ships. My trip started in London, stops at the Greenwich Observatory, a tour of the Cutty Sark, before the fire :( Then, out to Portsmouth to see the Naval yard. The next few days took me north where I saw several of the trees in Pakenham's book. What a trip!

Re: Tree's botanical name

#16

BarbS

Re: Meetings with...

BarbS

It would be! Sounds like a case of sensory overload! I love that book, by the way. Jealous you got to use it for a tour. Wonderful.

Re: Tree's botanical name

#17

Re: Tree's botanical name

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

Barb,

Sorry, but ginkgo (maidenhair-tree) has unique genus and species names which are not identical... Ginkgo biloba.

Al

Re: Tree's botanical name

#18

BarbS

Re: Tree's botanical name

BarbS

I realized it wasn't what you were looking for, but wonder if this bit of trivia may be what you were thinking of? As Tom and JL mentioned, is it even possible?

Re: Tree's botanical name

#19

Re: Tree's & Census dudes

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

Barb,

Sorry. I misunderstood your prevoius post.

Last summer (or was it 2 summers ago?) I had nothing better to do so was browsing Audobon's Field Guide to North American Trees along with a Golden Books Trees of North America. About that time, the U.S. Census dude showed up at the door. He asked a few questions and I, being a Great American, dutifully answered. The talk somehow turned to trees. He commented the "________" is the only tree with genus and species names the same. I had just noted the same thing while reading. Now, alas, I cannot rememmber the tree, hence the question. No way can I track down the census taker, so I thought WCers might come to the rescue.

Al

Re: Tree's botanical name

#20

Dale Lenz

Re: Tree's & Census dudes

Dale Lenz

I have googled your request as has others, I would guess. My finding was: In the animal world you can have genius species with the same name, but in the plant world it is not allowed.

Re: Tree's botanical name

#21

I'll have some answers!

Tom Dunlap

I posted this question on my discussion forum for arborists.

Already there are some clever answers, sorta!

--- English Oak is defined Quercus robur.

A latin dictionary will show you that both quercus and robur mean simply "oak".

So Quercus robur = "Oak oak"--a good combo imo, as the English oak has such an important primordial role. To be literal to the common name, the tree should be named Quercus brittanica or, perhaps, Quercus albion, but that would be giving away to much to the anglophiles..

--- Araucaria araucana.

And than you have the two look alikes with leaves that refer to each other. Platanus acerifolia and Acer platanoides. Confusing confusing. ;-)


--- Macedonian Pine (Pinus peuce)

Pinus, lat. "pine"

peuke, grk. "pine"

"Pine pine"

--- Tamarack, Larix laricina

--- Shrimp scampi

--- Arctostaphylos uva-ursi the common name: kinnickinnick

Arktos = Bear in Greek

Staphylos= Berry or Grape in Greek

Uva=Berry or Grape in Latin

Ursi= Bear in Latin

If more get posted I'll put them in this post.

Tom

Re: Tree's botanical name

#22

Re: Tree's & Census dudes

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

Good morning Dale,

While I agree that such would not be allowed today, isn't it possible that duplicate names were allowed in the past and not changed when the current guidelines went into effect?

Al

Re: Tree's botanical name

#23

Dale Lenz

Re: Tree's & Census dudes

Dale Lenz

Good morning to you also, Al,

Sure anything is possible, one thing I recall from.... I believe my forest genetic class. The botanical name is a man made and man control thing. I have seen a botanical name(s) change in my short 40 years of messing with trees, which I thought was not suppose to happen, don't recall which or what tree species that was. S0....I not saying that you did not see the same genius-species name at one time referring to a tree but my short 15-20 minute search did not turn up anything. As Ellis said in an earlier post Please inform us if you find something, I for one would be interested.