Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Engineered Hardwood Flooring???

Posts

Engineered Hardwood Flooring???

#1

Engineered Hardwood Flooring???

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Ok...so I have a modern house that was built about 50 years ago. I want to replace the carpeting in the living room with wood. The subfloor is concrete....flat and stable.

I'm looking at either maple (light natural) or bamboo.

With a concrete base, the method will be glue down I think. So is engineered hardwood flooring the way to go? I want the wear surface to be real wood.

Advice would be appreciated!

Tom

Re: Engineered Hardwood Flooring???

#2

Re: Engineered Hardwood Flooring???

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Known two who have done this; one failed. The failure was with a straight glue-down, boards buckled and cupped. The other guy glued down a 1/2" ply underlayment over a sealed slab, then used short nails to fix the flooring.

Re: Engineered Hardwood Flooring???

#3

With concrete ...

Mike Farinella

you have another option: floating floor with vapor barrier. Just had it done at my other house and it looks great. I can't imagine gluing down a floor then trying to replace it years later. Ugh!

Re: Engineered Hardwood Flooring???

#4

Re: Engineered Hardwood Flooring???

McKay

We have a full sized gym in our church that used to have that nasty carpeting. It was replaced with maple gym type flooring. They used sleepers on center (don't know the center measurement, but I would assume 16" or 12"). These carpeted floors in over twenty churches were all replaced at least 5 years ago and the floors are still beautiful and stable. The floor was nailed to the sleepers as was tradition with most gym floors.

Re: Engineered Hardwood Flooring???

#5

I did it

paul in AZ

Or more accurately, a flooring pro did it last winter.

Be critical of your materials. Much of what is sold is crap. I bought engineered maple from Karelia.

It was a glue down install on concrete. Slab prep and moisture control are important. I didn't pay enough attention to the materials but it seems you can't just use any ol' stickum to glue the planks down to concrete. The glue they used was also a waterproofer and I don't recall if they also sealed the slab before gluing. Moisture is what murders these floors, even if you use a plywood subfloor.

Slab moisture is rarely a problem in my climate -dry as the proverbial popcorn fart- but could be a consideration where you live.

In a previous house up north I glued engineered wood to concrete and had no troubles.

The other option of floating over a vapor barrier and foam pad is OK if you are aware of what I consider it's only real problem. It will NEVER EVER sound or feel like a solid wood floor because it does bounce on the foam pad.

Re: Engineered Hardwood Flooring???

#6

bamboo addendum

paul in AZ

Careful about bamboo. Some is good and then... Once it became popular anyone in china with a few plants jumped into the market and there is some good stuff out there and a ton of garbage that will split, check, curl and do other bad things. I don't know how one identifies the better quality materials.

A flooring guy told me he'd guarantee bamboo until my check cleared.

Re: Engineered Hardwood Flooring???

#7

Re: Engineered Hardwood Flooring???

Tony - Memphis

We installed some in our breakfast room a few years ago. It was Pergo line that is no longer available (I don't think anyway). Our concrete foor had vinyl over it. We put the flooring over the vinyl. We did install the rolled cushion material as suggested. It went down easy and has held up very well. No issues at all. I enede up making my own transition pieces because the stuff they offered was actually vinyl covered MDF type material. To qualify, it is just my wife and I in the house. That section of floor gets a lot of our traffic though. I remove my shoes, but the wifey doesn't, so she tracks in a lot of yard debris. So, I would do it again (or add more if they still sold it). I guess they call our installation a floating floor. I simply removed the base shoe molding and put it back afterwards.

Tony

Re: Engineered Hardwood Flooring???

#8

Re: Engineered Hardwood Flooring??? *LINK*

Dick Coers

My coworker put down an engineered oak floor on concrete and bought a special vapor barrier product from Amazon. It is also available at Home Depot, but Amazon was cheaper. So far so good for him in Pekin, IL.


Roberts Air-guard

Re: Engineered Hardwood Flooring???

#9

Re: Engineered Hardwood Flooring???

NickinMass

A few thoughts:

Moisture coming through your slab is your biggest potential issue. Do a calcium chloride test to see how much of a problem you have. Alternately, you can put down a troweled on moisture barrier (but they are spendy, so I think it is worth doing the test to see if you need it).

I love the way bamboo looks (especially vertical grain), but I agree with the previous posters that you need to be careful of the quality. My impression is that the good stuff is just as expensive as hardwood.

Have you considered a floating installation isntead of glue down? If you do, and you do it yourself, make sure you have a deadblow mallet handy for snugging up the panels (learned that the hard way last summer - a regular hammer/mallet bounces and is not particularly effective).

I did a walk-in closet with engineered cork flooring (floating installation) - I don't think I'd recommend cork for a living room (its kind of soft and I'd be concerned about dings), but it looks great and feels fantastic under bare feet (and stays warm too, even over our unheated garage in Massachusetts). The floating installation worked out well too, although I still need to install some of the shoe molding...

Re: Engineered Hardwood Flooring???

#10

Thanks for the input folks!


Re: Engineered Hardwood Flooring???

#11

Re: Engineered Hardwood Flooring???

J Barrett Irby

Probably the first thing to do is a moisture test. Stick a piece of polyethylene a foot or more square done tot he floor with some good tape. Wait a day or two or even a week and see if it steams up on the slab side. If it does, you need to be careful and probably use a floating floor or a vapor barrier.

And you should acclimate the flooring really well before you install it. Spread it out in the space for a couple of weeks and let it adjust.

You can go to NOFMA for more info. (National Oak Flooring Manufacturers Association.)