Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Ferric acetate?

Posts

Ferric acetate?

#1

Ferric acetate?

John in NM

Messing with some vinegar and steel wool, looking for a solution that will give a nice caramel stain on maple. Does anyone have experience with this? Stephen must have refinished a musket or two over the years :D

Letting it sit overnight, I still have only a weak solution, but it ebonizes walnut very nicely when hit lightly with a torch. I'm tempted to try it on the maple, but I didn't bring any scrap to work with me, so there's no going back if it doesn't work well on the stock I have here.

I've also read of using ferric nitrate, I can order some as crystals if this first experiment doesn't pan out.

Re: Ferric acetate?

#2

Re: Ferric acetate?

Stuart Johnson

The old Foxfire series listed dissolving steel wool in nitric acid as a finish. The mixture is painted on then in the book hung over a forge to dry. I finished a gun stock with it but used a torch to dry. It came out a nice brown that has darkened over the years. I'm not certain what wood but I think it was hard maple. FWIW, I've been told this is a stain not a finish but I can tell you in use it has been water resistant.

If you are interested I can dig around and find the actual Foxfire description.

Re: Ferric acetate?

#3

Tint the oil?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Lee Valley sells Tru-oil, gunstock oil finish. Perhaps you could put a little tint in the oil?

Tom

Re: Ferric acetate?

#4

Yep, that is the nitrate stain...

John in NM

Its simply safer and a lot easier to purchase ferric nitrate crystals than to make them with acid and an iron source :D

Both stains react with tannins to produce the color, so I was wondering if anyone had tried ferric acetate on maple - quite likely lower tannin than walnut, and might provide the look I want.

The idea is indeed to get a Kentucky stock kind of look, though it is going on a more modern rifle - pale curly maple doesn't seem to be a popular look for a gunstock.

Stain will be followed with linseed oil or another kind of topcoat.

Thanks to you both for the input so far, I think I'll do some looking around the web to see about the nitrate stain for ebonizing walnut - that might answer my question in a backwards sort of way.

Re: Ferric acetate?

#5

Re: Tint the oil?

John in NM

I do sometimes warm up dull looking maple with some stain, though I don't like to resort to it. I've tried dying very thin shellac as a pre-coat to the finish, but it is still basically a film and can eventually wear through where the stock is handled a lot.

The dyes I have on hand are Transtint, I've never had a lot of luck getting them to go into oil. You can add a little acetone to do it, but then the oil doesn't cure nice and hard, at least not as quickly as I'm used to.

Usually I use Waterlox for a similar look to Tru-oil, more because I have it around than because its a better or worse product. Though I've been told they are very different types of finish, they sure do act the same in application and look similar to my eye.

Re: Ferric acetate?

#6

Found a picture...

John in NM

Showing the nitrate vs acetate color on curly maple. Or put in typical web terms, vinegar vs. aqua fortis (nitric acid)


I think I'll order up some of the ferric nitrate crystals, I like the color better.

Re: Ferric acetate?

#7

JL

Try getting some glacial acetic acid

JL

or something a bit more concentrated. Vinegar is only several percent acetic acid. You really need something a lot stronger to make the ferric acetate.

I'd find something at least in the 50% range or see if you can get some glacial (99% or so).

Re: Ferric acetate?

#8

Re: Increase the tannin

Stuart Johnson

Both stains react with tannins to produce the color, so I was wondering if anyone had tried ferric acetate on maple - quite likely lower tannin than walnut, and might provide the look I want.


Try making a strong tea and wiping the piece down to increase the tannin. This comes up from time to time on the turning board.

Re: Ferric acetate?

#9

There are some complications

Bill Tindall

If you dissolve iron in acetic acid the product will be Ferrous acetate, not ferric acetate. Because the color development involves reaction with lignin it could well be that ferrous will yield a different color than ferric. I would predict there would be a difference.

Exposure to air may convert the ferrous acetate to ferric; I am not sure.

The case with nitrate is harder to predict. Dissolving iron in nitric acid could yield either ferric or ferrous nitrate.

Bottom line-the only way to be sure what you are using is to buy some. Or dissolve some steel wool and try it.

Re: Ferric acetate?

#10

I would guess...

John in NM

That the ferrous ion does go to ferric with atmospheric oxygen, though perhaps not completely or immediately. I've noted two color descriptions using the acetate solution - greenish grey (I'm going to guess ferrous) and the orange/yellow color I'm looking for - ferric. My color guesses are based on similar behavior in minerals, so they could well be way off base.

Some sources suggest letting a preparation stand a week or more, so I have some steel wool soaking in a jar of vinegar, should be ready when I go home next week. I'm going to take a stab and say that standing for a week is both because vinegar is so weak, but also to allow time for oxidation of the ferrous ion.

I'm looking forward to having some scrap to mess with, I never have found a stain I consider acceptable for maple, but I've always liked those muskets - they simply don't look stained.

Re: Ferric acetate?

#11

No need for more tannin...

John in NM

I believe that would aid in ebonizing using either of these solutions, but that isn't what I'm looking for. Looking for a nice amber to brown shade on the maple, without the obvious stained or dyed look that conventional products yeild.

I think extra tannin alone would yeild a more yellow to amber shade, based on a birdseye stock I have that my father made in the 50's. He said he'd fished the log out of a pulp pond in Maine, and that they'd stopped running logs on the water years before, so it had been soaking a long time. Nice stagnant pond with lots of old bark in it - that is the most yellow piece of maple I've ever seen, looks like its stained, but without the muddy grain.

Re: Ferric acetate?

#12

Re: Ferric acetate?

R Payne

I have done this on silver maple with both fresh and aged vinegar/iron solution (I don't always use steel wool, I also blacksmith so have used the vinegar I soak the forge work in to descale it). When fresh it tends to have an off hue that could be described as greenish on maple, when aged it leaves what I would call a light to medium brown and a second coat will darken it some. The solutions I've mixed seem to stabilize so far as color is concerned after about 3 weeks, stored in an old mayonnaise jar (plastic lid).

On the maple, the color didn't appear as immediately as it does with walnut or oak, probably due to the lower tannin content so wait a day or two after applying the first coat to evaluate the results.

ron

Re: Ferric acetate?

#13

Thank you Ron

John in NM

Just the first hand info I was looking for, which also more or less lines up with what I'd suspected about aging the solution. Thanks!